Back to search

National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)

Διερεύνηση της ηλεκτροχημικής διάβρωσης και αποκραμάτωσης των αρχαιομεταλλουργικών κραμάτων χαλκού: μελέτες περιπτώσεων, εργαστηριακές δοκιμές διάβρωσης και καθαρισμού

Abstract

dc:description

The current dissertation was undertaken in an interdisciplinary field, which involves Corrosion Science, Archaeometry and Cultural Heritage Metals Conservation, in the framework of which both the theoretical background and experimental techniques of Materials Science, Electrochemistry and Instrumental Analytical Chemistry were employed. The archaeometallurgical alloys, and archaeometallurgical copper alloys in particular, are characterized by unique chemical and microstructural features compared to typical industrial alloys. These special characteristics and the relevant alloy properties are attributed to the production and metalworking technologies available in particular historical periods and geographic locations of the ancient world. It is a scientific fact that Cu-Sn alloys (bronzes) και Cu-Zn alloys (brasses) are prone to decuprification and dezincification – dealloying phenomena that represent specific forms of galvanic corrosion. The decuprification mechanisms are well established and studied in ancient bronzes, while dezincification mechanisms have been the subject of many studies on industrial brasses. However, these dealloying mechanisms have never been described in detail in the case of as-cast archaeometallurgical Cu alloys.The General Theoretical Background includes a literature review focused on three sections: (i) the archaeometallurgical technology of copper and Cu alloys production and their properties (ii) the basic principles of electrochemistry and the general background of electrochemical corrosion, (iii) the electrochemical corrosion and dealloying phenomena observed in bronzes and brasses. The General Experimental Part includes bibliographic references on typical experimental methods employed in archaeometric studies and metals conservation projects, tailored to meet the particular needs and constraints of this scientific area. The dissertation design, general experimental methodology and structure is presented and all methods principles, laboratory installations and equipment used were described. The main part of the dissertation is comprised of five independent experimental chapters. In the first experimental chapter entitled ‘Case studies of longterm soil corrosion of bronze and brass artefacts’, four blank samples collected from Roman period objects – provided by a collaborating research group from Politecnico di Torino (Italy) – were examined. The original objects have been excavated from two locations in Italy: Tiber riverbanks and the archaeological site of Tharros in the west coast of Sardinia. The recognition of the objects utility, the approximate dating and the reconstruction of their archaeometallurgical production technology was attempted. The investigation was mainly focused on the reconstruction of the corrosion history of these objects and for this purpose adapted a methodology (a combination of destructive and non-destructive analytical techniques) aiming to map: (i) the intact metal cores in order to acquire information on the chemical composition and microstructure (ii) the multi-layered natural patinas and local corrosion patterns. Chemical analyses of soil samples from the excavation sites, as well as available bibliographic archaeological data were also employed to achieve a complete characterization. The initial sample documentation involved macro-photography, weight and dimensions measurements. The patinas surface chemical analysis was conducted by Fourier-transformed infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) in powder micro-samples and in the case of flat samples with X-ray fluorescence (XRF), X-ray diffraction (XRD), scanning electron microscopy coupled with energy dispersive spectroscopy (SEM-EDS). The elemental chemical analyses of the metal substrates were performed by XRF and EDS, the metallographic examination was conducted by optical microscopy (OM) after colour etching. The metallurgical characterization was completed by Vickers microhardness testing. The correlation of diagnostic data with literature sources led to the attribution of the four samples to: (i) a brass coin -of chemical composition 84.4%Cu, 12.7.