Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
The written Greek Adolescent English as a Foreign Language corpus: an analysis of argument construction
Abstract
dc:descriptionWriting is a complex skill that poses considerable difficulty to both first and second language writers. Second language writing research has focused on university level students leaving the area of adolescent second language writing severely underdeveloped. The present study addresses this research gap by examining the argumentative writing of Greek students, aged 12-16, in English as a Foreign Language (EFL). The participants, 353 Greek adolescent students completed the Quick Oxford Placement Test (UCLES, 2001), a brief questionnaire, and wrote essays on controversial topics. Students’ handwritten essays were transcribed and saved as word documents and a learner corpus of 100,000 words (507 essays in total) was compiled (GAEFL). The study primarily aims to map the territory of Greek adolescent EFL learners’ argumentative writing performance in terms of the overall quality of arguments as well as the use of the argument elements of thesis, data, warrant, and rebuttal, looking at the same time into factors that might affect argument construction. It also aims at exploring students’ thesis position rhetorical preferences and use of opinion markers in the thesis clause. More specifically, the research questions of the study are: What is the argumentative writing profile of adolescent Greek EFL learners in terms of a) thesis position and use of opinion markers in the thesis clause, b) the production of the argument elements of thesis, data, warrant, rebuttal, and c) the overall quality of their arguments? Do the factors of age, English language proficiency level, type of essay prompt, thesis position, use of suggestions/ solutions, and learning a second foreign language affect the production of the overall argument quality, as well as the use of the argument elements of thesis, data, warrant, and rebuttal? A mixed-methods research design was adopted using both qualitative and quantitative approaches. Qualitative analysis was performed in order to investigate the production of arguments in students’ essays. An adaptation of Toulmin’s (2003) model of argument structure informed by Kuhn and Crowell’s (2011) argument model as well as Wolfe and colleagues notion of myside bias (Wolfe et al., 2009; Wolfe & Britt, 2008) was used to both identify the argument elements of claim, data, warrant, and rebuttal and to assess the overall quality of students’ arguments. Quantitative analysis was used to analyze the questionnaire and QPT results. Statistical analyses were performed using the SPPS software ver. 25 (IBM Corp. 2017). Findings showed that students generate arguments of average quality. Although in most of the essays a clear thesis was articulated accompanied by an opinion marker, weaknesses were found in the use of the argument elements of data and warrant. Regarding the argument element of rebuttal, the overwhelming percentage of essays exhibited myside bias, neglecting completely the consideration of opposing positions. Age, proficiency level, and type of prompt were the most significant factors affecting argument construction in Greek adolescent EFL writing. Interesting findings emerged in relation to the students’ thesis location preferences. Findings are discussed informed by previous empirical findings and literature on the argumentative writing genre, argument schemata, and culture. Implications for argumentative writing pedagogy are also presented.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2022
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Xargia, Maria
- Ξαργιά, Μαρία
Subjects
dc:subject × 13Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/53233