University of Thessaly (UTH)
Modeling the impact of transit quality of service on user mode and route choices
Abstract
dc:descriptionAccording to the international bibliography, travelers follow a personal optimal strategy on their path; minimizing, at each decision node (i.e. a transit stop), the perceived travel cost. This travel cost is not necessarily economic but refers to a generalized cost for their trip that is differs from traveler to traveler. Minimizing this may refer: to the minimum number of transfers for the elderly, to the shortest path for trips made to work, to the route crossing the greater number of attractions for a tourist and so on. This cost is associated with the socio-economic characteristics of the users and the preferences / conditions of travel along with a list of quality related indicators. This PhD dissertation mainly aims at answering the following research question: "Which Quality of Service indicators affect, and how they affect, transit mode and route choices of travelers?", in order to identify the quality conditions that are attractive to the users. In this way, by offering the desired quality conditions, it is supported the creation of a viable urban mass transport network that, under proper management, will have competitive lines and networks and will contribute to urban deprivation that exists from massive private cars usage.In the context of this PhD, an extended state of the art review of the international bibliography was carried out, focusing on the two main topics examined in the present study, transit assignment (models, methodologies) and quality of service (models, methodologies, impacts). Based on the quality models reviewed and the gaps and needs identified for their exploitation and adaptation to the transit services, a conceptual model was proposed focusing on the analysis of these needs, underlining at the same time the quality deficiencies in the transit system. Five (5) transit quality GAPs were identified based on the diffences between: user’s importance and performance (GAP1); operator’s importance and performance (GAP2); operator’s estimation of user’s performance and actual user’s performance (GAP3), users’ importance and operators’ importance (GAP4) and operators’ importance and performance (GAP5).As a next step, and following a review on quality indicators, 26 quality indicators were selected to be futher analysed in terms of their importance and performance from both users and operators. These 26 indicators were grouped under 11 indicator categories that deal with: route characteristics, service characteristics, service reliability, comfort, cleanliness, fare, information, safety and security, personnel, customer services and environmental protection. The first research activity took place by conducting a survey aiming to measure the 5 quality GAPs between transit users and operators. This survey run in parallel for users and operators addressing both views and collecting their feedback for transit operations of three major Greek cities (Athens, Thessaloniki and Volos).A decision tree was developed to point out the relations among quality indicators performance and importance ratings as well as travelers socioeconomic and mobility characteristics on the service overall quality evaluation. This way the key quality indicators per user cluster were identified. The tree developed shows that for achiving the best possible evaluation by users, there are certain requirements for both importance and performance evaluations of a short list of indicators that deal with service frequency, cleanliness of bus interior, availiability of information by phone/mail and safety and security levels.The survey findings indicate that the quality required for the PT system in order to be acceptable is generally higher than the quality recognized by users and operators. The degree of satisfaction from the quality indicators tested is different for each indicator between service operators and users.As a next step and in order to investigate the relationship between user’s satisfaction and their intentions to use the service, a second research activity was conducted. This time, the pilot site was a typical medium-sized Greek city, the city of Volos. This survey was carried out in the context of the recording of city residents' trips on a typical working day, where, citizens were asked to state their level of satisfaction from transit services along with their intention to use/use more the service after quality improvements. Based on the findings of the second research activity as well as on the knowledge gained from the first research activity, the key quality indicators identified from the decision tree developed, were used to further experiments. Therefore, considering these indicators and in order to examine the quality impact on route and mode change decisions of travelers, a list of information scenarios were developed to be further tested in the third focused research activity. This research activity was conducted in the city of Thessaloniki, stimulating the behavior of OASTH’s bus line 3 users (Neos Sidirodromikos Stathmos-IKEA) under these scenarios. This research activity points out the importance of quality factors by modelling their impact on transit user’s decisions to change route or mode.Findings of this PhD thesis constitute an innovative and potentially useful management tool and reference framework for the sustainability of transit services, offering proper guidance for optimizing decision making of managers and operators.The model developed in the framework of the present thesis, can dynamically predict at any point and quality conditions examined, user’s decision to stay on board or alight the bus. It has been proved to be an accurate and reliable tool able to support operators on increasing the level of user satisfaction (existing and potential) and bring more users to the service.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Thessaly (UTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2019
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Tsami, Maria
- Τσάμη, Μαρία
Subjects
dc:subject × 11- Μέσα μαζικής μεταφοράς
- Μοντελοποίηση επίδρασης ποιότητας υπηρεσιών
- transit quality of service
- Public transportation
- Decision trees
- Επιστήμη Πολιτικού Μηχανικού
- Επιστήμες Μηχανικού και Τεχνολογία
- Επιστήμη και Τεχνολογία των μεταφορών
- Civil Engineering
- Engineering and Technology
- Transportation science and Technology
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/52804