Back to search

Athens University Economics and Business (AUEB)

Leadership by metaphors and storytelling

Abstract

dc:description

Metaphors and storytelling are important communication tools that bear a significant role in leadership and organizational life. Furthermore, they are widely considered powerful tools that can be utilized for the enhancement of leadership effectiveness. Leaders have used metaphors and storytelling to enhance their written and verbal communication from ancient times since Aristotle to the modern age. In fact history has recorded numerous cases where leaders (be it company or country leaders) have resorted to using them in order to more effectively and clearly convey their thoughts, captivate, and convince their audience, under normal situations, as well as in times of crisis. Accordingly, in the present research we focus on the use of storytelling and metaphors by leaders within corporate settings, as well as by country leaders in times of crisis. Aiming to contribute to the field of leadership through metaphors and storytelling, we conducted three research studies (Studies 1, 2, & 3) in the context of this thesis. Studies 1 and 2 were case studies, through which the utilization of metaphors and storytelling by country (political) leaders was examined in the context of two crises (a health crisis and a war conflict). Study 3 was a questionnaire survey study, where executives in Greek companies participated, in order to ascertain the effect of transformational leadership, the use of metaphors, and the use of storytelling by leaders, on the persuasiveness of leaders towards their subordinates. Different categories and taxonomies of metaphors and stories have been suggested in the literature. Moreover, several different types of metaphors and stories with different foci and content have been used in leaders’ discourse during crises in the past. In the context of studies 1 and 2, we investigated the following research question: “What types of metaphors and storytelling techniques do political leaders use in contemporary times of crises, and to what extent? Does the intensity with which political leaders use metaphors and stories fluctuate based on the severity of the crisis faced?”. Accordingly, we adopted a case study research methodology to analyze the statements of two country leaders in contemporary times of crisis as per their content in different types of metaphors and stories (both qualitatively, as well as quantitatively). Both cases were selected purposefully, as they represented cases where the successfulness of the communication strategy followed was widely and internationally acknowledged and acclaimed. Moreover, as existing taxonomies offer different perspectives that have found use in past studies within the same context, in this study we have constructed and utilize our own respective taxonomies of metaphors and stories by combining and synthesizing different views towards better categorizing the use of metaphors and stories by political leaders in specific. In Study 1 we perform an analysis of the public statements and addresses of the prime-minister of Greece during the Covid-19 health crisis. Similarly, in Study 2 we perform an analysis of the public statements and addresses of the president of Ukraine in the outbreak of the conflict of 2022. Based on existing evidence, their effectiveness in convincing their subordinates and conveying their intended meaning either nationally or internationally during the forementioned crises has been widely recognized. Our analysis reveals that both leaders have consistently utilized metaphors and storytelling in their efforts to be more convincing and empowering. We also find that the higher the intensity of the crisis, the more pronounced the use of metaphors and stories. We accordingly provide an analysis of the types and frequency of use for the forementioned communication tools. Reflecting on our findings, we provide specific insight for practice by leaders, discuss theoretical implications, and suggest directions for future research. Having confirmed the fact that persuasive leaders use metaphors and stories in times of crises in the context of studies 1 and 2, in Study 3 we went on to test the causality in these relationships. More specifically, we decided to test the hypothesis that the utilization of metaphors and stories by leaders positively affects their persuasiveness towards their subordinates. Moreover, bearing in mind the fact that literature suggests that transformational leaders have reportedly used metaphors and stories in their communication, we also went on to test the hypothesis that transformational leadership is positively correlated with the utilization of metaphors and stories. Finally, based on existing insight from the literature, we also decided to confirm the hypothesis that transformational leadership is correlated with Persuasion. To test our hypotheses, we conducted a questionnaire survey with N=149 employees (the majority of which in executive positions) in Greece. Reviewing the correlations between our researched variables and the demographic characteristics of our sample we found that the older the participant, the less transformational their leader. We also found that the older the participant, the less probable that their leader would employ storytelling, while the larger the organization where they were employed, the less stories their leader would utilize. At the same time, we found an indication that the larger the organization where the participants were employed, the less persuasive their leader was. A subsequent analysis of the inter-correlations between the constructs included in our research model revealed that the more transformational a leader is perceived, the more stories and metaphors they use, and the more persuasive they are towards their subordinates. Moreover, the more metaphors and stories a leader utilizes, the more persuasive they are towards their subordinates. Finally, we also found that leaders who employ metaphors in their discourse tended to also employ storytelling (and vice-versa). Further to the examination of the correlations between constructs, we proceeded to conduct a multiple linear regression to test our hypothesized model, which included transformational leadership, the utilization of metaphors, and the utilization of storytelling by leaders. The model explained 60.12 per cent of the variance in persuasiveness of leaders towards their subordinates. Moreover, we found that out of the three predicting