University of Crete (UOC)
Συγκριτική μελέτη της κλασικής υπερηχογραφίας δύο διαστάσεων (2D) με τις νεότερες υπερηχογραφικές τεχνικές τεσσάρων διαστάσεων (4D STIC) για την απεικόνιση της φυσιολογικής ανατομίας και την ανίχνευση της παθολογικής ανατομίας της εμβρυϊκής καρδιάς στο 1ο και στο 2ο τρίμηνο της εγκυμοσύνης
Abstract
dc:descriptionAIM: Aim of the present PhD Thesis is the evaluation of the performance of advanced ultrasound imaging, namely 4D STIC and 4D e-STIC (acquisition and reconstruction of 3D volumes with temporal information -4D- based on mechanical –STIC- or electronic-eSTIC- cross sectional sweep of fetal thoracic area by using Spatial Temporal Image Correlation-STIC technology) against conventional 2D imaging. We studied also the impact of gestational age (trimester) on the 4D STIC performance to document normal and abnormal anatomy. The PhD Thesis included four substudies to evaluate: a) feasibility and diagnostic accuracy of 4D STIC against 2D ultrasound imaging (and comparison between STIC and eSTIC) b) Direct comparison of STIC/eSTIC against 2D ultrasound imaging in terms of time required for each technique in both levels of fetal heart imaging (basic-extended basic and fetal echocardiogram), c) Comparison of 2dimensional measurements of cardiac structures (heart valves) by each technique (2D, STIC, eSTIC), d) evaluation of 4DSTIC as a teaching tool, allowing reconstruction of all recommended basic-extended basic fetal heart imaging and recognition of key features of normal anatomy in each plane, by physicians of various levels of expertise in fetal ultrasound imaging. METHODS. In order to address the main study hypothesis (4D STIC is equal or superior to 2D ultrasound fetal heart imaging) and evaluate factors that can influence its performance, the study included four sub-studies which followed an learning curve period: Learning Curve Period. During this period the key investigators (Observer 1. PhD Candidate S.P, obstetrician-fetal medicine expert, Observer 2. Co-Supervisor. I.G. pediatrician-pediatric/fetal cardiology expert) performed several 4D STIC volume acquisitions (Investigator 1) and off-line reconstructions (Investigator 2), with interim analysis, fine tuning and standardization of image acquisition presetings, up to a level of a satisfactory (best possible) and steady (as demonstrated in several subsequent interim analysis) performance. Sub-study 1. Direct comparison of fetal heart 4D Ultrasound Imaging (STIC): electronic (eSTIC) vs conventional (STIC) 4D image acquisition. Pairs of B-Mode and Color Doppler STIC volumes were acquired sequentially by STIC and eSTIC in 33 obstetric scans (median gestational age 23 (range 13-31) weeks. 66 fetal heart volume pairs were blindly assessed by a fetal cardiologist. The reconstruction feasibility, motion or artifact presentation, the subjective image quality (4-level scale: 1-best to 4-non-diagnostic) and the final diagnosis were documented, enabling paired comparison of STIC and eSTIC in same subjects under same conditions. Sub-study 2. 2D vs 4D STIC fetal heart imaging feasibility. A total of 22 singleton pregnancies, median maternal age 30 (19-39) yrs, referred for fetal echocardiogram, at a median gestational age 25.3 wks (range 18-36, IQR: 22.2-29.5wks) have been consecutive evaluated by an expert fetal sonographer (Obs.1) and a fetal cardiologist (Obs.1). Each observer documented the time required for basic (Obs.1) and extended (Obs.2) fetal heart imaging. Acquisition of STIC and eSTIC (2D and color Doppler) volumes was also documented (Obs.1). Stored 4D volumes have been off-line analyzed regarding feasibility and reconstruction time for basic and extended fetal heart imaging (Obs.2), Sub-study 3. Comparison of 4D STIC and 2D fetal heart measurements. A total of 10 fetal echocardiograms of normal mid-term singleton pregnancies (median gestational age 22.6 wks, range 21.9-23.9wks) with stored 2D cine loops and STIC / eSTIC fetal heart 4D volumes (transverse acquisition plane) obtained by a single expert sonographer (Observer 1) have been retrospectively reviewed by the same observer. Linear 2D