Back to search

University of Thessaly (UTH)

Methods for modelling the water - energy - food nexus and other environmental systems towards resilience and sustainability

Abstract

dc:description

This dissertation explores the potential of Nexus analysis under the frame of advanced clustering algorithms and system dynamics modeling, to enhance water security at all levels (household-, city-, and national-level) thus contributing to environmental security. When considering the Water-Energy-Food (WEF) nexus and in an effort to identify which sector affects the most the other sectors (most influential) and which sector is affected the most (most vulnerable), other studies (Laspidou et al., 2019) indicate that the Water sector is the most vulnerable one. To this end— efficient water uses through data science, technologies and efficient systems—clustering algorithms and specifically Self-Organizing Maps (SOM), K-means (KM) and Hierarchical Agglomerative Clustering (HAC) are implemented in matlab and RStudio to detect water consumption patterns at household and consumer level, using different features of the population each time to feed the algorithms. Moreover, a water-energy nexus analysis is conducted quantifying the water-energy nexus at the city level. Then the Greek WEF Nexus system under climate change is simulated using system dynamics modeling implemented in Stella Architect. Next, a system resilience analysis is applied to the same model to examine which proposed policy makes the system more resilient in terms of the size of the disturbance it can absorb and how quickly it recovers to its initial state. Finally, an analysis in terms of quantifying the impact of WEF nexus as a multi-dimensional approach on the 17 Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) is conducted, aiming to promote integrating planning and policymaking.In this dissertation, we use several datasets that come from various research projects. The datasets are the following:1)Water consumption from a single household in Sosnowiec, Poland in various locations, such as kitchen, bathroom sink, shower/bathtub, toilet flushing, dishwasher and washing machine; data had a granularity of 30 sec. This data set came from the EU project ISS-EWATUS. 2)Total household water consumption for Milford, Ohio, USA, for 10 households. Temporal data granularity is not constant here, since there was a recording every time a water use "incident" happened, e.g. every time a faucet was used in the household. This dataset was provided to us via a research collaboration with Prof. Enrico Creaco (Buchberger et al., 2003).3)Total water consumption for the island of Skiathos, Greece. This dataset came from the Skiathos Water Utility and represents daily amounts of treated water supplied to households and businesses in Skiathos, with a resolution of one value per day. This dataset came from the EU project ISS-EWATUS.4)Electricity consumption for the island of Skiathos, Greece divided in 3 uses--domestic, agricultural and commercial--in a monthly time step for 6 years (2010 to 2015). This dataset came from the Public Power Company of Greece.5)An extensive national level dataset for Greece divided in its 14 River Basin Districts for Water, Energy, Food, Land Use and Climate. The time step is monthly for the year 2010. This dataset came from the SIM4NEXUS project, and it is publicly available at: Mellios and Laspidou, 2020.The structure of this dissertation is described as follows:Chapter 2 focuses on how the daily household water consumption can be clustered aiming at water security at household level. Household water consumptions can be grouped into days of the week through specific population characteristics. The features used to discretize the days of water consumption are statistic metrics and (half-hourly) consumption time zone consumption metrics. The time zoning is realized in two ways, the first being the typical morning, noon, afternoon, evening and night and the second considering the local working hour time zones. For the analysis, the SOM algorithm is implemented, using some of the selected features. The outcome of this analysis was the self-organization of the Sosnowiec data into groups (clusters) with specific characteristics that essentially differentiate the water consumption of the household on weekdays and weekends. So, the algorithm manages to detect clear consumption patterns, grouping the weekday data (Monday to Friday) into a separate group from that of the weekends.In chapter 3, an analysis of urban water consumption patterns at consumer level and the estimation of the corresponding water demand for water utility is presented. This study proposes a comprehensive methodology for water managers to achieve an efficient operation of urban water networks, by successfully detecting residential water consumption patterns corresponding to different household needs and behaviors. The methodology uses SOM as the main clustering algorithm in combination with KM and HAC. The objective is to create clusters in a literature dataset that includes water consumption by customer-users. Originally, water consumption data was recorded for every water use incident in the household, while for this analysis, the information is converted to half-hourly water consumption. The consumptions refer to households in Ohio, USA. Individual customers with similar consumption behavior are clustered and water-consumption curves are calculated for each cluster; these curves can be used by the water utility to obtain estimates of the spatiotemporal distribution of demand, thus giving insight into peak demands at different locations. Statistical indices of agreement are used to confirm a good agreement between the estimated and observed water use, when clustering is employed. The resulting curves show a clear improvement in capturing water consumption behavior at household level, when compared to corresponding curves obtained without clustering. This analysis offers residents, water managers, water utilities, and policy makers an innovative solution relying on real time data and using data science principles for optimizing water supply and network operation by successfully detecting residential water consumption patterns corresponding