Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
Διερεύνηση ψυχοπαθολογίας και ψυχοκοινωνικών παραγόντων σε πληθυσμό κρατουμένων ελληνικής φυλακής με ιστορικό εξάρτησης
Abstract
dc:descriptionMental health problems are the most common cause of morbidity in prisons, which poses a major challenge for their management. Prisoners in low- and middle-income countries appeared to have a higher rate of mental disorders than in the general population and the same was true in high-income countries.The prevention of substance abuse in Greece is mainly implemented by the nationwide network of 75 Prevention Centres that operate in the framework of the cooperation of OKANA with the Local Government and local bodies (covering 50 of the 51 prefectures of the country), the Ministry of Education and Religions, as well as by other governmental or non-governmental bodies. There are currently a total of 11,011 prisoners in the 33 Greek prisons. In 2018, within the prison environment, nine treatment programs implemented interventions in a total of 18 prisons and a total of 2,002 detainees for drug related charges, of which 77 completed their follow-up and joined a treatment program outside the penitentiary, terminating their detention on parole or suspension. In addition, a total of 524 detainees received in-prison treatment services. Outside the prison environment, in the two counselling centres that operate for released users, a total of 149 people received counselling services, while in the 3 treatment programs that operate in the country for the same category of people, this number rose to 123 people. Finally, the total number of people who received the services of social reintegration centres for prisoners was 46.Cannabis is the most widespread substance amongst prisoners in Greece, with many having a history of drug use and being addicted to a combination of drugs. The incidence of mental disorders in Greek prisoners is higher than in the general population. The most common type of mental disorder is personality disorder, which was the only psychiatric diagnosis associated with violent crime. This highlights the need for screening for mental disorders and for providing therapeutic care in the prison environment. A previous study of a Greek prison population found that 27.5% of prisoners were addicted to opiates, 26.3% to alcohol, 73.8% admitted to using cannabis and 13.8% abused both drugs and alcohol. The same study investigated the association between a history of substance abuse before incarceration and mental illness. It was revealed that 31.2% of these detainees had depression.There is limited information about dependences for substances and none for alcohol and related medical conditions in the Greek prison system. This prospective study aims to report on the prevalence of depression and the psychosocial factors that affect it, in a sample of Greek prisoners with a history of substance and alcohol abuse as well as report on their anxiety levels while incarcerated.The study includes 100 male prisoners with a history of substance and/or alcohol abuse in the Grevena Correctional Facility, Northern Greece. The BDI AUDIT, DUDIT, CAGE, STAI Y-1 and Y-2 and SCL-90R were used. Linear regression was used to identify independent predictors for each of the questionnaire scores, using the parameters identified by Kruscal-Wallis and Spearman's rho tests, adjusting for age.The study participants were incarcerated in the correctional facility of Grevena, Greece, and have a recorded medical history of dependence; the participation in the research was voluntary and the subjects were literate in Greek, regardless of citizenship and nationality. Other inclusion criteria were that they had at least a conviction on drug related offences, regardless of whether it was a drug law offence of use or personal possession, or supply or trafficking or a combination, as described by Greek national and E.U. law definitions, regardless of being the current reason for imprisonment. The research had received the full approval of the correctional facility of Grevena administration, with respect to the 2016/679 (E.U.- 1, 2016) and the 2016/680 (E.U. – 2, 2016) E.U. Data Protection Act. The study has been approved by Aristotle University of Thessaloniki Bioethics Committee (1395/20/10/2020). In order to comply with these directives, the participant prisoners were volunteers and acknowledged the use of their data for the study’s purposes only.Demographic data were collected prior to the presentation of the questionnaires to the prisoners. Translated and validated versions of the questionnaires BDI (Beck Depression Inventory) 10, 11, AUDIT (Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test) 12, DUDIT (Drug Use Disorders Identification Test) 12 CAGE 13 as well as the self-report Spielberger State Trait Anxiety Scale (STAI Y-1 and Y-2) questionnaires for the diagnosis of state and trait anxiety, 14, 15 standardized for the Greek population 16 were presented to the prisoners. Prisoners also filled the Symptom Checklist-90-R (SCL-90R), a self-administered scale measuring subjective complaints and symptomatic behaviour of patients in several dimensions of psychopathology. Statistical analysis was carried out with the SPSS v.26 software. All continuous data were presented as mean and standard deviation (SD), whereas all categorical variables were expressed as counts and percentages. Shapiro-Wilk Test for normality deemed all data to be non-parametric thus, only non-parametric statistical test were used. Group differences were tested using Wilcoxon or, Mann–Whitney test for continuous measures, Kruscal-Wallis H test for two or more groups of an independent variable on a continuous or ordinal dependent variable. Univariate analysis was carried out to clarify the impact of demographic characteristics. Statistically significant variables were included in multivariable regression. Linear regression using stratified bootstrapping to account for the non-parametric nature of the data was used to identify independent predictors.One hundred inmates who met the inclusion criteria, out of 600 inmates in the Grevena prison, with a history of substance abuse were included in the study, 81 were currently incarcerated for drug-related offences and 19 for sexual offences (rape, statutory rape) with previous drug convictions and agreed to participate. Mean age was 38.5 years old (±11.7SD) with age groups evenly split: 26% below 30 years old, 28% 31-40 years old, 21% 41-50 years old, while there was a similar 24% of older prisoners above the age of 50 years old. The vast majority (63%) stated that they had mental health problems and that they were on medication. Currently, 37% are on antidepressants, 16% are on anxiety medication, and 7% on antipsychotic medication, while 34% stated they are not on medication and 6% that they had stopped taking medication. A grand majority of 79% had mild to severe depression (p<0.001), while 68% had an anxiety disorder (STAI-Y2) (p=0.001). 