Back to search

University of Thessaly (UTH)

Supplier policies under service-dependent buyer demand: ordering, competition, and buyer selection

Abstract

dc:description

This thesis deals with dynamic supplier policies under service-dependent demand. The thesis is structured in three parts. Part 1 explores optimal dynamic inventory policies when buyer purchase incidence is driven by past service, Part 2 looks at supplier competition and cooperation for buyer loyalty on service, and Part 3 tackles dynamic ordering and buyer selection when service affects future demand. A summary of each part follows. Part 1. A buyer exposed to a stockout may lose goodwill and be less inclined to select the same supplier in his next procurement. Reversely, an in-stock experience may restore the supplier’s prospect of being selected in the future. What should the supplier’s inventory control policy be in this situation? To address this question, we develop a multiperiod model of a buyer who selects a supplier with a probability that depends on the supplier’s rating. This rating reflects the buyer’s goodwill towards the supplier based on past service, measured in terms of in-stock/out-of-stock incidents, and is updated by the buyer after each service. The supplier’s optimal inventory policy partitions the inventory space in order-up-to and do-not-order intervals for each rating. The optimal decision depends on whether ordering reduces the supplier’s risk of being downgraded enough to offset the increase in her ordering and inventory costs. We derive and evaluate bounds on the optimal policy and expose some of its properties. We obtain conditions for the optimality of basestock policies and show that such policies are optimal if there are only two ratings or if the buyer’s demand is constant. Using our model, we impute the stockout cost in a newsvendor setting. Numerical experiments suggest that (i) the supplier may benefit from holding more inventory in intermediate than in extreme ratings, and from dealing with a buyer who responds less erratically to service, (ii) basestock policies are efficient, and (iii) using an arbitrary stockout cost in the newsvendor setting can significantly hurt profits. Part 2. A firm’s service-driven always-a-share behavior may have a significant effect on the competitive and cooperative inventory policies of its suppliers. To explore this effect, we consider a model of a repeat buyer (she) sharing her patronage among two heterogeneous newsvendor-type suppliers over an infinite horizon. To enjoy the best service advantage, the buyer plays one supplier (him) against the other by rewarding product availability with repurchase (loyalty) and punishing stockouts with switching (disloyalty) in the next period. Faced with this behavior, the optimal ordering policy of each supplier is a basestock policy with a non-negative “active” basestock level when the supplier has the buyer’s loyalty and a zero basestock level when he does not. Under competition, the optimal active basestock level of each supplier is greater than his myopic basestock level and increases in the other supplier’s active basestock level. Under a mild condition, the active basestock levels of both suppliers have at least one pure-strategy Nash equilibrium solution. If the suppliers cooperate, the optimal active basestock level of the supplier with the highest/lowest myopic profit is greater/smaller than his myopic basestock level. To better comprehend these results, we apply them to the case where the buyer’s demand is exponentially distributed. This allows us to obtain exact expressions for the optimal active basestock levels and payoff functions, which we then use in a numerical sensitivity analysis. We conclude with a discussion of the extension of the results to more than two suppliers. Part 3. Make-to-stock suppliers with regular buyers must balance the cost of overstocking against the cost arising from the buyers’ reactions when items are unavailable. In selecting which buyers to satisfy when shortages occur, they must weigh the current revenue from the satisfied buyers against the loss in future demand from the dissatisfied buyers. To provide insight and decision support on these trade-offs, (i) we develop a novel newsvendor model of a firm with heterogeneous buyers with service-dependent demand, (ii) we provide properties of the optimal ordering and buyer selection decisions of the firm, and (iii) we derive a novel Lagrangian Relaxation(LR)-based index policy for selecting buyers and compare it with two otherLR-based index policies. The model concerns a firm that orders items for a group of repeat buyers who generate different revenues and visit the firm with different average rates that depend on whether they are satisfied or dissatisfied with their last visit. The firm selects which buyers to serve if the demand exceeds the order quantity (current capacity). For two buyers, we show that a fixed order quantity (FOQ) policy and an index buyer selection policy are optimal. For more buyers, the optimal policy involves overstocking (understocking) when the overall buyer satisfaction is high(low) and selecting buyers that maximize the current revenue (future demand) when the overall buyer satisfaction after the demand is high (low). To tackle the problem, we derive three LR-based index policies: a Lagrangian index policy that uses a uniform capacity price, a Whittle index policy that uses a discriminatory capacity price and is myopically optimal, and a novel active-constraint index policy that uses a discriminatory capacity price when the capacity constraint is active. Numerical results indicate that the latter policy is near-optimal and outperforms the other two and that combining it with the right FOQ policy can be very efficient.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of Thessaly (UTH)
Year dc:date
2022

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Deligiannis, Michail
  • Δεληγιάννης, Μιχαήλ

Subjects

dc:subject × 22

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/53008

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Deligiannis, Michail; Δεληγιάννης, Μιχαήλ. Supplier policies under service-dependent buyer demand: ordering, competition, and buyer selection. University of Thessaly (UTH), 2022. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/53008