Back to search

University of Ioannina

Αριστοτελική ηδονολογία και νεότερος πολιτικός ηδονισμός

Abstract

dc:description

This dissertation focuses on the moral theories of Aristotle and John Stuart Mill and particularly it examines in depth the views they develop about pleasure and its relationship to eudaimonia and happiness, respectively. The theories on pleasure of these two great philosophers are reconstructed and compared in order to come to light the common elements, the differences and the possible effects of Aristotle on John Stuart Mill’s thought. This dissertation consists of Prologue, Introduction, two Parts, Critical Review - Conclusions and Bibliography. In the Introduction is stated that John Stuart Mill, who received a classical education from his early childhood, seems that in his view of happiness he has been influenced by the ancient Greek eudaimonistic ideal and especially by the Aristotelian concept of eudaimonia as some researchers argue. The work of these researchers was the main incentive to deal with this specific topic. The first Part, entitled "Pleasure and Eudaimonia in Aristotle's Ethics", consists of four chapters. The first chapter titled "Aristotle's Thematization of the Problem of Pleasure" constitutes an introductory chapter in which the reasons that prompted Aristotle to deal with the problem of pleasure and to include it in his practical philosophy are examined. In the three consequent chapters, a critical reconstruction of Aristotle’s theory of pleasure is attempted, which is based mainly on his works Protrepticus to Themison, Eudemian Ethics and Nicomachean Ethics. In the second chapter, denominated "Protrepticus to Themison and the Pleasures of Contemplative Life", Aristotle argues about the unique pleasantness of the philosophical life. In order to defend this position he makes use of a popularized form of his theory on potentiality and actuality. He concludes that perfect and unimpeded activity contains in itself pleasure. This entails that the activity of contemplation must be the most pleasant. In the third chapter entitled "Eudemian Ethics and the Conjunction of Pleasure and Eudaimonia", pleasure is classified by Aristotle among the internal goods of the soul which means that he ascribes to it a positive value. Aristotle cannot conceive eudaimonia without the element of pleasure. However, he rejects the life of enjoyment which is based on the sense of touch. Sensual pleasures are acceptable if they are under the control of reason. He also connects the moral virtues, which are the virtues of the irrational part of the soul, with pleasure and pain. Aristotle is convinced that a man’s character is determined by the stance he adopts towards certain physical pleasures and pains as well as by the way he expresses his passions. The fourth chapter which bears the title "Nicomachean Ethics and the Nature of Pleasure", the nature of pleasure is examined on the basis of two books of the Nicomachean Ethics: book Η’ (seventh, ch. 12-15) and book Κ’ (tenth, ch. 1-5). In the seventh book Aristotle rejects Speusippus’ antihedonism and denies the Platonic doctrine according to which pleasure is the perceptible replenishment of a lack or a process of generation. He defines pleasure as the “unimpeded activity of a disposition in its natural state” and argues that pleasure is something good, since its opposite, pain, is generally considered as something bad. Even though most pleasures are bad, nothing prevents a certain pleasure to be the good. The fact that all (man and animals) pursue pleasure, it could be an indication that pleasure is in a way the supreme human good. Eudaimonia is also an unimpeded activity, which entails that eudaimonia and pleasure coincide and that Aristotle in seventh book endorses hedonism. In the tenth book of the Nicomachean Ethics Aristotle maintains that pleasure is inextricably interwoven with human race. Human beings desire and choose what gives them pleasure and avoid what is painfull. For the formation of a virtuous character it is necessary to educate man from early childhood to enjoy and hate the right things. Αristotle in the tenth book criticizes Eudoxus’ hedonistic theory in order to prove that pleasure is not identical with the good. Aristotle does not identify in this book eudaimonia with pleasure, but he does not cease to combine these two elements by supporting that pleasure accompanies and perfects the eudaimonistic activity. At the end of the chapter the two kinds of Aristotelian eudaimonia are discussed. The second Part, entitled "Pleasure and Happiness in John Stuart Mill's Utilitarian Ethics", consists of seven chapters. The first chapter titled "Political Hedonism" refers to the emerge in the 17th century of the philosophical current of political hedonism and presents the main positions of the representatives of this current. In the second chapter, entitled "The Principle of Utility in Millian Ethics", an attempt is made to clarify the concept of “the principle of utility” or “the greatest happiness principle” and the way in which Mill connects it with pleasure. The third chapter, denominated "Natural Feeling of Duty - Social Feeling" deals with the social feeling which, according to Mill, characterizes the majority of people and justifies the principle of utility. In the fourth chapter titled "Millian Perfectionism" the model of individual perfection proposed by Mill is examined. This model aims at the cultivation of the self and the self-development of the individual by achieving excellences capable of contributing to the completion of human being. The fifth chapter, entitled "Millian Hedonism", refers to Mill's qualitative hedonism and its specific characteristics. Special emphasis is given to the competent agent as the model of moral behavior who is able to choose and appreciate ways of life that offer higher and spiritual pleasures. The sixth chapter denominated "Elements that Enhance Individual Fulfillment and Happiness and Promote General Happiness" discusses the great importance that Mill assigns to the excellence of individuality and to the cultivation of character and virtues in the promotion of individual and general happiness which is indicative of the influence that ancient Greek philosophy and Aristotelian ethics had exerted upon his thought. Finally, the last chapter entitled "The Mosaic of Happiness" analyses Mill’s concept of happiness and its relationship with pleasure. In the Critical Review - Conclusions the comparison of Aristotle’s and Mill’s theory of pleasure highlights important similarities and analogies between them. Among other things, it emerges: a) An analogy between Mill's competent agent who has in a sense practical wisdom and is therefore able to have a correct judgment about what is truly pleasant, as in Aristotle the prudent person (φρόνιμος) has the correct judgment about the pleasant and the good (ἀγαθόν). b) Aristotle's influence on Mill, since Mill, by introducing as a second criterion of morality the intention of the moral agent, essentially has in mind Aristotle’s stable dispositions of the character (ἕξεις) based on which the individual acts in such a way as to contribute to his happiness and to the well-being of the whole. c) The similarity of the two philosophers regarding the social character of their theories, as Mill's utility principle resembles Aristotle's views such as that the best man exercises his virtue towards another and that moral virtue is a capability of bestowing benefits upon others and d) The common view of the two philosophers about the individual who has mastered the highest good as an active being who, within the community, develops virtues and excellences, evolves, completes himself as a human being and acts taking into account the good of the whole.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of Ioannina
Year dc:date
2023

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Papageorgakis, Georgios
  • Παπαγεωργάκης, Γεώργιος

Subjects

dc:subject × 19

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/53645

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Papageorgakis, Georgios; Παπαγεωργάκης, Γεώργιος. Αριστοτελική ηδονολογία και νεότερος πολιτικός ηδονισμός. University of Ioannina, 2023. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/53645