Abstract
dc:descriptionIntroduction: Several endogenous and exogenous environmental factors affect cell physiology and homeostasis, causing DNA damage and genome instability. If DNA damages occur in the germline cells, they can potentially lead to infertility, abnormal embryo development and adverse obstetrical, perinatal, and neonatal outcomes. Mammalian oocyte response to DNA damage is of great interest, considering that the female germ cells are produced prior to birth and remain arrested at the prophase stage of meiosis I over a long period of time till puberty. During this extensive state of arrest oocytes may be exposed to several DNA damaging factors, affecting oocyte quality and competence. Therefore, it is of great importance to understand how these cells respond to DNA damage. Despite the significant research in the field started more than three decades ago, information is mostly provided by animal studies and limited data are available in humans.Aim: The aim of the present study was to investigate DNA damage response mechanisms in fully grown germinal vesicle (GV) stage human oocytes, focusing on double strand brakes (DSBs). To elaborate on that, this study investigated the sensitivity of the DNA damage response mechanisms during meiosis on different levels of genotoxicity, the oocyte ability to resume meiosis even with DNA damages, the oocyte capacity on repairing DNA damage as well as the effect of DNA damage on oocyte morphokinetic characteristics during in vitro maturation.Materials & Methods: The present prospective interventional study was conducted on the Laboratory of Cellular and Developmental Biology of the Department of Biological Applications and Technology of the University of Ioannina, in collaboration with the Assisted Reproduction Unit of the ‘’Institute of Life, IASO’’. Study’s protocol was approved by the Greek National Authority of Assisted Reproduction (Approval Number 443/31.7.2018). The population of the study constituted of 24 women till 35 years old, subjected to donor oocyte cycles. Participants received extensive consultation and provided their GV oocytes for the study’s proposes following informed consent. The total number of the donated GV oocytes was 158. Briefly, all participants received the standard short GnRH antagonist protocol. Following oocyte retrieval, the cumulus oocyte complexes (COCs) were mechanically and enzymatically (hyaluronidase, FertiPro) denudated, and the nuclear maturation status was assessed. The isolated GV oocytes were allocated in two groups, the experimental group, and the control group, respectively. The experimental group consisted of GV oocytes which were cultured for one hour in media supplemented with the genotoxic factor etoposide (Etop). Etoposide is a well-known chemical factor, which can induce the formation of DSBs. The control group consisted of GV oocytes which were exposed to the standard culture conditions without etoposide supplementation. Then, some of the GV oocytes of both groups were fixated with paraformaldehyde (PF) (Etop PF and Control PF, respectively), aiming to evaluate etoposide’s effect on inducing DSBs. The rest of the GV oocytes were cultured for 24 hours in benchtop incubators (Astec Pengium, Astec) employing the following culture conditions 6.5% CO2, 5% O2 and temperature 37.5 οC. In order to investigate the effect of etoposide pre-treatment on oocyte in vitro maturation, data obtained from time-lapse (TL) system (Primo Vision, TK Biotech, Vitrolife) were analyzed (Etop TL). Employing the same experimental process, control GV oocytes, without previous exposition on etoposide, were culture and in vitro maturation was also monitored via time-lapse (Control TL). Following culture completion, the oocytes from both groups were fixated, as previously described, in order to assess the competent of the human oocytes to restore DNA damages. Evaluation of DNA damage response was performed employing immunofluorescence experiments, targeting the phosphorylated histone γ-Η2ΑΧ. Histone γ-Η2ΑΧ is a well-known sensitive biomarker for accurately detecting DSBs. The histone γ-Η2ΑΧ immunofluorescent levels were assessed by using confocal microscopy (Leica TCS SP5). Statistical analysis was performed by using GraphPad Prism and the R Language for Statistical Proposes.Results: Aiming to investigate the sensitivity of the DNA damage response mechanisms during the prophase of the 1st meiotic division as well as during metaphase I (MI) stage, 31 GV oocytes were exposed to different concentrations of etoposide (Etop), which can induce different levels of genotoxic damage and then were cultured in order to in vitro maturate for 24 hours, employing incubators equipped with time-lapse systems (TL). More specifically, eight (8) GV oocytes were exposed on 100 μg/ml of etoposide (Etop 100 TL), seven (7) on 20 μg/ml (Etop 20 TL), and seven (7) on 10 μg/ml (Etop 20 TL), triggering severe, mild, and minimal levels of genotoxicity, respectively. Nine (9) GV oocytes were cultured without previous exposure to etoposide and served as the control group (Control TL). Data obtained from time-lapse were analyzed and analysis revealed that the in vitro maturation of the oocytes in the Etop 100 TL group was arrested in the GV stage, as the 100% of these oocytes remained in the GV stage. In contrast, the germinal vesicle breakdown rate (GVBD rate) with regards to the Etop 20 TL and Etop 10 TL groups was recorder to be 71.43% and the 1st polar body extrusion rate (PB1 extrusion rate) was recorder to be 71.43% and 57.14%, respectively. Similar GVBD and PB1 extrusion rates were recorder for the control group, reaching 88.89%, respectively. This data demonstrates that the DNA damage