to different residential needs and behaviors.In chapter 4, a water–energy nexus analysis is conducted in order to achieve a sustainable supply and effectively manage water and energy at city level. Different electricity uses such as domestic, agricultural and commercial are compared and tested on how they correlate with water use. Specifically, time series of water and energy consumption for the island of Skiathos are analyzed using specific distance metrics. The results of the analysis show that water and energy are intimately related. Therefore, domestic electricity use does not correlate with water use. This isolated case is due to the fact that the water on the island of Skiathos is characterized by a high mercury content, thus making the water not eligible for drinking, so its domestic use is limited. Chapter 5 highlights that climate change impacts the water–energy–food security; given the complexities of interlinkages in the nexus system, these effects may become exacerbated when feedback loops magnify detrimental effects and create vicious cycles. Resilience is understood as the system’s adaptive ability to maintain its functionality even when the system is being affected by a disturbance or shock; in WEF nexus systems, climate change impacts are considered disturbances/shocks and may affect the system in different ways, depending on its resilience. Future global challenges will severely affect all vital resources and threaten environmental resilience. In this article, we present a resilience analysis framework for a water–energy–food nexus system under climate change, and we identify how such systems can become more resilient with the implementation of policies. We showcase results in the national case study of Greece. Parametric sensitivity analysis for socio-ecological systems is performed to identify which parameter the model is the most sensitive to. The case study is based on the structure of a system dynamics model that maps sector-specific data from major national and international databases while causal loop diagrams and stock-and-flow diagrams are presented. Through engineering and ecological resilience metrics, we quantify system resilience and identify which policy renders the system more resilient in terms of how much perturbation it can absorb and how fast it bounces back to its original state, if at all. Two policies are tested, and the framework is implemented to identify which policy is the most beneficial for the system in terms of resilience.Finally, chapter 6 focuses on the cross-mapping of important interactions between Water-Energy-Food nexus indices and the SDGs. Worldwide, many developing countries are making efforts to achieve sustainability through the 17 SDGs and at the same time to contribute to environmental security. The Water-Energy-Food (WEF) nexus aims to enhance this effort through an integrated, multi-disciplinary and multi-domain approach providing a better understanding of the interactions among the Goals, both at and across different scales, to promote equitable access to resources, human wellbeing, and ecological integrity. The Nexus approach will support the implementation of the SDGs especially SDG 2 (Food), SDG 6 (Water), and SDG 7 (Energy), but also most SDGs have elements linked to food, water, and energy in one or more ways, and will benefit from a Nexus approach. The SDGs are designed to be cross-cutting and to be implemented together, which is also reflected in a WEF Nexus approach. In this article, we explore the influence of the WEF nexus on the SDGs by assessing the impact of Water-Energy-Food—the three WEF nexus components—on specific SDG targets by providing scores via a 7-point rating scheme. The goal is to help policymakers to create coherent policies and strategies through a systemic analysis of the many interactions by identifying synergetic or antagonistic effects of WEF nexus policies with the SDGs. Results are showcased through advanced visualization tools that cross-map the WEF nexus on the SDGs to reveal the complex and possibly obscure inter-relationships of the resource nexus with the 17 SDGs. Finally, a Fuzzy Cognitive Map analysis is conducted on the scores in order to identify the most “influential” and most “influenced by” SDGs analyzing the causality in this complex system of positive and negative interlinkages. Through this analysis, specific SDGs are indicated as the most influenced by the WEF nexus, revealing either synergies or trade-offs, while other SDGs are identified as having little interaction with the WEF nexus system.The novelty of this dissertation relies firstly on a detailed pattern analysis using the SOM algorithm. Daily patterns of water consumption at household level are identified by using specific population characteristics leading to the creation of clusters. An innovative solution for water utilities is proposed, based on real time data and using data science principles to optimize water supply to customers and network operation. Two combined algorithms—Self-Organizing Maps (SOM) – K-Means (KM) and Self-Organizing Maps (SOM) – Hierarchical Agglomerative Clustering (HAC)—were developed to create clusters that include customer water consumption. Then a Water-Energy nexus analysis is performed at the city level in order to quantify their correlation and a WEF nexus approach under climate change combined with systemic resilience and parametric sensitivity analysis at national level is also presented. To simulate and model the Nexus for this analysis, System Dynamics Modelling is used. In this dissertation, the influence of the WEF nexus on the SDGs is also explored, by using Fuzzy Cognitive Maps analysis.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of Thessaly (UTH)
Year dc:date
2022

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Ioannou, Alexandra
  • Ιωάννου, Αλεξάνδρα

Subjects

dc:subject × 21

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/52805

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Ioannou, Alexandra; Ιωάννου, Αλεξάνδρα. Methods for modelling the water - energy - food nexus and other environmental systems towards resilience and sustainability. University of Thessaly (UTH), 2022. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/52805