Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
Ηθικό αδιέξοδο και ματαιότητα της θεραπείας από τη σκοπιά των ιατρών μονάδων εντατικής νοσηλείας νεογνών και των γονέων των νοσηλευόμενων νεογνών: ποιοτική μελέτη
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe moral distress of neonatologists is widely reported in the literature both in terms of the original definition that includes obstacles and limitations, and in the broader sense of uncertainty. This specific qualitative study investigated the phenomenon of moral distress in NICUs, with a focus on the duo neonatologist - mother of a newborn, with the aim of understanding the way in which the moral distress is perceived and evaluated by the two parties who have a central role in dealing with the ethical dilemmas that are raised during the hospitalization of a newborn in the NICU. Factors favoring the emergence of moral distress among neonatologists are the lack of previous experience in the management of cases with strong bioethical concern, the absence of clear and adequate clinical practice guidelines and the lack of health care resources in NICUs. Additional factors causing a moral distress for neonatologists are the need to make morally critical decisions under time pressure, within the morally charged context of NICUs, where the best interest and the prognosis for the future outcome and quality of life of severely ill neonates are sometimes difficult to determine. Regarding the moral distress of parents, there is a relatively limited bibliographic reference. However, the present study revealed its existence as a separate entity for the parents who experienced the traumatic experience of the hospitalization of their seriously ill newborn in the NICU. Medical paternalism was recognized by the mothers as a factor that can lead to the genesis of parental moral distress. However, it was characterized as mild and "beneficial" paternalism, which, while strongly experienced at the beginning, was later reduced. The quality of communication between parents and neonatologists appeared to be a determining factor for the development of moral distress in mothers. The degree of parental involvement in decision-making was determined by the mothers themselves and varied on a case-by-case basis based on their religious values and existential beliefs. The shared decision-making process centered on the patient and the family, emerged from the study as the most effective method of decision-making and as a way to alleviate the moral distress of limitation and uncertainty on both sides of neonatologists and parents. The strict regulations of NICUs, preventing mothers from offering their own milk, care and affection through contact to their child while visiting the NICU, led to the experience of moral distress of restriction. Furthermore, among the factors that caused moral distress to mothers were the limited health resources in the NICU such as shortages of materials or personnel, the uncertainty of doctors about the safety and results of the proposed treatment as well as the limited trust of mothers in neonatologists due to poor communication between them. Conversely, building a sense of good communication, empathy, respect and trust between doctors and mothers, reduced parental uncertainty, and consequently the risk of developing moral uncertainty distress. Factors that strengthened mothers' trust in neonatologists were the doctors' genuine interest, their responsibility, dedication to their work duty, and respect for parents' beliefs and values. Virtues of neonatologists, such as practical wisdom (phronesis), empathy and the skill of effective communication with colleagues and with parents, played an essential role in reducing the moral distress in mothers of newborns but also in neonatologists themselves and their colleagues . The concept of futile treatment was recognized by most neonatologists to be vague and strongly influenced by their personal and religious beliefs. Another finding of the study was the emergence of the concept of parental moral schism, as an extreme type of uncertainty moral distress that is not related to limitations. This is a significant, internal struggle with personal values due to a genuine uncertainty on the part of the parent about which decision best serves the best interests of the newborn. Finally, the upgrade of the role of bioethics committees, and the need for training in the management of cases with extreme uncertainty as well as psychological support on a regular basis from an interdisciplinary team of the nursing institution where they work, were presented as a request of the neonatologists.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Deligianni, Maria
- Δεληγιάννη, Μαρία
Subjects
dc:subject × 16- Ηθικό αδιέξοδο
- Μάταιη θεραπεία
- Μονάδες εντατικής νοσηλείας νεογνών
- Moral distress
- Futile treatment
- Neonatal intensive care units (NICU)
- Επιστήμες Υγείας
- Ιατρική και Επιστήμες Υγείας
- Επιστήμες υγείας, γενικά
- Κλινική Ιατρική
- Παιδιατρική, Νεογνολογία και Υγεία του παιδιού
- Health Sciences
- Medical and Health Sciences
- Health sciences, general
- Clinical Medicine
- Pediatrics, Perinatology and Child Health
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/54324