Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
Τα υποκειμενικά και αντικειμενικά όρια της συμφωνίας περί διαιτησίας
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe doctoral thesis deals with the scope of the arbitration agreement ratione personae and ratione materiae. The first chapter analyses the subjects covered by the arbitration agreement, with an emphasis on the binding of third parties. Theory and jurisprudence are drawn from a variety of theories, which are not treated uniformly by the national legal orders, to establish the binding of non-signatories to the arbitration agreement. However, the extension of the arbitration agreement to third parties who did not agree to it requires the evaluation and assessment of all circumstances of the case at hand. Therefore, it is found that many theories on the extension of the subjective scope of the arbitration agreement are largely treated on a case-by-case basis. These theories are subject to criticism in the context of international and Greek theory and jurisprudence, as they create legal uncertainty and jeopardize the integrity of arbitration as an equal to litigation dispute resolution mechanism. This derives from the fact that state and arbitral courts cannot formulate different judicial judgments because they evaluate the same historical and legal basis differently. Furthermore, solutions are sought at the stage of drafting the arbitration agreement that can preserve the enforceability of arbitral awards. It is proposed to conclude a global arbitration agreement, which will refer to other, as well as future contracts that the parties will conclude with third parties, and which will help to prevent problems arising from the participation of non-signatories in the arbitral proceedings. In addition, the application of traditional theories concerning the binding of third parties to the arbitration agreement seems appropriate, as it contributes to predictability, whilst enhancing legal certainty and shielding the enforceability of arbitral awards. The second chapter of the doctoral thesis is devoted to the objective limits of the arbitration agreement. The study focuses on identifying the scope of disputes covered by the arbitration agreement and analyses the issue of arbitrability. The doctoral thesis deals with certain categories of disputes, which create various doctrinal and practical problems regarding their arbitrability both in Greek and other legal orders. However, recent international jurisprudence demonstrates that the former distrust of arbitration, which was manifested by the exclusion of a wide range of disputes from submission to arbitration, does no longer exist. In recent years, the categories of disputes that are considered arbitrable have expanded considerably, and judicial review of the conflict of arbitral awards with public policy rules at the enforcement stage has been established. In any case, it is crucial to address the question of arbitrability of certain disputes, as well as the question of the acceptance or not of the theories on the extension of the arbitration agreement to third parties, by the national courts of the country where annulment and/or enforcement of the arbitral award is sought. In particular, the arbitral tribunal must consider the risk of frustration of the recognition and enforcement of an arbitral award at the enforcement stage, as well as the impact on the arbitral institution itself.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2022
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Tsertsidou, Rafaila
- Τσερτσίδου, Ραφαήλα
Subjects
dc:subject × 13Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/52129