Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
The impact of CLIL and EFL instruction on learners' WM and executive functions
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe topic of the present dissertation is to investigate whether two forms of bilingual education under the conditions they are implemented in the Greek educational context can impact upon learners’ particular cognitive skills. Bilingualism in this study is not equated with balanced bilingualism since it refers to learners who are not equally proficient in the two languages. 72 Greek-English ‘bilingual’ children aged 10 years old were examined in three different experiments after they had been divided into different groups. The study primarily investigated whether the exposure to CLIL instruction, the differential amount of exposure to CLIL instruction and finally, the differential amount of exposure to EFL instruction affect the cognitive functioning of young Greek learners. The main cognitive variables investigated in the study are Working Memory (WM) and in particular its subcomponents; the Phonological Loop (PL), the Visuo-spatial Sketchpad (VSSP) and the Central Executive System (CES) (Baddeley & Hitch, 1974). Furthermore, learners’ performance (accuracy) in Proactive (PI) and Retroactive (RI) Interference tasks as well as their resistance to PI and RI are measured to draw conclusions about their executive functions (EFs), particularly about inhibition and selective attention (Bialystok & Feng, 2009). To our knowledge, the impact of CLIL instruction on these particular executive functions in a bilingual educational context with the under-researched language combination (L1 Greek_L2 English) has never been attempted before. The main hypotheses of the thesis are that the learners’ exposure to CLIL instruction, intensive exposure to CLIL instruction and intensive exposure to L2 English will have a beneficial effect on the young learners’ cognitive skills. A wealth of studies has investigated how the experience of being bilingual affects our language and cognitive abilities (Bialystok, 2016). Moreover, micro studies looked into the language outcomes of CLIL students in comparison with the language outcomes of EFL learners (Merikivi & Pietilä, 2014). Research conducted during the past ten years suggest a common finding; that is, CLIL learners’ overall language ability is greatly benefited by the ‘bilingual education’ context CLIL promotes (Bialystok, 2016; Lorenzo & Moore, 2010). Furthermore, studies on the impact of CLIL or, in fact, of any type of bilingual education on content outcomes are considerably fewer (Dalton-Puffer, 2011; Mattheoudakis, Alexiou & Ziaka, 2018). What has been even less researched is whether the bilingual advantage in EFs emerges in learners who attend L2 programs of different intensity, i.e. CLIL instruction or intensive EFL instruction (Efstathiadi & Mattheoudakis, 2022). Overall, the results of this thesis are more than promising, as they strongly suggest that CLIL instruction and particularly intensive exposure to CLIL instruction can definitely enhance certain cognitive skills in young learners. Resistance to PI and RI, which strongly relies on executive control, seems to relate to the one form of bilingual education which is examined, namely CLIL instruction (Cenoz, 2015; Moore & Nikula, 2016). However, the differential amount of exposure to EFL instruction, another form of bilingual education based on contemporary references (Baker & Wright, 2021), does not seem to impact upon executive control (Lynch, 2017; Uriel, 1953). Finally, in line with previous studies which did not find evidence of a bilingual advantage in WM capacity, this thesis fails to associate either CLIL instruction or EFL instruction with any of the components of WM. This thesis provides new data on the role of CLIL instruction as a form of bilingual education in the development of learners’ cognition. The outcome of this work reveals for the first time that learning in two languages is beneficial not only for the development of language and content-knowledge but cognition as well, a fact that may have implications for the education of bilingual learners as a whole.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Konstantinidou, Parthena
- Κωνσταντινίδου, Παρθένα
Subjects
dc:subject × 14Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/54840