%Ζn, 2.2% Pb, 0.7%Fe- manufactured between 23-120 A.D., (ii) a brass (82.7%Cu, 17.3%Ζn) handle of a handheld tool, the manufacture of which can be assumed between 1st -2nd century A.D., (iii) a copper disk-shaped utensil or tool frequently used at high temperatures, (iv) an as-cast curved handle (or ornamental element) made of highly leaded bronze 5(0.4%Cu, 43.2% Pb, 5.3.%Sn and 1.2%Fe), of ambiguous dating. The detailed macroscopic and microscopic characterization of the sample cross-sections by a combination of analytical techniques (OM, XRF, SEM-EDS, OM, XRD, Raman, FTIR) revealed: the development of synchronous dezincification and decuprification processes on the two brasses, fossilization processes of the external corrosion layers of all samples that lead to the deposition of silicate and calcareous sediments and the incorporation of soil material crystals (quartz, calcite, feldspars). Moreover, the observed local corrosion attack and dealloying patterns were correlated with changes of the corrosion micro-environment and with the internal features of the objects. The systematic SEM-EDS examination of the patina stratigraphy on the two α-brasses επί της στρωματογραφίας pointed out the following facts: During the initial stage of electrochemical attack an intense or complete dezincification takes place, while the long-term corrosion layer formation and transformation is mainly promoted by the decuprification mechanism. The brass containing higher Zn content exhibited intense intergranular and transgranular attack, a typical case of stress corrosion cracking (SCC). On the copper object the intergranular corrosion of metal grains was also reported along with a variety of non-typical corrosion structures. These findings combined with the elements detected in crevices (C, O, N, P, Fe, S, Ca, Si) were attributed to microbiologically induced corrosion (MIC). The cross-section of the corroded leaded bronze revealed a combination of typical and non-typical deposition of corrosion layers: accumulation of uniform layers, diffusion of corrosive species into the alloy matrix through short paths and selective corrosion of Pb phase inside the bulk alloy. Among the main Cu, Zn and Pb corrosion products detected on the external corrosion layers of the four samples by FTIR and Raman microscopy - rarely reported in the scientific literature – were Cu hydroxy-phosphate and hydroxy-carbonate compounds, mixed Cu-Zn hydroxy-carbonates, Pb hydroxy-phosphates.The following experimental chapters utilized specimens from three reference archaeometallorurgical copper castings, produced with processes simulating archaeometallurgical practices. The three reference alloys were two ternary bronzes (Cu-Sn-Pb and Cu-Pb-Sn) and a quaternary brass (Cu-Zn-Sn-Pb), with % weight nominal composition 92.3Cu-7.5 Sn- 0.2 Pb, 88.0 Cu-8.0 Pb- 4.0 Sn and 82.5 Cu,-14.0Zn-3.0 Sn- 0.5 Pb, respectively.In the framework of ‘Metallographic characterization of copper alloy castings produced by archaeometallurgical practices’ standard microscopic and metallographic techniques, as well as X ray spectroscopic methods were used. The general chemical analyses of the metal substrates employed XRD for the identification of crystalline phases and XRF for the semi-quantitative determination of the chemical composition. The metallogrphic study of the ground and polished sufraces and cross-sections was conducted with reflected light OM, after colour etching with Klemm reagents. Afterwards, Vickers microhardness testing was also performed. The alloy phases (predominant α-(Cu-Sn) phase in bronzes and α-(Cu-Zn-Sn) phase in brass, immiscible Pb phase in all three alloys), as well as the casting defects (such as hot-tearing and crack evolution due to shrinkage, pores, non-metallic inclusions) were clearly depicted. The distinct microstructure zones were mapped by local SEM-EDS analyses. The compositional and microstructural inhomogeneity of the as-cast alloys was testified both in the micro-scale (cored dendritic structures) and in the macro-scale (radial macro-segregation and gravity segregation). The chapter ‘Electrochemical corrosion and dealloying phenomena of archaeometallurgical Cu alloys in aqueous NaCl solutions and synthetic electrolytes’ includes multiple sections addressing different research questions via suitable potentiodynamic electrochemical techniques (approaching the initial electrochemical attack or the intense anodic dissolution) and ex situ characterization using microscopies and spectroscopic analyses. For the purposes of