Back to search

National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)

Πειραματική διερεύνηση της ανισότροπης συμπεριφοράς άμμου σταθεροποιημένης με κολλοειδή πυριτία

Abstract

dc:description

The liquefaction of non-cohesive soils during seismic loading can cause significant damage to the superstructure, even leading to complete failure. Preventing the risk of liquefaction at sites for new constructions can be achieved through a series of established soil improvement techniques before the building is constructed, depending on the characteristics of the liquefiable soil. In cases where soil improvement is applied in areas with existing structures, the available methods are limited and often come with many disadvantages (e.g., improvement of only a small portion of the footprint, foundation problems due to high-pressure injection of grouts, etc.). These conditions led to the development of a new soil improvement method called passive site stabilization (Gallagher, 2000).This method involves the injection of a stabilizer with a low hydraulic gradient—an environmentally safe material composed of nanoparticles with various possible chemical compositions—into the liquefiable soil. The stabilizer is slowly injected into the ground and transported through the saturated soil mass utilizing natural or enhanced groundwater flow (Gallagher et al., 2007; Jurinak et al., 1989), or by electro-osmosis (Thevanayagam & Jia, 2003). The silica hydrosol has low viscosity during the injection phase and thickens in a controllable manner to form a stable, non-toxic gel; the gel fills the pore space, retains the pore water, and supports the grain structure. Enriching the pore fluid with the stabilizer alters the mechanical behavior of the soil skeleton-pore fluid system, resulting in increased strength, enhanced dilatancy, and greater resistance to liquefaction (Gallagher & Mitchell, 2002; Kodaka et al., 2005; Díaz-Rodríguez et al., 2008; Porcino et al., 2011, 2012; Vranna & Tika, 2015). The colloidal silica Ludox-SM® was selected as the stabilizer in this thesis Although the aforementioned laboratory studies have provided answers to several issues related to this novel and promising sand stabilization method, their results are based on conventional liquefaction resistance tests using triaxial or simple shear devices, which do not allow for the investigation of the anisotropic behavior of stabilized sands. The term "anisotropy" in soil materials refers to the dependence of their mechanical behavior (strength, dilatancy, stiffness) on the loading direction due to their anisotropic structure. The oriented internal arrangement of grains and voids, including grain orientation, contact normal vectors' orientation, and the voids' distribution and orientation, define the material's fabric (Mitchell & Kenichi, 1976).A comprehensive understanding of the stabilized soil's response under various loading conditions is required for the practical application of passive stabilization. This dissertation experimentally investigates the effectiveness of the "new" method for improving non-cohesive soils through monotonic and cyclic loading tests, examining the influence of grain shape, drainage conditions, and effective stress using both conventional tests and specialized tests under generalized loading conditions in the Hollow Cylinder Apparatus. Stabilization with colloidal silica appears to result in higher compressibility during one-dimensional compression, facilitating grain slippage (plastic deformations), while during unloading, it does not seem to affect the development of quasi-elastic deformations. Under triaxial compression, stabilized sand exhibits significantly higher dilatancy than untreated sand, leading to higher peak strength. The improved strength and pronounced dilation tendency of sand stabilized with a 10% CS colloidal silica sol gradually decreases with increasing stress and shear strain accumulation. In the final critical state, the stress ratio of stabilized specimens approximates that of untreated sand specimens when frictional characteristics dominate grain contact behavior. During cyclic loading of loose sand, a rapid increase in excess pore water pressure occurs alongside significant axial strain development when the stress path reaches the instability line, leading to liquefaction. In stabilized sand, axial strain accumulates gradually from the first loading cycle. Despite the effective stress reaching zero (initial liquefaction), the specimen does not liquefy. While the initial stiffness modulus of untreated sand is equal to or greater than that of stabilized sand, it declines rapidly upon initial liquefaction and nearly vanishes. In contrast, the stiffness of stabilized sand diminishes gradually. However, because most geotechnical problems involve complex initial stress states and loading conditions that include changes in both the magnitude and direction of principal stresses (σ1, σ2, σ3), studying soil response under generalized loading conditions is essential. For this reason, the effect of principal stress rotation on the response of stabilized sand is investigated for the first time through triaxial extension tests and specialized experiments using the Hollow Cylinder Torsional Shear Apparatus. Initially, a framework describing the anisotropic response of sand was established, and this framework was then used as a reference to highlight the improved behavior of stabilized sand. In monotonic loading tests under a constant inclination angle α of the principal stress axis, the optimal mechanical behavior occurs when the major principal stress is perpendicular to the bedding plane (α = 0°). As the σ'1-axis deviates from the vertical, the sand response becomes more contractive, reducing its strength with increasing α. For a given α value, increasing the intermediate principal stress parameter (b) significantly reduces shear strength and increases contractiveness. Stabilized sand exhibits pronounced anisotropic behavior similar to untreated sand. As the σ'1-axis moves away from the vertical, strength decreases significantly, and contractiveness increases. The lowest strength is observed at α = 60°, similar to dense sand M31. Regardless of α, the maximum strength of stabilized sand exceeds that of dense sand M31. Additionally, the addition of the stabilizer reduces contractiveness and increases dilatancy. However, for α ≥ 45°, stabilized sand exhibits weaker performance at low stress ratios, with the accumulation of plastic strain under constant volume conditions. When loading is stress-controlled, and drainage is either restricted or free—where the latter is feasible before and after the unstable response—stabilized loose sand exhibits unstable behavior similar to that of untreated loose sand under undrained conditions. As loading progresses and dilation begins, stabilized sand develops greater peak strength than even the densest sand. In tests with continuous rotation of the principal stress axes under constant deviatoric stress (q), mean effective stress (p'), and intermediate principal stress parameter (b), the specimen's response to axis rotation reflects only its initial structural differences. As the axes rotate, volumetric contractive strain accumulates, and plastic incremental strains develop. The magnitude of these strains depends on sand density, the value of parameter b, and the applied stress ratio. Principal stress axis rotation at a high stress ratio leads to large deformations and specimen failure. During monotonic loading tests, a deviation between the principal stress direction and the principal incremental plastic strain direction (non-coaxiality) is observed in both untreated and stabilized sand, particularly when 30° ≤ α ≤ 60°. This deviation is most significant in the early loading stages. Compared to loading at a constant α angle, the non-coaxiality of sand is more pronounced under continuous variation of α. The angle of non-coaxiality decreases when rotation occurs under a higher stress ratio and when parameter b increases. Generally, sand behavior becomes nearly coaxial with shear strain accumulation as failure approaches.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Year dc:date
2023

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Pavlopoulou, Eleni-Maria
  • Παυλοπούλου, Ελένη-Μαρία

Subjects

dc:subject × 23

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/54659

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Pavlopoulou, Eleni-Maria; Παυλοπούλου, Ελένη-Μαρία. Πειραματική διερεύνηση της ανισότροπης συμπεριφοράς άμμου σταθεροποιημένης με κολλοειδή πυριτία. National Technical University of Athens (NTUA), 2023. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/54659