National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Η εφαρμογή των συνταγματικών δικαιωμάτων: αναλογικότητα - στάθμιση και θεσμική εφαρμογή
Abstract
dc:descriptionConstitutional rights, as recognized and established by the legal order and primarily the Constitution, are not only declarations of principles, but are legally binding rules that create rights and corresponding obligations. At the same time, however, they are applied and their application extends throughout the length and breadth of the legal order, occupying almost the entire regulation.Constitutional rights were originally enshrined as individual rights in order to provide protection from state power. Already, at this level, their application showed great practical difficulties, which multiplied after the expansion of their scope to the relations between individuals to which they suit («Drittwirkung»).But what exactly is the difficulty of their implementation? And how should it be treated? Before referring to any issue relating to the application of constitutional rights, there is a need to define the meaning of limitation. The limitation emerges as the great "protagonist" of the application of constitutional rights. However, the concept of limitation, as a contraction of the content of the right, presupposes the precise definition of the limited size, the "right" and its exact content.On the occasion of the above questions, this doctoral thesis analyzes the issue of the application of constitutional rights through the clarification of the crucial concepts and with the indicative but at the same time rich case study it cites, attempts to highlight the need to identify and adopt by the law enforcer of a perfectly reasonable and precise mechanism for resolving everyday "conflict" disputes of constitutional rights, capable of providing solid legal certainty and security.In this effort, proportionality is approached both as a legal principle with its individual manifestations (appropriateness, necessity, stricto sensu proportionality) and as a legal tool for controlling the limitations of constitutional rights, in the light of both greek and foreign jurisprudence. In search of theoretical bases and through the citation and elaboration of mainly jurisprudential cases, a critical approach is attempted to the current holding in theory and jurisprudence balancing, both in terms of its doctrinal weaknesses and in terms of its effectiveness in practice.There are recorded, also, the other methodological proposals of the constitutional theory regarding the resolution of the "conflict" of constitutional rights. Having already clarified the concept of limitation by other related encumbrances of constitutional rights, the institutional application of constitutional rights is separately analyzed with its the three individual stages through the processing of illustrative cases from everyday practice.It is finally established that balancing is not based on solid theoretical foundations and faces problems in practical application. The other proposals of the constitutional theory, as individual aspects of proportionality and balancing, do not offer a specific and effective methodology for resolving disputes and certain of them do not avoid in cases of "conflict" the "sacrifice" of one right for another.On the contrary, the method of institutional application of constitutional rights, with the integrated approach to each problem, mainly through the conceptual subordination of the real data of each case to the scope of application of each constitutional right, but also by adapting the right to the special relationship or the institution, through of the logical tool of causation, provides the guarantees of accuracy, the required legal certainty and solid reliability in all cases.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Douli, Maria
- Δουλή, Μαρία
Subjects
dc:subject × 33- Συνταγματικά δικαιώματα
- Eφαρμογή
- Περιορισμός
- ΟΡΙΟΘΕΤΗΣΗ
- Στάθμιση
- Δίκαιη ισορροπία
- Αιτιώδης συνάφεια
- Θεσμός
- Ειδική κυριαρχική σχέση
- Ασφάλεια δικαίου
- Πανδημία
- Αναλογικότητα
- Πρακτική εναρμόνιση
- Σύγκρουση
- Constitutional rights
- Application
- Restriction
- DELIMITATION
- Balancing
- Fair balance
- Causation
- Institution
- Special sovereign relationship
- Legal certainty
- Pandemic
- Proportionality
- Practical harmonization
- Conflict
- Νομική Επιστήμη
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Δίκαιο
- Law
- Social Sciences
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/53854