Back to search

Panteion University of Social and Political Sciences

Λογική και ιστορία της κρατικής μορφής: ο Hegel του Marx απέναντι στον Spinoza του Negri

Abstract

dc:description

This dissertation deals with the question of a general sociology of the State and proposes a "paradigm shift", and it seeks to articulate the fields of general sociology, political philosophy and the empirical investigation of the state phenomenon. For this purpose, it suggests the construction of a new methodological framework starting from the critical review of the work of Spinoza, Hegel, Marx, Negri. As a gateway to this problem, we have chosen a genealogical review of the concept of the State, with the ancient Greek and the modern reflection on the State Form as key points of reference, and with the aim of highlighting the mythological and imaginative coordinates within which the Logos of the State takes shape. A result of this investigation is the preliminary definition of state rationality as the dominant strategy of prevailing in civil war. Then, we study and critically reconstruct the contribution of Spinoza and Hegel to the theory of State Form. In Spinoza, we find an analytical strategy for understanding the State's immanence in the Multitude, which presupposes its ethical ontology and political psychology, but also a dynamic understanding of the feedback between the competitive development of the Multitude and the State. This double movement is the engine of development of the State Form, from Monarchy to Democracy. The constitutive terms of the logical structure and history of the State, which in Spinoza have only been analyzed in a simplistic way, emerge more clearly in Hegel. The initial disintegration of multitude and community, primitive alienation, is the generative mechanism of the State Form, with Hegel's youthful theological writings emphasizing its material factors – demographic densification, socio-economic inequality and cultural conflicts within the human community. The late Hegel, moreover highlights the dialectical constitution of the State Form both at the level of a phenomenology of domination, which the subjects internalize under the weight of the intersubjective and objective conditions of the realization of their freedom, and at the level of the State’s objective realization in the family, bourgeois society, the constitutional nation-state, world history. Ultimately, our critical examination highlights the State as an objective strategy for realizing unfreedom. Our examination then turns to the materialist critique of the State Form from Marx to Negri. Regarding the work of Marx, we find that already in the initial phase of the preconditions of the Marxian theory of the State Form, and especially in the Critique of the Hegelian Philosophy of the State and Law, the whole trajectory that a materialist theory of the State must undertake is wholly if not abstractly sketched. According to our interpretation, in this work we can distinguish the tertiary contradiction of the organic State, as reflected in the contradictions of hegemonic, executive and legislative power that stifle the possibility of a substantial realization of democracy, the secondary contradiction between bourgeois society and the political State, while we also trace, in a latent way, the existence of a primary contradiction which results in the dissolution of the primitive community and the formation of the primary, divine-patriarchal State. Thus the Marxist view of the State Form can be distinguished in phases of development of the general concept of historical materialism, which studies the primary contradiction, of the critique of political economy, on the basis of which Marx develops his class historiography, which refer to the secondary contradiction, and the critique of the juridical-political edifice of the State. This concerns the understanding of the tripartite contradiction, in the horizon of a latent quaternary contradiction in the global capitalist context, which Marx does not elaborate further. Then, we turned to the work of Antonio Negri, in critical continuity and rupture with Marx's work, which also marks a decisive shift in the spinozian corpus, as opposed to the Hegelian, as a theoretical reference. We have tried to demonstrate the continuity and discontinuity of the problematic of the initially workerist Italian Philosopher in relation to the marxist background of understanding the State Form, as well as some critical theoretical concepts for understanding the contradictions and competitive dialectic that governs the history of the capitalist State. Then, we focused on Negri's spinozian turn, signaled by his book Savage Anomaly, with which he attempts an affirmative-productive foundation of the critique of the State Form, beyond the negative foundation of the workerist critique of the state and capital. From the history of the Constituent Power to the Labor of Dionysus to the Empire, the Multitude, and the Commonwealth, Hardt & Negri develop an original view of modern capitalist relations, in which the socialization of modern cooperative, scientific-intellectual production forms a new subject of exploitation and struggle, the Multitude, against a new kind of globalized statehood, the Empire of deterritorialized capital . Finally, in the concluding chapter of the dissertation, we devoted ourselves to the theoretical summarization of the philosophy of the State Form of Spinoza, Hegel, Marx, Negri, in the hope of establishing a common conceptual outline. Our approach distinguished between the generative mechanisms producing the State Form, the strategic dialectic of the State Form, which rests upon a certain state infrastructure and superstructure, the logical history of the State Form, and its evolutionary history. On this basis, we proposed a research program in order to investigate the social evolutionary history of the capitalist State, and of individual capitalist States, in the era of crisis.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Panteion University of Social and Political Sciences
Year dc:date
2023

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Εfstathiou, Ioannis
  • Ευσταθίου, Ιωάννης

Subjects

dc:subject × 22

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/53795

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Εfstathiou, Ioannis; Ευσταθίου, Ιωάννης. Λογική και ιστορία της κρατικής μορφής: ο Hegel του Marx απέναντι στον Spinoza του Negri. Panteion University of Social and Political Sciences, 2023. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/53795