National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Μελέτη της αλκοολικής ζύμωσης με χρήση ζυμών non-Saccharomyces
Abstract
dc:descriptionBeer is a unique product with special sensory characteristics, which consists of four main ingredients: water, malt, hops and yeasts. The demand for mass production of beer has led to the selection and use of specific Saccharomyces strains, which may exhibit high efficiency, but limit the variation in metabolic pathways that could provide new and interesting sensory characters to the final product.With the rapid development of microbreweries on a global scale, brewers have tried to differentiate their products by choosing alternative malts and hops, with the ultimate goal being the enrichment of their products in aromas and flavors. One way to establish this goal is the selection of different yeasts, since their metabolism is one of the main factors that determine the sensory profile of beer. Originally known from the wine industry as spoilage microorganisms, non-Saccharomyces or "wild" yeasts, are now the main choice due to the aromatic and taste complexity they provide in the final product. Similar opinions, regarding the alteration of the final product, prevailed in the Brewing industry, although in some beer types, such as Lambic, their use is imperative even in mixed fermentations of different genera. Nowadays, there is a great deal of interest in the use of non-Saccharomyces in the brewing industry, which through various metabolic pathways, can produce a number of substances that affect and contribute to the aromatic profile.The purpose of this dissertation was to produce an innovative beers using non-Saccharomyces yeast strains, which would differentiate from the corresponding conventional products due to its aromatic complexity. In addition to the differentiated aromatic profile, it is essential for the used strain to metabolize the main sugars of wort (glucose, fructose and maltose) in order to produce ethanol. For this purpose, after literature review in studies conducted in wine fermentations, two non-Saccharomyces yeasts were selected, Torulaspora delbrueckii (T.d.) and Metschnikowia pulcherrima (M.p.) as alternative yeasts to Saccharomyces cerevisiae (S.c.). More specifically, two commercial strains of T. delbrueckii, 291 (Lallemand) and Prelude (Hansen), and a commercial strain of M. pulcherrima (Flavia MP346, Lallemand), were evaluated in comparison to a strain of S. cerevisiae (US-05, Fermentis by Lesaffre). The research focused on the evaluation of the ability of these strains to ferment the main sugars of the wort, to measure the produced ethanol, the consumption of free amino nitrogen and to investigate the effect of fermentation temperature on the kinetics of fermentation. Hence, the fermentations were conducted in two different temperatures, 13 and 20 °C, while the volatile compounds produced in each sugar were also studied. Based on the above, synthetic substrates of glucose, fructose, maltose and a mixture of the aforementioned sugars were produced in proportions corresponding to those of a typical wort (86% maltose, 9% glucose and 5% fructose) and fermented at 13 and 20 °C, in order to study the fermentation kinetics. Results showed that all studied strains are able to metabolize all sugars, producing a sufficient amount of ethanol and grew at both temperatures, but at a slower rate at 13 °C. Glucose intake was faster than fructose, for T. delbrueckii 291 at 20 °C, and for T. delbrueckii Prelude at 13 °C. Maltose showed a lower rate of consumption compared to monosaccharides, especially at lower temperature, without affecting the concentration of residual sugars. In T. delbrueckii 291 fermentation, a lag phase is observed during the metabolism of maltose, and also during its growth, which is due to the difficulty of this strain to activate the maltase enzyme. In M. pulcherrima, maltose is consumed more slowly compared to the two monosaccharides (glucose and fructose), with a lower metabolic rate and a slight delay in the beginning of fermentation.In the present study the Monod model was used due to its simplicity and ease of adaptation to the experimental data. The model is able to predict the biomass growth rate for conventional yeast and T. delbrueckii Prelude, as the experimental results of cell growth exhibited a satisfactory fit. However, it does not show a satisfactory fit for T. delbrueckii 291, especially at 13 °C. Generally, T. delbrueckii 291 presented the maximum specific growth rate in the two monosaccharides at 20 ° C, followed by the strain of M. pulcherrima. Similar results were observed at the lower studied temperature, with no significant difference in k-values. The maximum cell growth of all non-conventional yeasts was significantly higher (p <0.05) than that of S.c US-05 at all fermentable sugars and fermentation temperatures. Cell yield was found to be higher in T. delbrueckii 291 in the two monosaccharides. As for the mixed sugars fermentations, the maximum cell growth is observed at 20 °C in the fermentations of T. delbrueckii 291 and M. pulcherrima. At 13 °C, non-Saccharomyces show higher cell growth than S. cerevisiae US-05, as well.Temperature had a significant effect (p <0.05) on ethanol yield. More specifically, wild yeasts produced quantities of ethanol equal to or higher than the conventional yeast. In particular, at 13 ° C, the concentration of ethanol produced by M.pulcherrima (40 g/L) in maltose fermentation was significantly higher (p <0.05), surpassing the other yeasts. In contrast, at 20 ° C, a higher concentration was produced by S. cerevisiae US-05 (43 g / L).Additionally, the final concentration of free amino nitrogen was significantly different (p <0.05) between the studied strains and the fermentation temperatures. The greatest need for nitrogen was observed in M. pulcherrima at all sugars at both temperatures, while between T. delbrueckii strains, the consumption was higher for T. delbrueckii 291.The volatile compounds were affected by the fermentation temperature and the sugar used (p<0.05), while all strains produced higher alcohols, medium chain fatty acids and their corresponding esters in the fermentation of maltose and mixed