University of the Aegean
The contribution of area-based fisheries management measures to fisheries sustainability and marine conservation
Abstract
dc:descriptionArea-based management approaches have been widely recognised as a valuable means of sustainably exploiting coastal and marine resources. A variety of area-based management tools exists worldwide under various jurisdictions, spanning from tools regulating specific human activities (e.g., fisheries, shipping, or mining) to multi-sectoral or cross-sectoral tools, such as Marine Protected Areas (MPAs) and Marine Spatial Plans. Notably, international processes such as the United Nations 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) Strategic Plan 2010-2020, the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework, and the EU Biodiversity Strategy for 2030 have committed to the use of area-based management approaches. As defined by the CBD, Area-based Fisheries Management Measures (ABFMs) are formally established, spatially defined fishery management and/ or conservation measures, implemented to achieve one or more specific fishery objectives. Applied currently in most contemporary fisheries management plans and regulations, their outcomes are commonly related to the sustainable use of resources. However, they are increasingly considered broader conservation measures, especially when their implementation protects ecological features or mitigates fisheries’ impacts on biodiversity or ecosystem structure and functioning. ABFMs promote primary, secondary, or ancillary forms of conservation contingent upon their objectives. ABFMs advance primary or secondary conservation outcomes when the conservation benefits produced align with their intended and explicit primary or secondary objectives respectively. Ancillary conservation is facilitated by ABFMs when the management measures are explicitly intended to support the sustainable harvest of the target species but, at the same time, de facto reduce pressure on biodiversity and ecosystem functioning. ABFMs promoting ancillary forms of conservation may be considered Other Effective Area-Based Conservation Measures (OECMs) according to the definition of the CBD Decision 14/8, i.e., non-protected areas, which achieve positive long-term outcomes for the protection of biodiversity and associated ecosystem services, functions, and other locally relevant social or economic values. OECMs can contribute to the attainment of Target 14.5 of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development and Target 3 of the CBD Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework. According to the latter, specific actions must be taken by 2030 to ensure that at least 30 per cent of land and sea areas globally are conserved through ecologically representative, effectively and equitably managed, and well-connected networks of Protected Areas and OECMs. The objectives of this thesis are to: 1. Identify and map the current distribution of spatiotemporal restrictions on fishing activities in the Aegean Sea and Crete, and provide scientific documentation for fisheries policy research, decision-making, monitoring, control, and enforcement. Also, critically examine the national fisheries' legal framework concerning these restrictions and identify and discuss its weaknesses. 2. Develop a methodological approach for assessing the extent to which Fisheries Restricted Areas (FRAs) may contribute to marine conservation. The Aegean Sea is used as a case study area to assess the degree of attainment of Aichi Biodiversity Target 11 by considering both officially designated MPAs and potential OECMs. The goal is to assist marine managers and decision-makers in the region in their efforts to achieve spatial conservation targets. Also, to support the strategic decision-making in recognising OECMs by developing an operational framework for applying the IUCN-World Commission on Protected Areas (WCPA) OECMs guidelines, through a multi-criteria decision analysis based on expert judgement. 3. Identify, map, and summarise the existing evidence on how ABFMs applied exclusively for fisheries management have contributed to fisheries sustainability and area-based marine conservation. Also, investigate how the ABFMs' contribution to fisheries sustainability and marine conservation has been assessed and the methodologies employed in relevant research. Knowledge gaps will be identified and discussed. 