Back to search

University of Thessaly (UTH)

Στα δίκτυα του πρότζεκτ: πολιτικές της γνώσης, τεχνο-λογικές της συνεργασίας και η εθνογραφία της ειδημοσύνης

Abstract

dc:description

The "project" is examined in this dissertation as a modern form of organization and a technology of governance, which, originating from the field of management, has penetrated most spheres of human activity. Hence the claim of Jensen et al. about the "projectification of everything" (2016). Research activity is no exception. Through my ethnographic field, I examine the European Union's policy frameworks for research, as a regulatory and normative framework for research projects of fixed, usually three-year, duration. Specifically, through the analysis of discourses and practices of the European research project in which I took part as an ethnographer, I detect what is required and what can emerge within/from a project: what kind of relationships, subjectivities and practices, material imprints and forms of knowledge. I attribute a central role, in terms of project processes, to the mechanism of audit/review, evaluation and accountability of European research projects. It is in relation to this mechanism that the agency of actors participating in projects is revealed, tested and performed. The diffusion of projectification has historically coincided with the rise of "audit cultures" (Strathern 2000). Nowadays we find the two interrelated technologies normalized everywhere. There is no funded project without some kind of audit and accountability mechanism. I argue that, consequently, there is no project without indebtedness. For this reason, I attach great importance to debt for the analysis of relations and subjectification processes in/through projects (Lazzarato 2012).One of the main arguments of this dissertation is that the policies and frameworks of the E.U. for research borrow from and resemble the ideology, rhetoric and practices of development aid programs. I contend that, whether it is a health, agricultural and/or sustainable development project, or a research and development one, of the E.U. or of any other supranational organization, certain central parameters are present: the hegemonic economistic ideology of the "one-world" world of the respective (normative and) regulatory framework, the audit/review-evaluation-accountability mechanism, the use of ambiguous and de-radicalized concepts (sustainability, participation, empowerment, etc.) which indicate dominant logics and chronotopes (such as progress through techno-economic solutions), a "harmonious" way of forming relations based on consensus, the necessary expert managerial "project class" (Csurgó et al. 2008), the equally necessary groups of non-expert "beneficiaries", and the hierarchy - which includes and excludes as it is reproduced - associated with produced knowledge. This analysis traces the power relations and technologies of governance by which certain entities, types of artefacts, worldviews and concepts dominate and determine others, and identifies the mechanisms and techniques through which processes of dominance are enacted and (/also because they are) concealed. I argue that, as it is governed by and enforces a post-political framework of action, project technology requires and shapes subjectivities with traits that are compatible with—and in any case not encouraged to challenge—hegemonic, neoliberal (and) market logics. Most times, the various problems are identified, solutions are proposed and new problems are posed through implicit ideological assumptions and banal epistemological perspectives. Research projects consortia typically adopt the techno-economistic principles of the regulatory framework, already at the stage of creating and submitting their research proposal. As a result, project participants are (re)produced as (autonomous, responsible) project actors which interrelate as nodes connecting in a network, and produce heterogeneous, watertight and politically "non-threatening" packages of knowledge in the form of deliverables. In the Afterword I discuss the relation between the contemporary occupational precariousness of researchers and the production of "precarious knowledge" (Kelty 2018: 12), disconnected from the social conditions within which it has been produced, insufficiently reflective, meaningless. I also discuss possible tactics of resistance, specifically of research workers, against the seemingly inescapable - subjectifying and indebting - mechanisms of projectification.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of Thessaly (UTH)
Year dc:date
2023

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Papageorgiou, Alexandros
  • Παπαγεωργίου, Αλέξανδρος

Subjects

dc:subject × 75

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/53998

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Papageorgiou, Alexandros; Παπαγεωργίου, Αλέξανδρος. Στα δίκτυα του πρότζεκτ: πολιτικές της γνώσης, τεχνο-λογικές της συνεργασίας και η εθνογραφία της ειδημοσύνης. University of Thessaly (UTH), 2023. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/53998