Democritus University of Thrace (DUTH)
The interpretation of the 1951 convention for the protection of refugees by Greece and Turkey after the Syrian refugee crisis
Abstract
dc:descriptionAt this time, approximately 70.8 million people have been forced from their homes around the world, and one person is forcibly displaced every two seconds as a result of conflict or persecution. In a context of rampant – and global – xenophobia, internal and international displacement remains an important issue.The Mediterranean has become the world’s most deadly crossing point for migrants. In 2015, there were 856,732 recorded arrivals in Greece as well as an estimated total of more than 6,600 missing persons or deaths in the Central and Eastern Mediterranean routes in 2015 and the first half of 2016. The aim of this research is to assess how Greece has responded to this influx, and identify lessons for addressing large scale refugee movements at a European and global level.Based on research and fieldwork in Greece, mainly in Athens and Lesvos and Turkey, this thesis focuses on the critical period 2015 until nowadays with main emphasis to the critical period of October 2015-May 2016, which saw high flows of asylum seekers into Greece and predates the EU-Turkey deal signed in March 2016 until nowadays. The research focuses on the ways in which the Greek and Turkish government as well as the EU struggled to address the “crisis” during that period, outlining the challenges of implementing sustainable solutions and efficient policies given the obstacles at national and European level. In particular, it focuses on the island of Lesvos, the main entry point of refugees from Turkey to Greece, and the island’s reception capacity. The findings highlight the need for a more effective common asylum system in the EU that includes adequate support and assistance to frontline states and makes suggestions for preventing future crises in situations of large-scale arrivals from third countries to the EU border countries. Relations between Greece and Turkey have long been contentious, despite sharing a common history and situation as a border country in the Mediterranean region. Moreover, both have been asked to find solutions to the refugee crisis since 2015. My research focuses on the extent to which each state takes responsibility and fulfills their obligations under the 1951 Geneva Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees, commonly called the Refugee Convention. The innovation of the research is that the author attempts to examine Greek-Turkey relations under the prism of the Refugee Convention after the Syrian influx, through a comparative study based on field work via interviews with refugees, refugee communities, local communities, policy makers and activists from field visits in Greece and Turkey (during the period 2015 until nowadays). The thesis examines the refugee protection mechanisms in the two countries and how protection norms were implemented by both Greece and Turkey in terms of effectiveness and efficiency for refugees, reception conditions and integration processes. Additionally, the role of EU and UN mechanisms and how they influenced Greek-Turkey relations at a bilateral level are further examined. My main argument is that the EU policies implemented in Greece and Turkey (including containment, externalization, dehumanisation (process of offshoring or extra territorialisation) and shifting responsibility for refugees to a “safe” third country led to violations of refugee rights with the implementation of the infamous EU-Turkey deal/statement, criminalisation and massive deportations based on the logic of exchanging money for refugee containment resulting to state responsibility and accountability. The usual problem with off shoring is that applicants are subjected to a much-restricted process in terms of due process and protection . Those fleeing armed conflict and other human rights violations will not simply stop coming just because politicians try to outdo themselves with empty rhetoric while failing to full international obligations they would prefer to impose on other, less well-off states. Humanitarian issues thereby became part of accession negotiations for Turkey and developed into a highly politicized issue that the author criticizes. The author further argues that the political decision of the EU-Turkey deal signature does not fulfil European and international legal standards of refugee rights. Finally, a strong and sincere cooperation between Greece and Turkey, based on human rights and refugee protection norms, would benefit both the region and refugees.The author concludes that both Greece and Turkey accepted the restrictive policy instruments and policies for various reasons each. Displacement and policy responses to this phenomenon is not about nationality of refugees and politicization of the refugee issue but how states and the international community are handling issues of displacement, migration and mobility, with recommendations for EU, Greek and Turkish policy makers.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Democritus University of Thrace (DUTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2022
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Velentza, Christina
- Βελέντζα, Χριστίνα
Subjects
dc:subject × 32- Σύροι πρόσφυγες
- Διεθνής προστασία
- 1951 σύμβαση για τους πρόσφυγες
- Ελληνοτουρκικές σχέσεις
- Εξωτερίκευση ευθύνης
- Σύνορα
- Λέσβος
- Κέντρα κράτησης
- Ύπατη αρμοστεία για τους πρόσφυγες
- Συμμόρφωση του κράτους και Παραβιάσεις
- Δημόσιο διεθνές δίκαιο
- Ανθρώπινα δικαιώματα
- Ευρωτουρκική συμφωνία
- Syrian refugees
- International protection framework
- 1951 convention relating to the status of refugees
- Greece Turkey relations
- Externalization
- Borders
- Lesvos
- Detention camps
- UNHCR
- State compliance and violations
- International law
- Human rights
- EU-Turkey deal
- -
- Νομική Επιστήμη
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Δίκαιο
- Law
- Social Sciences
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/54322