4. Compile the recommendations proposed globally in the literature for effective area-based fisheries management. This compilation will provide key science-informed recommendations for policymakers, marine managers, and researchers for guiding efforts to rebuild fisheries and conserve marine biodiversity in alignment with the CBD Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework. To accomplish the stated objectives, this thesis undertook the following tasks: 1. Conducted an up-to-date systematic review and unofficial codification of the national fisheries legislation. Additionally, an up-to-date systematic review of environmental, archaeological, and maritime legislation related to spatiotemporal restrictions on fishing activities, by all fishing gears, in the Aegean Sea and Crete was carried out (Chapter 2). This included a review of spatio-temporal restrictions established by the European Union and the General Fisheries Commission for the Mediterranean. A comprehensive database was built, including detailed information on the identified FRAs. All FRAs were mapped, as polygons in Geographic Information System shapefiles. The national fisheries, environmental, archaeological, and maritime legal framework encompassed 32, 2, 37 and 43 legal acts respectively; EU and GFCM legislation consisted of one Regulation and one Recommendation, respectively. A total of 521 FRAs were identified in the study area with 511 being national (254 established by fisheries, 21 by environmental, 85 by archaeological and 151 by maritime legislation), 6 being EU and 4 being international FRAs. Most (85.2%) of these FRAs were in the Aegean Sea, with the remaining 14.8% in Crete. Towed or mobile gears were restricted in 88.5% of the FRAs, while static gears were restricted in only 10.2% of the FRAs. The primary reasons for regulating fishing activities were the protection of fish stocks (25.3%) and Posidonia oceanica beds (25.0%). Most FRAs (85.4%) imposed permanent closures. National fisheries, environmental, archaeological, maritime, EU and international FRAs covered 25.8%, 1.0%, 1.1%, 0.4%, 13.5% and 22.6% of the study area, respectively. The compiled and produced information is valuable for fisheries managers in reconsidering the establishment of spatio-temporal restrictions on fishing activities, under the provisions of the Common Fisheries Policy and the EU framework for Maritime Spatial Planning. 2. Developed an operational framework to assess the value of FRAs for marine conservation (Chapter 3). This framework contributes to the wider concept of considering OECMs, as complementing conservation efforts and substantially contributing to effectively and equitably achieving Aichi Biodiversity Target 11. A tailor-multi-criteria decision analysis was designed and applied to assess potential OECMs on a case-by-case basis, categorising them according to their effectiveness in contributing to marine biodiversity conservation. This operational framework adhered to the official documentation and guidance provided by the IUCN, serving as a role model for managers and decision-makers in assessing the contribution of FRAs to marine conservation under the OECM concept. This study also offers a review of the conservation status of the Aegean Sea, providing scientific documentation to guide managers and decision-makers in addressing spatial conservation targets. By considering marine Natura 2000 sites as effective MPAs, Aichi Target 11 is achieved (14.94%) at the national level (i.e., within the Greek territorial waters). At the ecoregional level (i.e., including international waters of the Aegean Sea) the target is not achieved (6.66%). It is proposed that, by adding all effective FRAs and several less effective FRAs, under the condition of increasing their effectiveness for conservation, into the network of MPAs and recognising them as OECMs, the conservation target can also be attained at the ecoregional level.3. Conducted a Scoping Review (ScR) to identify and map the evidence base regarding the contribution of ABFMs to fisheries sustainability and marine conservation. The ScR followed the Joanna Briggs Institute methodology and the PRISMA statement. A total of 2,391 documents were identified, and following a two-stage screening process, 151 documents were eventually included in the ScR for full review and data extraction. Most documents were published within the last 12 years. Studies had a wide geographical distribution (mainly located in Europe and North America), were primarily conducted at the subnational level, concerned fishing restrictions of towed gears, and assessed ABFMs from a single stock's perspective. Various types of ABFMs were identified, but