these experiments a series of aqueous NaCl solutions and other synthetic liquid electrolytes – representing corrosive environments such as seawater, coastal urban atmosphere, coastal soil and fertilized soil of agricultural areas - were produced. A series of pilot experiments aimed in the understanding of the tendency of the three alloys towards corrosion and anodic dissolution in chloride electrolytes and in the determination of test parameters and optimal experimental conditions for the setup of particular tests. The nature of anodic and cathodic electrochemical reactions in NaCl solution systems and the corrosion attack local patterns resulting from the casting microstructure, the representativeness of synthetic liquid soil electrolytes compared to wetted soil for the use in laboratory test etc., were some of the important issues that were investigated. The effect of the alloying elements (Sn, Zn and Pb), as well as the chloride concentration and the pH of the NaCl media in the overall electrochemical behavior of the three alloys was studied by: 1 h open circuit potential (OCP) recordings, anodic polarization measurements, cyclic polarization measurements and pitting tests. The effect of alloying elements and chloride concentration was studied in NaCl systems (molarities 0.01, 0.06, 0.1, 06 mol/L) for Cu and the three alloys. The overall electrochemical behavior and the parameters determined by the anodic curves were comparatively assessed and in respect to pure copper. The cyclic curves in 0.01 and 0.1 mol/L solutions by applying five different sweep rates, provided with additional data on the electrochemical profile of the alloys. Based on the characteristics of the experimental curves, the influence of the scan rate increase on the position of the anodic and cathodic peaks, the current density levels and the tendency towards pitting was discussed. At all conditions, copper exhibited a clear tendency towards pitting. However, at [Cl]=0.1 mol/L the formation of more stable Cu compounds is favored. Higher resistance towards pitting was reported for the three archaeometallurgical alloys at the particular concentration, with the leaded α-bronze exhibiting the best performance. At low chloride concentrations, the three alloys were more vulnerable to pitting evolution. Pitting test in neutral and acidified NaCl solutions, confirmed the general trend of more intense pitting at.01 mol/L for all tested metals. The pH decrease from 6.5 to 4 increases the pitting tendency, especially for α-brass. At 0.1 mol/L and neutral pH, the pitting potential (Epit) of the examined systems shifts towards more negative potentials, but the pitting tendency is much lower. The dealloying processes of α-bronze and α-brass under anodic dissolution conditions in 0.1 mol/L NaCl were approached by anodic polarization tests (ΟCP+1.5 V, 0.25 mV/s) and subsequent characterization of the topography and stratigraphy of anodic dissolution products by ΟΜ and systematic SEM-EDS analyses. Through this setup, the influence of micro-segregation to the surface chloride attack, the development of decuprification of α-bronze and the simultaneous development of dezincification and decuprification of α-brass was assessed. The Cu-enriched dendrites of α-bronze act as local anodes and exhibited a higher decuprification rate. The corroded interdendritic areas remain enriched in Sn compared to the average composition of the attacked surface and the more stable corrosion products decrease their dissolution rate. The quaternary α-brass undergoes selective Zn dissolution, which initiates form the dendritic network. The elemental mapping also indicated a polarity reversal of the local galvanic cells at high anodic potentials, due to rapid Zn dissolution from the α-dendrites.The characterization of chemical composition, topography and stratigraphy of α-bronze casting corrosion products in chloride electrolytes, -representing typical corrosive media- was attempted after: (i) immersion tests (with duration between few hours and few days) in0.6 mol/L NaCl solution, (ii) cyclic polarization in the anodic domain in 0.1 mol/L NaCl solution, (iii) anodic polarization (ΟCP+0.6 V, 1 mV/s) in chloride electrolytes (NaCl solutions, Athens urban atmosphere synthetic electrolyte, Piraeus coastal soil electrolyte).The spontaneous electrochemical corrosion products formed after the 72 h immersion 0.6 mol/L NaCl are: (i) Cu2O and CuCl traces for copper, (ii) Sn21Cl16(OH)14O6, intermediate