University of Patras
Οι μεταστροφές της μουσικής φόρμας στον Beethoven και Chopin υπό το πρίσμα των αισθητικών θεωριών του Kant και του Schelling
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe present dissertation concerns both the philosophical investigation of the art of music in the context of Kant and Schelling’s aesthetic theories and the examination of the potential differentiations on the musical form in the works of Beethoven and Chopin, always in relation with the above aesthetic views. By keeping the purpose of highlighting findings, the analysis of the selected works yielded results. Through these new elements the following comparative approach of the works was attempted according to the central positions of both Kantian and Schellingian aesthetic theory. About the approach on the transformations of musical form in the light of Kant's philosophical thought, on a main basis the investigation course pertains a combination of the aesthetic theory, which is drawn mainly from the Critique of Judgment, and of the form that responds to selected works of Beethoven and Chopin. However, we are referring to a subject that does not lack difficulties. These are usually arising from the incomplete collection of findings, as well as from the philosopher’s controversial attitude towards the discussion about the central parameters of the art under examination. To begin with, a parallel axis was distinguished onto which both Beethoven and Kant developed their thinking and creativity. This is happening at the edge of two eras that they are characterized by the classical, on the one hand, and the romantic style, on the other. The parallel of the matter is mainly based on the fact that both personalities made intensive efforts in order to integrate two directions. Nevertheless, the stake of the possibility regarding the compatibility of Kant's aesthetics with any kind of music ‒let alone when it concerns the absolute music‒ was assessed as crucial. On the other hand, the research on Schelling's aesthetics proved even more demanding, mainly due to the fact that it is, to a large extent, a relatively uncharted field. In this field, however, more critical issues were discovered and were investigated concerning the nature of artistic creation, the autonomy of the musical work of art, but above all about the interactive kind of the relationship between this particular art and the Schellingian thought. The findings from the comparison into this twofold field, music as well as philosophy, were, in any case, successful in part of the musicals works, of both Beethoven and Chopin’s, across the consideration of Schelling’s aesthetic elements, as these were mainly presented in his work The Philosophy of Art. Nevertheless, the successful conjunction between the musical and the aesthetic-theoretical findings did not mean the complete association of the musical form’s evolution towards the positions developed by a Philosophy of Music, even to the degree of Schelling's originality. However, the association was the motivation for the intensification of the research, as well as one of the models for its process in a whole. Furthermore, I think it will be worthwhile emphasizing about the significance of the musical time’s research hypothesis which is presented as intertwined with temporal disengagement, especially in the piano works by Chopin; this is, of course, true to the extent that temporal disengagement is consistent with the musical style of the Romantic era, before, that is, the tendencies which are usually found in the 20th century, in particular towards the extensive disengagement of rhythm, as well as towards ambiguity in relation to tonality. Apart from the issues of time, I consider of particular interest the findings regarding the possibility of a hypothetical dialogue between the great composers, especially when their spiritualized entities persist in a mental and long termed cultural realm. Equally interesting are the questions of the central Schellingian concept of indifference, but also of the creative management towards the contrasts that emerged between the Parts of a musical composition, but also within each Part, during the evolutionary course of the musical form from Classicism to Romanticism. Through the analysis of the works by Beethoven, with the abundance of which the transition to the era, in which the romantic style will dominate, is accomplished, and the analysis of the works by Chopin with which the specific style had mainly flourished in his piano compositions, I set my central target to make plausible the hypothesis of transformations in the musical form of these works. The achievement of my goal was attempted under the condition of interactive correlation on the music-philosophical axis, always in combination with the investigation of musical elements within the framework of the two aesthetic theories. In any case, the challenge of this research was indeed twofold. Most importantly, the highlighting of original theoretical findings in the aesthetic theories both of Kant and Schelling, combined with their unnecessary reductive application to the music creators in question, actually brought out different aspects. Besides, the two composers have been considered as great junctions for the development of both music and its philosophy. Therefore, the interest of examining their works with the Kantian and Schellingian aesthetic considerations, which are equally central to philosophy, is eventually apparent. So, in the light of these considerations, we will try to approach Beethoven’s innovative language that induces inversions in terms of the musical character, while, in the other research’s part, regarding Chopin’s work, we will turn to the potential rupture of the core concerning the spirit of Romanticism in music, seen, however, through a unique prism.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Patras
- Year dc:date
- 2022
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Petrou, Veroniki
- Πέτρου, Βερονίκη
Subjects
dc:subject × 22- Καντ, Ιμμάνουελ
- Σέλλινγκ, Φρήντριχ, Βίλχελμ, Γιόζεφ
- Μπετόβεν, Λούντβιχ, βαν
- Σοπέν, Φρεντερίκ, Φρανσουά
- Γερμανικός Ιδελισμός
- Φιλοσοφία της μουσικής
- Μουσική μορφή
- Αισθητική θεωρία
- Kant, Immanuel (1724-1804)
- Schelling, Friedrich, Wilhelm, Joseph (1775-1854)
- Beethoven, Ludwig, van (1770-1827)
- Chopin, Frédéric, François (1810-1849)
- Musical form
- Aesthetic theory
- German idealism
- Philosophy of music
- Φιλοσοφία, Ηθική και Θρησκεία
- Ανθρωπιστικές Επιστήμες και Τέχνες
- Φιλοσοφία
- Philosophy, Ethics and Religion
- Humanities and the Arts
- Philosophy
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/53354