the use of terminology was inconsistent in the literature. Diverse data collection (primarily experimental surveys/sampling and open data sources) and analysis methods (most commonly, fisheries and ecological analyses and modelling) were applied, often in combination, using various metrics. Knowledge gaps emerged, mainly related to the study of ABFMs networks and the application of an interdisciplinary and ecosystem-based approach in assessing ABFMs. The social, economic, and environmental impact of ABFMs was positive in most cases (56%) and in fewer cases negative (22%) or mixed (14%). This ScR serves as a valuable source for understanding the contribution of ABFMs to rebuilding marine ecosystems and achieving CBD conservation targets through the OECM concept. 4. Undertook a mini-review aimed at providing key recommendations to guide the science-based implementation of effective ABFMs for rebuilding fisheries and conserving marine biodiversity in the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework era. This review capitalised on the previous ScR, recording a total of 232 recommended actions. Most of these recommendations pertained to informed and more effective area-based management (n=115) and improved ABFM planning (n=70). Fewer recommendations focused on transparent and inclusive area-based management (n=25) and accountability for and responsiveness to change (n=22). For effective area-based fisheries management, the following actions were recommended: (1) apply informed and more effective management by collecting more, updated and high-quality data, adjusting management measures to research findings, developing regular monitoring schemes and comprehensive management plans, applying interdisciplinary research and reinforcing ABFMs control and surveillance; (2) improve ABFMs planning by considering the complexity of marine ecosystems and interactions between their components and uses, combining ABFMs with other measures, considering socio-economic aspects, designing connective, representative and comprehensive ABFMs and considering ABFMs applicability and transferability; (3) support transparent and inclusive management by reinforcing cooperation across different levels of government and sectors, supporting transparent and equitable governance and increased participation of key stakeholders; and (4) account for and be responsive to change by applying adaptive and dynamic ABFMs and considering climate variation and change. This thesis intends to provide fisheries managers and policymakers with insights into the evidence-based knowledge about ABFMs and contribute to the policy discussion on where an ABFM should be positioned along the continuum of “effectiveness” to qualify as an OECM and contribute, together with MPAs, to the attainment of the CBD spatial targets.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of the Aegean
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Petza, Dimitra
- Πέτζα, Δήμητρα
Subjects
dc:subject × 47- Άλλα αποτελεσματικά χωρικά μέτρα διατήρησης
- Αλιευτική νομοθεσία
- Αλιευτική πολιτική
- Ανασκόπηση σκοπιμότητας
- Βιώσιμη αλιεία
- Διαχείριση της αλιείας βάσει επιστημονικών στοιχείων
- Θαλάσσια διατήρηση
- Θαλάσσια προστατευόμενη περιοχή
- Θαλάσσιος χωροταξικός σχεδιασμός
- Οικοσυστημική προσέγγιση για την αλιευτική διαχείριση
- Παγκόσμιο πλαίσιο για τη βιοποικιλότητα
- Περιοχή περιορισμού αλιείας
- Πολυκριτηριακή ανάλυση αποφάσεων
- Στόχος “30 μέχρι το 30”
- Στρατηγική για τη βιοποικιλότητα της ΕΕ
- Χωρική θαλάσσια διαχείριση
- Χωρικό μέτρο αλιευτικής διαχείρισης
- Area-based fisheries management measure (ABFM)
- Area-based marine conservation
- Global biodiversity framework (GBF)
- Ecosystem approach to fisheries management (EAFM)
- EU biodiversity strategy
- Fisheries policy
- Fisheries restricted area (FRA)
- Fisheries sustainability
- Marine conservation
- Marine protected area (MPA)
- Maritime spatial planning (MSP)
- Multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA)
- Other effective area-based conservation measure (OECM)
- Science-based fisheries management
- Scoping review (ScR)
- Target “30 by 30”
- Γεωεπιστήμες και Επιστήμες Περιβάλλοντος
- Φυσικές Επιστήμες
- Επιστήμες περιβάλλοντος
- Ωκεανογραφία
- Βιολογία
- Θαλάσσια βιολογία και Βιολογία γλυκών υδάτων
- Διατήρηση της βιοποικιλότητας
- Earth and Related Environmental Sciences
- Natural Sciences
- Environmental Sciences
- Oceanography
- Biological Sciences
- Marine and Freshwater Biology
- Biodiversity Conservation
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/54092