transformation products to Sn3O2(OH)2 and SnO2 for tin, (iii) a mixture of non-stoichiometric Cu2O with amorphous SnO2 and amorphous CuCl for α-bronze. The ex situ characterization via XRD, Raman microscopy and cathodic electrochemical polarization (OCP -1.5V/OCP) points to this conclusion. The characterization of anodic dissolution layer produced in 0.1 mol/L solution, after a cyclic sweep in the anodic domain highlighted a duplex layer consisting of a compact inner layer and a thinner outer layer characterized by a granular external surface. The increased adhesion, the decreased dissolution rate of the corrosion layer as well as the metal substrate and the decreased pitting tendency are attributed to the Sn-enriched inner layer. The characterization of the detached patina internal surface after the anodic dissolution in three synthetic chloride media (seawater, soil filtrate, atmospheric electrolyte) led to the following findings: The corrosive attack initiates from the Cu-enriched edge of the casting towards the center, due to radial macro-segregation. Moreover, the cored dendritic structure in the grains is responsible for the action of local micro-galvanic cells, corresponding to the formation of different corrosion products and variable dealloying rates. The main chemical species of the anodic dissolution products are Cu2(OH)3Cl andCu2(OH)2CO3 compounds.The influence of inorganic N-P-K fertilizers addition to the corrosion rate and anodic dissolution of leaded α-bronze in soil from agricultural area was approached by Τafel tests, anodic polarization measurements (OCP + 0.6V) Thessaly soil filtrates and in aqueous solutions of two types of N-P-K fertilizers ( 0.2, 1, 5, 10 % w/w). The fertilizer aqueous solutions with higher N/P and N/S ratios were related to faster electrochemical attack and to the formation of nitrate and phosphate corrosion products at the alloy surface, leading to the decrease of corrosion rate at higher potential domains. The addition of fertilizers increases the corrosivity of the soil electrolyte at potentials near OCP but could potentially result in the decrease of the corrosion current density and in the increase of polarization resistance (Rp) of leaded α-bronze at high anodic potentials.In the first part of the chapter entitled ‘Chemical synthesis of artificial corrosion products related to bronze disease’ the study of the redox reactions and of the deposited products on alloy surfaces in condensed electrolytes with high Cu cation concentrations was attempted. The chemically attacked surfaces produced by the immersion in CuCl2 solutions (molarities 0.05, 0.1, 0.5 and 1 mol/L, immersions periods of 24 and 72 h) were characterized by vibrational spectroscopy methods (FTIR, Raman). The chloride concentration and pH pH of the CuCl2 did not affect the nature of Cu and Sn corrosion species, but only the quantity of the deposited compounds. The main compounds detected were Cu(I) and Sn(II) chlorides (mainly CuCl and SnCl2·2H2O). In the second part, two different accelerated corrosion protocols (two step procedures) were applied for the production of cuprite (Cu2O) patinas on copper surfaces and and Cu(II) hydroxychlorides (Cu2(OH)3Cl) on copper and the three reference alloy surfaces. The specimens produced by the second protocol were employed for cleaning laboratory tests. The physicochemical characterization of the synthetic patinas was conducted by microscopy and instrumental chemical analyses (XRD, SEM-EDS, XPS, TGA, FTIR, Raman), in order to testify that the artificial products were representative of ‘bronze disease’ compounds and also study the nature of Sn, Zn and Pb compounds.In the chapter entitled ‘Cleaning tests of chloride patinas on archaeometallurgical Cu alloy surfaces – Investigation of possibilities and limitation s in the application of plasma and laser techniques’ small experimental series undertaken with the collaboration of the research groups from the Laboratory of Plasma Physics (NCSR ‘Demokritos’) and the Laboratory of Optoelectronics, Lasers and their Applications (School of Applied Mathematics and Physical Sciences-NTUA) are presented. Cleaning procedures using these two methods have been tested by several scientific groups during the last decades, by applying variations of experimental setups and experimental conditions on both coupons and metallic museum objects made of various metals and alloys.The treatment of Cu2(OH)3Cl patinas of the three reference alloys