National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Τα ηθικά στάδια στην Εγελειανή φιλοσοφία του δικαίου
Abstract
dc:descriptionTHE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN CONSCIOUSNESS, LOGOS AND SCRIPTURE AND THE CORRESPONDING RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN LAW, SUBJECTIVE RIGHTS UND JUSTICE This treatise analyses not historically (par les faits), but logically (par la raison) the three parameters of the cognitive horizon consciousness, logic and scripture, which are translated in the domain of law as: Law, subjective rights, justice. A.GREEK OR DIALEKTIC ERA The absolute identity of individuality and essence: Here, for the first time both the observation- registration of the human needs as well as their meeting and addressing through Logos, whereas these three parameters of the cognitive horizon and the being coordinate harmonically. The consciousness conceives through the Logos the deep meaning of nature and the three normal parameters balance with another. Under the aegis of the Greek spirit the nature reflects itself on the surface of the Logos as essence and casts up as conception on the shore of knowledge. In the realm of law, the object of consciousness is formed on the grounds of customs and manners, which rely on the domestic Penates, the Lares, the gods of hearth and home and their original traditions. Justice and natural law reside as an institutional net within society, connect themselves with the law as „de lege lata” and shape the subjective rights as a speculative necessary legal consequence and a dialectic synthesis of the preceding premises. The subjective right as mediation between material possession or real-estate on the one hand and institutional organization on the other is achieved automatically through the restitution-mechanism of „Dike”. The adequacy between thing and understanding (adaequatio rei et intellectus) is thrown off balance due to the discovery of the asymmetric numbers, where only the perennation of the approach to the truth is feasible. B.REPUBLICAN OR PRAGMATIC ERA In accordance with the above a shift of balance is observed that overthrows the pre-stabilized harmony. This discrepancy is registered initially in the function of coordinates concerning nature, the immovability of which was declared by philosopher Seneca for the last time. Nature is perceived henceforth as an unstoppable becoming, which carries away in its flow all established values. The result is a time of fragmental knowledge and fractured -smashed- shattered consciousness. As reaction to it logic and science begin to expand their actions to cope with the continuously changing reality and to include new figures into their analysis. Now their only ambition is the formulation of temporary, not eternal partial truths, of reliable circumstantial meaningful perceptive ascertainments or certainties of limited passing duration, that are valid under specific conditions according to the clause „rebus sic standibus“. The conception of truth is substituted by tried and tested certitudes as temporary, fleeting, non-definitive answers to existing problems. The various moral points of view are considered as equivalent, while the formal judiciary equality of the persons and their opinions leads to a comparison, valuation and confrontation of the proposed principles, crucial for the pending required decision. Under these conditions, justice as management of the system of needs in association with the variety and the peculiarity of the invoked rights entails the law as an inditement of casuistic precedents, whilst a very special role is reserved for the judiciary case law (edict of praetors in democratic Rome, Anglo-Saxons’ states of the present). The dogmatic convictions or clear insights of the persons are controlled by the commonsense to the extent that they meet the requirements of morality, so the most logical and purposeful solution is prioritized both in the present case and as precedent in view of other cases. B.JEWISH- CHRISTIAN OR POSITIVISTIC ERA To restitute the precarious balance the opposite size of the function of coordinates, i.e. consciousness, wakes up, realizes the intervening and creating power slumbering in it and attempts to follow the pulse of the evolving nature, coping through successive sovereign decisions with the new needs. This is the transition into the infinite positivity through the negation of the spiritual dispersal (Israel), where the consciousness becomes aware of its enforcing power to influence reality by its decisions and commands. Progressively, the will of the almighty god is substituted by the will of the legislator. This unlimited freedom of the will, which shapes the environment with its emanations, creative influences, even whims without any fail-safes or guarantees causes to people unimaginable fear and blank sheer pure terror.Here, the law and the rights proclaimed by it don’t recognize any other source (adherence and devotion to the word of the lawgiver) and confine justice to a mediocre and non-dynamic role, namely the assurance of the legal and social peace (Byzantium, reception of Roman law, French revolution).C.GERMAN OR SYSTEMATIC ERAAccording to dialectic necessity the lying between both cognitive parameters Logos begins to take initiative and assume proper activities to compensate the precipitous collapse of nature and the garrulous measureless consciousness and to facilitate again their harmonic peaceful coexistence this time in the frame of an automatic, adaptive, everchanging relationship. A return to the institutions (customs and manners) is completed, which introduce henceforth systems relying on constitutional ideas (Lassall’s process of communication) and communicate with each other on the grounds of cybernetic principles and diminishment of differences. In accordance with it, the communication among law, rights and general legal settlement is conducted across mechanisms of information exchange and cybernetic interaction of the pertinent factors. Family, civil society, corporations, labor-unions and state depend tightly on each other and constitute an autonomous organism, perceived in organic development. The „autopoiesis” of the communicating systems allows no leeway for radical reality formation, but only for critical thought (critical school, German systematic theory). (The full text of the PhD includes translation in english and german.)
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2000
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Γιακουμής, Σταμάτης
Subjects
dc:subject × 4Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/5455