dimensions of mitral (MV), tricuspid (TV) in diastole, aortic (AoV) and pulmonary (PV) valve in systole were measured repeatedly (3 times) from a) 2D cine loops obtained by conventional fetal echocardiography (2D) and from 4D volumes obtained during b) STIC and c) e-STIC 4D fetal echocardiography. Intraobserver variability for each set of measurements and each mode has been assessed (ICC: intraclass correlation coefficient), average measurements have been compared for significant differences (related samples Friedman’s test) and the regression of STIC and eSTIC values against each other and 2D values has been assessed. Sub-study 4. 4D STIC in Basic Fetal Heart Imaging Teaching. Documentation of the first structured teaching of basic and extended basic routine fetal heart imaging, based on visual evaluation of reconstructed 4D fetal heart volumes (4D STIC), during the summer school entitled “Introduction in 4D Fetal Echocardiography”, School of Medicine, University of Crete, Heraklion 12-16th September 2022, organized by the PhD Thesis research team. Participants were 27 certified physicians and trainees (66% PhD level), including obstetricians (52%) paediatricians (37%) cardiologists (7%) and one radiologist. Through the course their ability to reconstruct and correctly interpret the recommended cross-sectional views of basic-extended basic fetal heart imaging was evaluated, while a quality evaluation of the seminar was performed by anonymized questionnaires. RESULTSSub-study 1.: eSTIC volumes were of higher temporal resolution (37 vs. 24 FPS, p < .001), with less motion (12 vs. 20 cases, O.R. 7.0, p = .002) and of better quality (1.9 vs. 2.2, p = .006) compared to STIC volumes. Feasibility (diagnostic reconstructions) of eSTIC was higher (n = 55, 86%) compared to STIC (n = 52, 78.8%), p = .001). Off-line evaluation time did not differ (mean 4.96 vs. 4.94 min in STIC and eSTIC respectively). In direct image quality comparison regarding original acquisition (A) and reconstructed planes B and C e STIC was superior in 22 (33%), 39 (59%) and 21 (38%) volumes, respectively. Remaining cases were of similar quality, with only <10% in each plane favoring STIC. A similar impact of imaging mode and gestational age on both eSTIC and STIC performance was documented: Feasible studies were documented in 49 (75.8%) vs. 48 (72.2%) obtained by B-Mode, 60 (90.9%) vs. 56 (84.8%) obtained by Color Doppler, 8 (62.5%) vs. 10 (50%) of early, 38 (95%) vs. 38 (95%) of mid-gestation, and 7 (70%) vs. 6 (60%) of third trimester studies. All 6 cases of fetal heart abnormal findings were documented by STIC and eSTIC. In 2 cases 4D STIC allowed for additional anatomy abnormality detection (great artery variants) compared to 2D routine ultrasound evaluation. STIC and e STIC had comparable diagnostic performance (40/48 concordant diagnoses, kappa 0.657) all confirmed by fetal and/or postnatal echocardiography.Sub-study 2. The mean time for basic-extended basic fetal heart imaging (Obs 1) and for fetal echocardiogram (Obs 2) was 5.6 min (2.3-11.1) and 6.8 min (1.6-14.3), respectively. Abnormal findings were documented in 4 cases (3 great artery variants, 1 tricuspid regurgitation). The mean time of STIC and eSTIC volume acquisition was 4.6 min (4-8) and 4.04 min (3-6) (p=0.009). The STIC and eSTIC volume reconstruction time (for basic-extended basic imaging, including 2D and Color D) was (mean/median, range) 0.99/0.68 (0.3-2.5) and 0.54/0.46 (0.31-1.33), p=0.05. Reconstruction failure due to suboptimal image quality (both 2D and Color D) was documented in 2/22 (9%) and 3/22 (13%) regarding STIC and eSTIC, respectively. When comparing STIC/eSTIC reconstruction times to real time basic 2D ultrasound imaging, 4D STIC techniques were faster than 2D imaging (p<0.0001). However, total 4D STIC time (including acquisition and reconstruction time) was shorter only when comparing eSTIC against real time 2D imaging (p=0.03). Regarding the performance of 4D STIC to reconstruct the additional image planes used in fetal echocardiography, reconstruction failure due to suboptimal image quality (both 2D and Color D) was