University of Ioannina
Δυνατότητα εφαρμογής ευρημάτων των τυχαιοποιημένων κλινικών δοκιμών στο πεδίο της πρωτοβάθμιας φροντίδας υγείας
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe purpose of this PhD thesis is to assess the applicability of the findings of randomized clinical trials (RCTs) in the field of Primary Health Care (PHC) and more specifically in its subset, Primary Care.The first aim of the PhD thesis was to create an evidence and research gap map in the broad field of primary care, which captures existing evidence and research gaps. For this purpose, a systematic search for RCTs in primary care, published between years 2000 and 2020, was performed. 518 RCTs were identified, which were mapped according to the primary outcome category and for each outcome category, by type of health care (preventive care, acute care, chronic care and palliative care) and type of intervention (drug, behavioral intervention, intervention in the structure and intervention in the process of care). For RCTs assessing patient health outcomes as primary outcomes, we further mapped using the quality-of-care dimensions, that is, effectiveness, safety, and patient-centeredness. 357 trials (68.9%) evaluated a patient health outcome as the primary outcome, and 161 trials (31.1%) evaluated only health services outcomes as primary outcomes. Many focused on population with chronic illness (224 trials; 43.2%) and evaluated a drug (142 trials, 27.4%) and interventions on processes of care (239 trials; 46.1%). Research gaps identified include preventive and palliative care, behavioral interventions, and safety and patient-centeredness outcomes as primary outcomes.The second aim of the PhD thesis was to empirically assess the applicability in primary care RCTs. For this purpose, we used a randomly selected sample of RCTs derived from the 20-year evidence map. We then captured data necessary to address the five pre-defined questions on applicability as suggested by Burford et al. We appraised whether these data were reported adequately, partially, or were totally missing and based on data availability whether the five questions could be adequately addressed in each RCT. We assessed 104 primary care RCTs. More often were adequately described elements, such as the type of setting and location (53, 51%), the time frame (82, 78.8%), study population characteristics (94, 90.4%), the baseline prevalence of the health issue of interest (58, 55.8%), intervention components (89, 85.6%), the responsible organization for intervention provision (97, 93.3%), organization structure (50, 48.1%) and intervention implementation including monitoring and evaluation (92, 88.5%). Contextual factors that were often underreported included health system structure (32, 30.8%), evidence of differential effects across sociodemographic or other groupings (2, 1.9), intervention components tailored for specific settings (7, 6.7%) and factors affecting implementation (35, 33.7%). The proportion of trials that adequately addressed each of the five predefined questions on applicability ranged between 1% and 20.2%. We captured several gaps in reporting essential elements to appraise applicability in PC RCTs, mainly on contextual factors. Quite often are the contextual factors that shape outcomes and explain variability of effectiveness across, or even within, populations and settings. Stakeholders should ask for, while RCT authors should transparent report contextual factors in future studies. Moreover, development of a standardized framework in PC considering these elements should be pursuit.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Ioannina
- Year dc:date
- 2022
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Missiou, Aristea
- Μίσσιου, Αριστέα
Subjects
dc:subject × 11Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/53978