in atmosphere of hydrogen (H2) glow discharge plasma: (i) led to unacceptable aesthetic results concerning the final patina coloration, (ii) was partly effective in removing chlorides and (iii) was finally considered harmful because the Cu(II) hydroxychlorides transformation to CuCl (along with metallic Cu) under reducing conditions, reactivates the surfaces rendering the object vulnerable to the cyclic phenomenon of ‘bronze disease’. These data were acquired by the evaluation of few hour exposure at a discharge of 200 ° C temperature and 0.9 Torr pressure, as well as low temperature experiments (80°C) conducted with Η2 and subsequently with atmospheric air. The monitoring of the physicochemical changes was achieved by macrophotography, ΟΜ, XRD and SEM-EDS analyses. This procedure is not recommended for the treatment of bronze and brass surfaces with active ‘bronze disease’. Future trials investigating the exposure in a reducing and subsequently in mild oxidative atmosphere is encouraged. The cleaning tests with laser ablation using a Q-switched nanosecond Nd:YAG laser (beam of 1064 nm, pulse duration 6ns) were performed on the same artificial Cu2(OH)3Cl patinas formed on α-brass and leaded α- bronze. Different fluence values and number of 6 ns pulses were tested taking into consideration the specific properties of the two alloys. The monitoring of the physical and chemical changes on the corroded surfaces before and after the local interventions was conducted by macro-photographic documentation and microscopic examination (OM, SEM) combined by elemental EDS analyses. For α-brass satisfactory chloride removal levels and milder thermal and chemical side effects were achieved at a fluence of 1.5 J/cm2, while for leaded bronze the ablation with 0.2 J/cm2 led to partly acceptable results. However, at high magnifications, damages such as local alloy melting were reported. The XPS surface analyses on representative cleaned regions detected Cu+, Cu2+, Pb2+ chemical species, the presence of which indicates an intense chemical activation due to plasma production and sputtering phenomena resulting Pb particles deposition. The thin films of anhydrous and hydrated PbCO3 compounds which were identified are attributed to the chemisorption of CO2 and O2 by the Pb deposited particles. The accumulation of these products was enhanced during exposure in 100% RH. For the experimental series employing α-brass specimens - pre-corroded via a semi-accelerated corrosion protocol in soil – higher fluence values of the laser beam and multiple pulses were considered necessary, in order to achieve the ablation of compact and hard encrustations. The results indicated the lack of selectivity and control regarding the removal of particular corrosion layers, while the ablation of unwanted crusts was not possible without thermal side effects on the metal substrate (blackening and melting at the macro- and micro-scale respectively). For applications of laser ablation on alloys containing low melting point elements, the design of a setup incorporating a cooling stage for the metal objects is recommended. In any case, this method is considered unsuitable for cleaning treatments on leaded bronzes. The innovation of this dissertation is: (i) The documentation for the first time of dezincification mechanisms in archaeometallurgical α-brass. (ii) The description of the initial stages of decuprification and dezincification mechanisms in as-cast archaeometallurgical Cu alloys with macro- and micro-segregation features in chloride media. (iii) The new data regarding the nature of Sn corrosion products evolved in α-bronzes exposed in chloride electrolytes. (iv) The micro-scale documentation of thermal damages and surface chemical changes in leaded α-bronze and α-brass, after laser ablation with Q-switched nanosecond Nd:YAG laser (1064 nm).

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Year dc:date
2023

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Papadopoulou, Olga
  • Παπαδοπούλου, Όλγα

Subjects

dc:subject × 16

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/53859

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Papadopoulou, Olga; Παπαδοπούλου, Όλγα. Διερεύνηση της ηλεκτροχημικής διάβρωσης και αποκραμάτωσης των αρχαιομεταλλουργικών κραμάτων χαλκού: μελέτες περιπτώσεων, εργαστηριακές δοκιμές διάβρωσης και καθαρισμού. National Technical University of Athens (NTUA), 2023. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/53859