sugars. More specifically, the two T. delbrueckii strains exhibited high values of phenylethyl alcohol, in different sugars each, T. delbrueckii 291 in maltose, while T. delbrueckii Prelude to the sugar mixture at 20 °C. Similar results are presented in the fermentations of M. pulcherrima, with the later exhibiting the highest values in fructose and mixed sugars substrate. At 13 °C, the wild strains showed higher concentrations of fatty acid esters than S. cerevisiae US-05, and at the same time, more esters were detected compared to 20 °C. According to the results of the GC-MS analysis, T. delbrueckii 291 produced the maximum concentrations at 20 °C, while T. delbrueckii Prelude at 13 °C. In terms of fermentation with M. pulcherrima, higher production of medium chain fatty acid esters was observed at lower temperature fermentation. As for the sugars, most of the esters were detected in the mixed sugars fermented by the two T. delbrueckii strains, while for M. pulcherrima in fructose.After the fermentation of the main sugars was ascertained, the production of an American Pale Ale type of beers with initial density values of 12.2±0.1 °P and pH 5.1. ±0.1 was conducted. In these experiments different beers were fermented with monocultures of the studied yeasts (S.c. US-05, T.d. 291, T.d. Prelude and M. p.), as well as with mixed cultures of conventional yeast with each strain of T. delbrueckii in a ratio of 1:10 and with M. pulcherrima in ratios of 1: 1 and 1:10, respectively, at 13 and 20 ° C. In particular, the ratio of 1:10 was chosen based on the literature review, as it has been found that S. cerevisiae and T. delbrueckii grow in parallel without competition, and can provide a very interesting aromatic profile with high percentages of ethanol. Regarding M. pulcherrima, it has not yet been tested in beer production, so it was considered useful to examine it in different proportions, as to, also, study in detail the fermentation kinetics, the competitiveness between the two microorganisms as well as the characteristics of the beers produced.Although the non-Saccharomyces yeasts showed lower fermentation rates than S. cerevisiae US-05, they were capable of producing American Pale Ale beer, both in mono- and mixed cultures at both temperatures (13 and 20 °C). Monoculture T. delbrueckii 291 had the slowest metabolic rate at both temperatures, presenting a similar lag phase observed in synthetic substrates fermentation. The consumption of FAN was rapid at low temperature for all non-Saccharomyces yeasts, as they were in need due to survival from the low fermentation temperature as well as the stress of disaccharide. Regarding the M. pulcherrima fermentations, at 20 °C, the ratio 1:1, showed a similar metabolic rate to the conventional yeast, indicating that in this mixed fermentation S. cerevisiae US-05 prevailed.The mixed fermentations of non-conventional yeasts produced similar ethanol concentration to S. cerevisiae US-05, especially at 20 °C. The only exemption was the mixed fermentation of T. delbrueckii Prelude, whose ethanol production (5.40 ± 0.10% ABV) significantly exceeded (p <0.05) S. cerevisiae US-05. The monocultures produced lower ethanol at both temperatures. In addition, the color and bitterness of the produced beers were measured at the end of the fermentation, as well as after a period of 30 days. After this period, it was observed that flocculation was greater in mixed fermentations than monocultures due to the presence of S. cerevisiae US-05. Among the strains examined, the monocultures of T. delbrueckii showed higher values in color, compared to M. pulcherrima, while the values in bitterness did not show significant difference in most fermentations.In terms of flavor produced, the mixed fermentation of T. delbrueckii 291 presented the most aromatic profile at low fermentation temperature, with more fruity notes and floral aromas, while T. delbrueckii Prelude demonstrated that at 20 °C. Regarding the M. pulcherrima strain, monoculture was significantly different (p<0.05) from S. cerevisiae US-05, especially at higher temperature, presenting a promising sensory profile, as it can enhance the beer with more fruity, but also phenolic notes, since in the case of this strain, the highest concentration of 2-methoxy-4-vinyl-guaiacol was detected.Finally, all the beers produced, unfiltered and unsterilized, were aged in a custom chamber at 13 °C for two years. At specific time intervals (1 month, 6 months, 1 and 2 years) samples were collected to study the evolution of aromatic compounds during ageing. In general, no off-flavor compound, such as the characteristic trans-2-nonenal, was detected but the beers were altered aromatically. The volatile compounds produced at 13 °C increased only during the yeast autolysis, with no ageing compounds detected. In contrast, at 20 °C fermentations, the changes were significant (p <0.05), especially for the mono- and mixed fermentation of T. delbrueckii 291. In M. pulcherrima fermentations, most significant changes were shown in monoculture, while the two examined ratios in mixed cultures fermentations did not differ. Changes in volatile compounds in S. cerevisiae US-05 were observed at 20 °C fermentation, with a significant increase in higher alcohols as well as in medium chain fatty acid esters. At low temperature, hydrolysis of esters was observed in all beers, which may have been the main reason for the loss of the fruity character during storage. In general, in wild fermentations, fruity as well as flower aromas were transformed into aromas of stone fruits, such as apricot and peach, as well as caramel, which is attributed to the increase of ethyl esters and the detection of new volatiles, i.e. lactones. To conclude with, the studied wild yeasts are able to produce innovative beer products with unique sensory characteristics, and, therefore, they present a viable solution when microbreweries want to differ based on the sensory characters of their products.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
- Year dc:date
- 2022
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Drosou, Foteini
- Δρόσου, Φωτεινή
Subjects
dc:subject × 14Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/52337