documented in 7/22 (31%) and 9/22 (41%) regarding STIC and eSTIC, respectively. When comparing STIC/eSTIC reconstruction times (basic-extended basic plus additional fetal echocardiography views, 2D and Color D) to real time fetal echocardiography, 4D STIC techniques were faster than 2D imaging (p<0.02). However, total 4D STIC fetal echocardiography time (including acquisition and reconstruction time) did not differ to real time fetal heart imaging. In all but one case (aortic arch hypoplasia, suboptimal imaging), 4D STIC (both techniques) had diagnostic concordance with 2D fetal echocardiogram. Sub-study 3. Intraobserver variability was in ascending order average to good for 2D measurements (ICC 0.69-0.78), good for STIC (ICC: 0.77-0.84) and e-STIC (ICC: 0.86-0.89). There was not any significant difference between median measurements of MV (5.1/5.2/5.3mm), TV (5.6/5.7/5.8mm), AoV (4/3.9/4mm) and PV (4.3/4.3/4.5mm) obtained by STIC/eSTIC/2D echocardiography, respectively. R square values of linear regression analysis comparing measurement methods ranged from 0.58-0.84Sub-study 4. All participants could effectively reconstruct and appropriately recognize normal anatomy key features in all recommended basic –extended basic fetal heart imaging views following a 10 hour-structured interactive teaching course. They validated the 4D-STIC based fetal echocardiography course as excellent (95) or very good (4%). CONCLUSIONS. Based on the results of the PhD Thesis, three-dimensional ultrasound imaging (4D STIC) can offer comparable or additional diagnostic information compared to conventional 2D ultrasound fetal heart imaging, in both levels of routine basic-extended basic fetal heart imaging as well during advanced fetal heart imaging (fetal echocardiogram), provided that a) both image acquisition and 4D volume analysis is performed by experts in the corresponding fields b) high quality images of c) mid-trimester fetuses are evaluated. The performance of the technique in other than the above settings is suboptimal. 4D STIC allows for a complete fetal heart anatomy evaluation, based on 2D cross sectional ultrasound “sweep” (mechanical or electronic-based) of the fetal thorax. The time for a complete fetal heart 4D study (including acquisition and reconstruction) is comparable to real time 2D ultrasound study, at each level of evaluation (routine, expert). Including color Doppler 4DSTIC imaging and using of e-STIC further improves the technique’s performance. Following structured, supervised teaching courses, physicians of various levels of fetal sonography expertise are capable to reconstruct and correctly interpret basic and extended –basic fetal heart views, by using 4D STIC associated PC –software (4D View). Current practice guidelines regarding fetal echocardiography classify 4D ultrasound imaging of the fetal heart as “complementary” advanced imaging method to evaluate anatomy and or “research tool”. Based on the results of the present PhD Thesis, 4D STIC (and 4D fetal echocardiography in general) could represent a powerful teaching and diagnostic tool with additive value over standard 2D ultrasound fetal heart imaging. Further research regarding factors with impact on 4D STIC performance, along with technical advances in computer technology and 4D ultrasound imaging combined with expected lower cost of the technology could result into establishment of 4D ultrasound imaging as the standard of care in fetal cardiology in the near future.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Crete (UOC)
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Pepes, Spyridon
- Πεπές, Σπυρίδων
Subjects
dc:subject × 14- Εμβρυϊκή υπερηχοκαρδιογραφία
- Εμβρυϊκή καρδιά
- Ηλεκτρονική τετραδιάστατη εμβρυϊκή υπερηχοκαρδιογραφία
- Fetal echocardiography
- Fetal heart
- Electronic 4D fetal echocardiography
- Κλινική Ιατρική
- Ιατρική και Επιστήμες Υγείας
- Μαιευτική και Γυναικολογία
- Καρδιολογία και Καρδιοαγγειακά νοσήματα
- Clinical Medicine
- Medical and Health Sciences
- Obstetrics and Gynecology
- Cardiology and Cardiovascular Medicine
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/53543