variables, transformational leadership makes the largest unique contribution, storytelling also made a statistically significant contribution, while the contribution of metaphors to the model was much smaller, and non-statistically significant. Therefore, based on all the attained results in Study 3, we propose that leaders should exhibit both the characteristics of transformational leadership, as well as strive to utilize metaphors and storytelling in their organizational routines, in order to more optimally persuade their subordinates. Our findings from Studies 1 & 2 contribute to existing theory in four ways. First, combining insight from existing taxonomies, we have provided two taxonomies – a taxonomy of metaphors and a taxonomy of stories – that can be utilized in the context of studies that analyze the utilization of metaphors and storytelling, especially by leaders. Second, we have confirmed and provided additional support for the fact that, as already evident by past research, political leaders indeed use metaphors and storytelling in times of crises. Moreover, we have provided evidence that this fact remains true, and that metaphors and storytelling continue to remain relevant in the contemporary setting. Third, we have provided insight with regards to the types of metaphors and stories that have successfully been used by leaders in times of crises to engage and motivate. Finally, our research has added to existing literature, by providing evidence that the use of these tools (metaphors and storytelling) by leaders becomes more intense, as the situations of the crisis faced intensify. This insight may be used by researchers, in order to conduct similar investigations in the future, taking into account both the types of metaphors and/or stories that can be investigated in analyses of leaders’ communication patterns. Our findings from Study 3 contribute to existing theory in four ways. First, by providing an examination of the of the combined effect of the leader's use of metaphors and storytelling on persuasiveness. Past studies have examined the effect of metaphors and storytelling in separation, while the insight has mainly been qualitative. Second, we provide an assessment of the combined effect of transformational leadership, in combination with the utilization of both metaphors and stories on leaders’ persuasiveness. To our knowledge, this is the first study where this combined effect is studied. Third, we provide a quantitative assessment of the correlation between the utilization of metaphors and stories by leaders, as well as the correlation between transformational leadership and the utilization of both these communicational tools. Although past research has shed light on examples of transformational leaders that have utilized metaphors and storytelling, such a quantitative connection has, to our knowledge, not been attempted in the past. Moreover, as the utilization of metaphors and stories was correlated for leaders, this leads us to deduce that leaders who use metaphors tend to also use storytelling (and vice versa). Fourth, examining the effect of transformational leadership, combined with the utilization of metaphors and storytelling, on leaders’ persuasiveness, we have uncovered an overshadowing effect of storytelling and transformational leadership on metaphors' contribution to leaders' persuasiveness. This has allowed us to deduce that in view of the effect of the utilization of storytelling by transformational leaders, the statistical significance of the use of metaphors ceases to exist. Apart from their theoretical value, our findings from Studies 1 and 2 also bear significant practical contribution. First, the taxonomy of metaphors and stories that we provide, can be utilized in order to organize and articulate the delivery of speeches by leaders in the future. Moreover, the types of metaphors and stories that, based on our analysis, have been successfully utilized in contemporary crises by leaders, can also be utilized by leaders, towards more successfully conveying the intended meaning, as well as convincing, and attaining their intended results, especially when facing future crises. Therefore, apart from the prescription to utilize metaphors and storytelling, they can gain insight as per what types of metaphors and stories to use, as well as how intensely. Moreover, according to our findings, in times of crisis future leaders would gain by employing both metaphors and storytelling with increasing intensity/frequency according to the severity of the situation faced, to gain the trust and convince their audience towards supporting their decisions, as well as earning their support towards a shared cause. At the same time, should the audience share common backgrounds (such as culture, or religion), it is also suggested that the theme of the metaphors and stories employed by the leaders should be shaped to fit their audiences’ shared cultural/ethnic/religious/historical background and/or shared values and beliefs. The attained results from Study 3 also bear their respective practical contribution accordingly. According to our findings, we find that leaders who aim to increase their persuasiveness towards their subordinates, should strive to be transformational, as well as utilize metaphors and stories. However, owing to the overshadowing effect of adhering to the behaviours of transformational leadership and utilizing storytelling, over the importance of utilizing metaphors, our findings prescribe that transformational leaders should strive to include more storytelling in their discourse above and before the utilization of metaphors. In essence, this provides evidence that using stories may be more effective and impactful for transformational leaders than using metaphors. However, the utilization of both metaphors and storytelling still remains impactful on persuasion and leaders should examine utilizing both means of expression in their organizational communication.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Athens University Economics and Business (AUEB)
Year dc:date
2023

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Gkalitsiou, Aikaterini
  • Γκαλίτσιου, Αικατερίνη

Subjects

dc:subject × 12

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/54349

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Gkalitsiou, Aikaterini; Γκαλίτσιου, Αικατερίνη. Leadership by metaphors and storytelling. Athens University Economics and Business (AUEB), 2023. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/54349