response mechanisms during meiosis of human oocytes are sensitive for extensive genotoxic damages and activate upon severe damage resulting on arresting extensively damaged oocytes on the GV stage. In contrast, mild or minimal damages do not activate the DNA damage response mechanisms, which are insensitive to restricted damages and thus oocytes presenting with these levels of DNA damage are able to successfully maturate. Aiming to further elaborate and verify these conclusions regarding the lack of sensitivity of the DNA damage response mechanisms on detecting mild DNA damages, experiments on larger oocyte population were performed. Briefly, 102 GV human oocytes were recruited in this stage of the study. Forty-five (45) of them were exposed to 20 μg/ml of etoposide (Etop) and then were cultured to in vitro maturate for 24 hours in incubators equipped with time-lapse systems (TL), serving as the experimental group (Etop TL). The rest 57 GV oocytes were cultured under the same conditions to in vitro maturate without previous exposure to etoposide, constituting the control group (Control TL). It is crucial to highlight that prior to these experiments, the ability of 20 μg/ml etoposide on inducing mild damages in the form of DSBs was assessed employing immunofluorescence experiments, targeting the phosphorylated histone γ-Η2ΑΧ. Statistical analysis did not reveal any significant difference between the Etop TL and Control TL groups with regards to both GVBD (62.22% vs 63.16%, p-value = 0.543) and PB1 extrusion rates (85.71% vs 88.89%, p-value = 0.495). In addition, no statistically significant difference was observed between the two groups regarding the time required for both GVBD (5.86 ± 3.19 hours vs 5.89 ± 3.71 hours, p-value = 0.792) and PB1 extrusion (18.32 ± 2.70 hours vs 17.96 ± 3.66 hours, p-value = 0.914), indicating that DNA damage did not affect the transition time from the GV stage to the metaphase II (MII) stage. These data are in the same line with the data originated from the previously described titration experiments, supporting the hypothesis that DNA damage response mechanisms of human oocytes are insensitive to minimal and/or mild levels of genotoxic damage. The effect of DNA damage to oocyte morphology was also assessed. Interestingly, a statistically significant increased rate of oocytes with abnormal morphological features, and especially with granule ooplasm, was observed in the Etop TL group compared with the Control TL group (55.56% vs 29.82%, p-value = 0.015). This increased rate of morphologically abnormal oocytes in the Etop TL group was recorded for both oocytes remained arrested in the GV stage and oocytes successfully reached MII stage. These findings indicate that DNA damage in human oocytes may be associated with abnormal morphological features. A subgroup analysis according to the oocyte donors’ age was performed, in order to investigate the possible effect of maternal age on DDCs sensitivity during oocyte maturation. The first subgroup consisted of GV oocytes retrieved from donors with age ≤ 30 years old. The second subgroup consisted of GV oocytes retrieved from donors with age > 30 years old. No statistically significant difference was observed between and within subgroups with regards to all morphokinetic data analyzed. Finally, the ability of the human oocytes to repair DNA damage, focusing on DSBs, was investigated. Following the 24 hours in vitro culture, a significant reduction of γ-Η2ΑΧ immunofluorescence levels was observed in GV-arrested oocytes previously exposed to etoposide. However, these levels remained statistically significant increase in comparison to the respective GV-arrested oocyte of the control group, which were never exposed to etoposide. These findings indicate that human oocytes can partially restore DNA damage during meiosis.Conclusions: The findings of the present study are in the same line with previously published data, mainly originating from animal studies, and indicate that human GV oocytes can successfully complete maturation from the GV to the MII stage, even if they are carrying DNA damage. This is attributed to the low sensitivity of DNA damage response mechanisms of the human oocytes during meiosis, which on one hand can effectively arrest oocyte maturation in the presence of severe and extensive DNA damage, but on the other hand cannot prevent maturation when DNA damage is mild or minimal due to low sensitivity. However, even the mild DNA damage can cause genome instability, jeopardizing oocyte quality and competence as well as embryo developmental potential. Regarding the ability of human oocytes to repair DNA damage, it seems that it is restricted, and it is taking place mainly via homologous recombination (HR). However, it should be noted that DNA repair is not mandatory for the successful completion of oocyte maturation, as indicated by the fact that MII oocytes, previously damaged at the GV stage, are still carrying DNA lesions. Moreover, this study highlights for first time in literature that human oocytes characterized by abnormal morphological features, and especially by granular cytoplasm, are more likely to carry DNA damage, even if reach MII stage. However, robust data are needed to verify these conclusions. Future studies employing high-throughput techniques, including OMICs and artificial intelligence, are needed in order to deeply understand human oocyte response to DNA damage in both cellular and molecular levels.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Ioannina
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Agapitou, Krystallo
- Αγαπητού, Κρυστάλλω
Subjects
dc:subject × 14Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/53745