45% of the sample had both moderate to high anxiety disorder and mild to severe depression symptoms (p<0.01). They were found to be dependent (DUDIT), in custody, 59% on substances and 40% on alcohol, with 37% of the total being dependent on both at the same time. 72% were found to have a high range of SCL-90-R psychopathological symptoms (p<0.001). In contrast, only 11% had an extroverted personality trait according to Eysenck E (p<0.001). 30% had neuroticism characteristics (p<0.001). The mean questionnaire scores were BDI 20.56 (±12.9SD), AUDIT 11.59 (±11.05SD), DUDIT 15.08 (±14.9SD), CAGE 1.36 (±1.2SD), STAI Y-1 score was 45.25/80 (SD 14.46), while STAI-2 score was 45.24/80 (SD 14.16), the mean Global Severity Index for the SCL-90 was 1.11 (SD 0.76). Statistical analysis showed that several demographic categories had statistically different questionnaire scores. Of note, BDI scores differed statistically significantly between very low and very high school performance (p=0.05). Another category with differences for the BDI was family history, where inmates with sibling problems had significantly higher scores than inmates without sibling-related problems (p=0.042). Parental relationships also influence BDI scores, with prisoners with poor and moderate relationships having significantly higher BDI scores than prisoners who reported having excellent relationships (p=0.028 and 0.004, respectively). DUDIT scores differed statistically significantly between the no problems and the group with problems with theft, violence and substance abuse, with the latter having the highest scores (p = 0.001). Parental relationships also affected DUDIT scores, with prisoners with mediocre relationships having much higher scores than prisoners who reported having excellent relationships (p = 0.034). AUDIT scores followed a similar pattern and differed statistically significantly between the behaviourally unproblematic and the theft, violence, and substance abuse problem groups, with the latter having the highest scores (p = 0.001). Parental relationships affected DUDIT scores, as prisoners with mediocre relationships had much higher BDI scores than prisoners who reported having excellent relationships (p = 0.034); on the other hand, CAGE differed statistically significantly only by school performance, with prisoners with very good performance showing the lowest scores compared to prisoners with very low and good performance (p = 0.05 and 0.044, respectively). Parental relationships were the main influence on the STAI Y-1 and 2 questionnaires completed together. On the STAI Y-1, prisoners with poor and moderate parental relationships had much higher scores than prisoners who reported having excellent parental relationships (p = 0.04 and 0.022, respectively). Similarly for the SCL-90 questionnaire, prisoners with mediocre relationships had much higher scores than prisoners who reported having excellent relationships with their parents (p = 0.048).ConclusionsPrisoners have higher anxiety levels, in Greece, than the general population. Higher self-reported SCL-90R scores, increased medication while incarcerated were positive independent score predictors for state anxiety, while childhood family living standards was also a strong negative independent predictor for trait anxiety along with the other two. Anxiety management interventions are needed especially for these prisoners, with exercise intervention being a good initial step 27 but regular monitoring and better mental health strategies are de facto needed to be adopted in the Greek correctional system in general. The need to psychologically evaluate prisoners, not only when they enter the correctional facility, but also at different times during their detention is considered imperative. Diagnosis and treatment of mental illness in prisons could potentially have a positive effect on prisoners' quality of life, their reintegration into society, and the reduction of recidivism for mental illness-related offenses. We believe that stress management interventions are required specifically for these detainees, with specialized practice interventions, but regular monitoring and better mental health strategies should in fact be adopted in the Greek penitentiary system in general. Our sample included only male prisoners, as the Grevena facility is an all-male correctional institution. This is an important issue, which illustrates a limitation of our study and all Greek studies so far, at the extent that they focus on male prisoners only. Moreover, a larger sample population would have been better, but this was due the focused nature of the sample that included only prisoners with a history of dependence in a single facility. As the data was collected by the visiting psychiatrist in the course of normal clinical appointments providing a service to prisoners, there is a possibility that prisoner felt coerced to participate, even though every step was taken to ensure otherwise, but it is only fair to mention it here as a potential limitation of the study.To conclude, the prevalence of depression among Greek prisoners who have a history of dependence in either drugs or alcohol is much higher than in the general population in Greece and even between other prisoner groups. School behaviour, performance and level of parental relationship were the independent factors associated with depression and alcohol and drug abuse as measured by BDI AUDIT alcohol and DUDIT. CAGE did not show strong effectors in contrast to AUDIT. Higher self-reported SCL-90R scores and increased medication while incarcerated were positive independent score predictors for state anxiety. For trait anxiety, childhood family living standards was also an additional strong negative independent predictor anxiety. This is the newest study in Greek prisons and the only one concerning an inmate population with history of dependence. Therefore, its conclusion of higher than before prevalence of depression should be considered for diagnosis and therapy strategies in prison. Furthermore, anxiety management interventions are needed especially for these prisoners, with exercise intervention being a good initial step 27 but regular monitoring and better mental health strategies are de facto needed to be adopted in the Greek correctional system in general. We hope that more research will shed even more light into mental illness in prison and its treatment.Key words: depression; anxiety; substance abuse; prisoners; mental health; prison psychiatry
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2022
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Papathanasiou, Nestoras
- Παπαθανασίου, Νέστορας
Subjects
dc:subject × 18- Κατάθλιψη
- Άγχος
- Κατάχρηση ουσιών
- Κρατούμενοι φυλακών
- Ψυχική υγεία
- Ψυχιατρική των φυλακών
- Depression
- Anxiety
- Substance abuse
- Adult prisoners
- Mental health
- Prison psychiatry
- Κλινική Ιατρική
- Ιατρική και Επιστήμες Υγείας
- Ψυχιατρική και Ψυχική υγεία
- Clinical Medicine
- Medical and Health Sciences
- Psychiatry and Mental Health
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/52870