Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
Constructions of sexual and gender identities in institutional and everyday discourse: political dimensions, institutional claims and rights
Abstract
dc:descriptionThis PhD thesis explores the argumentative resources, the dilemmas and the identity constructs that emerge in rhetoric about LGBTQI+ community’s claims and rights in political, activist and lay discursive contexts in Greece, as well as the rhetorical and ideological consequences of these constructions. Literature review underscores the diverse claim frames and argumentative resources that have been historically elaborated in the study of LGBTQI+ issues and indicates the multifaceted dilemmas that they stimulate. These include essentialist discourses that favour rigid, continuous and well-defined categories, human rights approaches, usually followed by the assumption of universality, and sexual citizenship perspectives, which politicized LGBTQI+ identities. It is maintained that none of these constructs has escaped tensions and dilemmas, which revolved around their possible embedment in homonormative norms, their unwanted ideological implications (e.g. homonationalism) and the negligence of complexity and power imbalances within the LGBTQI+ community. The research objectives of the present project have been articulated in the light of the aforementioned social scientific and political tensions, taking into account the particularities of the socio-historical context of Greece. Three empirical studies which focused on different discursive contexts were conducted. Each data set was analyzed via the constructs and analytic tools provided by Critical Discursive Social Psychology, which enables the eclectic analysis of both micro- and macro-social components. The first study analyzed a plenary session of the Greek Parliament regarding a bill on gender identity. It showcased the flexible mobilization of the human rights construct and its varied content, boundaries and agency in different argumentative lines oriented to different rhetorical goals. The second study analyzed nine individual interviews with LGBTQI+ activists, indicating varied constructions of “difference” between activists. A positive evaluation of ingroup diversity was grounded on resources drawn from the liberal argumentative “reservoir”. Even when subgroups’ fragmentation was questioned, essentialist accounts constituted divisions as inevitable. However, arguments attentive to power asymmetries pointed to intersectional and collaborative activist objectives. The third study analyzed lay discourse produced in the context of seven focus group discussions on LGBTQI+ issues. This study highlighted lay dilemmas around equality-diversity-difference. Arguments grounded on liberal equality and diversity often aligned with homonormative and homonationalist hierarchies of exclusion between sexual, gender and ethnic categories and even prioritized “unanimous” and “non-provocative” claims and practices. Arguments that stressed the de-radicalizing implications of homonationalism, however, pointed to the need for intersectional claims. Overall, appeals to a reservoir of liberal constructs and principles seem to have (historically contingent) empowering implications. They also entail, however, depoliticizing and normalizing effects. Seeds of social change, on the other hand, necessitate disengagement from (liberal) single identity politics and the simultaneous development of a broader frame attentive to intersecting categories, actively oriented to manage power imbalances and informed by its immediate and distal contexts.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Michos, Ioannis
- Μίχος, Ιωάννης
Subjects
dc:subject × 16- Σεξουαλικές και έμφυλες ταυτότητες
- ΛΟΑΤΚΙ+ δικαιώματα
- Διεκδικήσεις
- Κριτική κοινωνική λογοψυχολογία
- ΛΟΑΤΚΙ+ πολιτική
- Sexual and gender identities
- LGBTQI+ rights
- Claims
- Critical discursive social psychology
- LGBTQI+ politics
- Ψυχολογία και Γνωσιακή Επιστήμη
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Κοινωνική ψυχολογία
- Psychology and Cognitive Sciences
- Social Sciences
- Social Psychology
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/53910