Back to search

University of Peloponesse

Δημοκρατία, διακυβέρνηση και κοινωνικό κεφάλαιο: μια διακρατική προσέγγιση με πολυεπίπεδα μοντέλα ανάλυσης

Abstract

dc:description

The contribution of this Doctoral Thesis lies in the investigation using simple regressions, but also multilevel models of analysis, as well as the most recent data, of the following three (complex) research questions: 1st, Individuals' degree of satisfaction with democracy is influenced by social capital at the individual (micro) level. 2nd, Individuals' degree of satisfaction with democracy is influenced by social capital at the aggregate (macro) level. 3rd, Assessment of a country's governance quality and trust in its institutions are influenced by political ideology, social trust and cultural environment. More specifically, the thesis aims to analyze the effect of social capital on satisfaction with democracy, through the introduction into the analysis of determining factors both at the level of the individual and at the level of the country. In this way, it is possible to distinguish the effects of individual level evaluations of satisfaction with democracy, as they are placed within a specific national context, and at the same time form an opinion on the explanatory power of the above two sets of determinants of satisfaction with democracy. An additional contribution of the analysis is the provision of comparative data on the predictive ability of the model through the analysis of the relationship between social capital and satisfaction with democracy during the period of the financial crisis, as well as identifying changes in the relationship between social capital and support for the democratic regime between the two periods, before and after the financial crisis. Empirically, it attempts to measure people's evaluations of support for the democratic regime from individual-level data on satisfaction with democracy (SWD). Furthermore, different operational definitions of social capital are used at the individual than at the collective level of analysis. At the individual level, an integrated view of the concept of social capital as shaped by the dimensions of trust (generalized and institutional trust), human values (such as altruism, tolerance, equality, and humanitarianism) and participatory behavior (political engagement, activism, and association activity). At the country level, Hofstede's (2001) “national culture” approach is adopted and the dimensions of power distance, uncertainty avoidance, masculinity, and individualism are linked to collective characteristics and/or social capital outcomes. Individual and collective characteristics of social capital are therefore combined, and support is provided for the argument that they are determinants of political system performance evaluation. The proposed analytical framework allows the study of the role of social capital both at the individual and aggregate level, since it makes possible the separation of subjective evaluations and judgments from actions that can also be observed as results of social capital. Empirical research estimates include appropriate multilevel techniques, which account for individual-level data nested within groups. Information from different sources is combined to obtain the necessary data. At the individual level, data are drawn from round 8 of the European Social Survey (ESS) which refers to a cross-section of 17 countries, as well as from the ESS round 4 data set which refers to 24 countries. Round 8 data were collected by the ESS in the postcrisis period, specifically in the year 2016, while round 4 data were collected in the pre-crisis period, in the year 2008. Our country-level data were drawn from the UN. Considering variability in individuals' socioeconomic characteristics, but also differences in national cultures at the national level, strong evidence is found that social capital influences satisfaction with democracy. More importantly, the evidence used in the study to analyze the potential mechanisms through which the effect of social capital is transmitted on individuals' evaluations of government performance are strong predictors of this relationship. Moreover, the effects of these factors are observed after controlling for the overall macro-environment (power relations, development, individualism, masculinity). Thus, characteristics of social capital such as trust, altruism, equality, tolerance, humanitarianism, and civic engagement could indeed be seen as the key mechanisms of different modes of cooperation. In-depth study of such mechanisms provides us with valuable insights into how citizens of different countries can build cooperation and maintain a critical mass of willingness to cooperate to overcome unexpected challenges or advance socioeconomic and political reforms. Finally, this PhD Thesis focuses on the relationship between governance and social capital. Specifically, the relationship between individual evaluations of governance quality and the social capital stock of a country is analyzed, through the comparison of two countries, namely Greece and Cyprus. The choice of the two countries serves the purpose of the analysis, since it is thus possible to assess the importance of institutions and the quality of governance, as well as the degree to which they are influenced by variables such as social trust and ideology, through the comparison of two countries which have many common cultural elements and therefore very “close” cultural environments. We believe that Greece and Cyprus are indicative examples of how the interaction of ideology and administrative structures led to the development of different trajectories regarding the management of the economic crisis of 2008. The two countries have common characteristics. They are both mature democracies and members of the eurozone, while also having remarkably similar sociocultural backgrounds. They differ in terms of political culture and public administration, two factors that allow us to compare the two countries in terms of their effectiveness in crisis management in the political and civil society sectors. Focusing on the political management and institutional foundations of the two countries, we study their relationship with people's perceptions of good governance and institutional trust. Perceptions of both governance and institutions are influenced by political ideology. On the other hand, the existence of quality institutions presupposes that power is exercised in a way that ensures accountability, transparency, and good levels of other quality indicators of democracy. Through the empirical investigation of these assumptions, we attempt, focusing on individuals' perceptions, to expand existing knowledge regarding how ideology and culture can become catalysts for structural changes and adaptations in times of crisis. We find that governance, institutional, ideological, and cultural differences in Greece and Cyprus worked in opposite directions. As a problem-acceleration mechanism in the case of Greece and a problem-solving mechanism in the case of Cyprus. We believe that it is the differences in cultural backgrounds, the quality of governance institutions and administrative structures that led the two countries to follow completely opposite directions and are the key to interpreting the observed differences in the degree of success of the two countries in crisis management. In our empirical analysis, we used data from two sources, namely the European Social Survey (ESS) and the Eurobarometer databases. For analytical purposes, we cover distinct government periods before, during and after the crisis and test the aforementioned interactions between governance, institutions, ideology, and culture. Good governance and institutional trust are approached as composite indicators of citizens' evaluations of key policy areas and key institutions, respectively. Political ideology is measured by self-reported placement on a left-to right scale, while culture is determined by a composite index that includes generalized trust, interpersonal honesty, and willingness to help each other. Controlling for the sociodemographic and economic profile of the respondents, support is provided to the proposed empirical hypotheses. We believe that the findings of the research help to interpret the choices of the two countries at the policy level.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of Peloponesse
Year dc:date
2023

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Bekiaris, Evangelos
  • Μπεκιάρης, Ευάγγελος

Subjects

dc:subject × 24

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/54540

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Bekiaris, Evangelos; Μπεκιάρης, Ευάγγελος. Δημοκρατία, διακυβέρνηση και κοινωνικό κεφάλαιο: μια διακρατική προσέγγιση με πολυεπίπεδα μοντέλα ανάλυσης. University of Peloponesse, 2023. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/54540