University of Patras
Πολιτική οικονομία και φυσικό περιβάλλον: μια κριτική θεώρηση της κλασικής, μαρξιστικής και νεοκλασικής ανάλυσης
Abstract
dc:descriptionWith the present analysis, an attempt is made, first of all, to investigate the way in which nature is included in the theoretical systems of the School of Classical Political Economy, Marxian and Orthodox (Neoclassical) Economic Theory. The concept of (relative) independence of nature is introduced. Nature is a source of land rent for landowners and a key factor in increasing labor productivity and capital profitability. However, it is (relatively) independent from capital, nature is not produced in its entirety by the capital’s production process. It enters to capitalist or non-capitalist production processes regardless of whether or not transformational processes exist. However, it does not enter in any case directly and immediately into the productive processes of capital. Based on the degree of independence of nature from the production processes of capital, the views of Physiocrats and Adam Smith, David Ricardo and Thomas Malthus are discussed. According to Physiocrats there is a perception where nature is relatively independent from capital and economic-technological development. Nature partially loses its independence as the natural fertility of the land is transformed by the introduction of capitalist relations of production in agriculture. The transformation of nature is demonstrated in their economic policy proposals for extensive fixed capital investments in agriculture under conditions dominated by capitalist relations of production. However, the beneficial influence of nature is exhausted exclusively in agriculture, as they ignore that nature is a factor of development and enhancement of labor productivity for other sectors such as industry. Smith embraces some of the views of the Naturalists, since both downplay – except for agriculture – the influence of natural conditions in areas of production such as industry (manufacture). In his theory of rent, Smith recognizes the relative independence of nature and its potential for transformation by capital. The size of the rent depends on the natural fertility and location of the land. Contrary to the theory of differential rent, rent is a part of price and a result (not a cause) of the difference between the market price and the production price of the individual capital. Smith found that rent is the result of either the exceptional fertility of the land – leading to a greater value of agricultural goods – or it comes from increased demand, which causes a higher price/value and correspondingly the appearance of rent. Physiocrats were oriented towards a similar, “contradictory”, interpretation, as they pointed out that the origin of the “surplus” is sometimes found in demand and sometimes in the exceptional land’s fertility-productivity. On the other hand, Malthus with the principle of population and the theory of (differential) rent recognizes the absolute independence of nature from capital production processes and economic-technological development – considering that any technological progress does not ultimately inhibit the operation of the “law” of diminishing returns. Nature is a condition for the development of human society but also a factor in economic difficulties, due to the effect of the “law” of diminishing returns. Malthusian conclusions found agreement with David Ricardo. The latter accepted the assumptions of uncontrolled population growth, as well as the “law” of diminishing returns, concluding that nature, through the effect of diminishing returns, is a factor of economic stagnation and economic crisis, especially under the dominance of specific political conditions, such as the embargo on the importation of grain. Thus, he recognizes the existence of absolute natural limits in agricultural production, despite technological developments. Marxian analysis points out the multiplicity of nature-capital interaction. Nature, in its totality, cannot be produced by the production process of capital itself and at the same time undergoes the transformative effect of economic relations. It is relatively independent of capital and economic-technological development. Based on the above reasoning, two forms of “natural limits” in the production process are analyzed: a) metabolic rift between human production and its natural conditions caused by the continuous, spatial expansion and development of capital and the violation of natural laws of life and exchange of matter, b) eco-regulation which is a natural process of preservation, regulation and reproduction rather than transformation, in which labor that is carried out concerns the optimization of the conditions of transformation, which are organic processes not amenable to intentional modification in the context of production. On the other hand, Marxist views of the “social construction of nature” and the production of a “second nature” accept the absolute subordination of nature to the production processes of capital, question the relative independence of nature and the class (capitalist) context of technology and emphasize the potential substitution of natural resources by available technology, just as neoclassical economic theory suggests. At the opposite end of the problem of natural limits is the neoclassical economic theory which in its basic “microeconomic” foundation accepts the possibility of infinite solutions of productive substitution of the “factors of production” (in the convex part of an equal product curve). Economists such as Robert Solow and Joseph Stiglitz have argued that the world can get by without natural resources, while technical change can compensate for a gradual decline of the input of natural resources. In addition, neoclassical economic theory of (negative) externalities recognizes the inability of the market price mechanism to automatically “internalize” negative externalities in the polluter's prices and achieve the optimal allocation of resources (Pareto criterion). However, it cannot fit the inability to resolve negative externalities through the market price mechanism into its specific capitalist (class) context and identify class biases. Whatever is the “perfect” solution, it implies residual (cumulative) pollution, which, in this respect too, indicates that neoclassical economics ignores the natural limits and scarcity of (natural) productive resources by overemphasizing the potential substitution of economic resources and technologies. In capitalism two kinds of environmental crisis are distinguished: The first kind of environmental crisis occurs when the accumulation of capital is threatened by environmental restrictions on the supply of necessary material use-values – and on this basis this kind of crisis basically goes back to the Marxian “law” of the falling rate of profit. The second kind of environmental crisis expresses the capitalist degradation of the conditions of human development and is related to the consequences of capitalist development on nature and human life, the “metabolic rift” and the violation of “eco-regulatory processes”. The second kind of environmental crisis can cause a fall in the profitability of capital (first kind of crisis), however this does not occur in any case. Nature is not in its entirety integrated into the conditions of production-reproduction of capital and does not directly influence in any case the factors that determine capital’s profitability. There is no automatic (corrective) mechanism for arresting the environmental crisis, such as the crisis itself, nor any price mechanism for the elements of nature that are not integrated into capitalist production-reproduction which will give the “signal” of their burden, degradation, or destruction. Based on the above, the relationship of pandemics, especially the Covid-19 pandemic, with capitalism, its spatial expansion in nature and the violation of natural limits by industrial intensive animal husbandry is explored. The causal connection between capital reproduction processes and the emergence of diseases and the Covid-19 pandemic is analyzed. The Covid-19 pandemic is a manifestation of the second kind of environmental crisis, which, in turn, can trigger the first kind of environmental crisis. Pandemics in capitalism are not random phenomena external to the capitalist relationship, but rather internal (inscribed within) to the capitalist relationship of exploitation and appropriation of nature. In this context, the modern changes in the consumption’s pattern, their relationship with the capitalist stable-intensive livestock farming and the capitalist development model of agricultural production are examined. The dietary transition to food of animal origin, the –associated with this transition– changes in the productive structure of livestock farming and the consequences of breeding methods on the occurrence of pandemics, as a result of the widespread violation of the natural limits of the ecosystem and thus the expansion of the metabolic rift, are investigated.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Patras
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Papalexiou, Georgios
- Παπαλεξίου, Γεώργιος
Subjects
dc:subject × 20Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/54444