Back to search

University of Thessaly (UTH)

Λειτουργικές αποκρίσεις φυτών που αναπτύσσονται υπό συνθήκες ενυδρειοπονίας (aquaponics)

Abstract

dc:description

Aquaponics is an integrated crop and fish production system, which operates according to the circular economy concept to produce food. It combines hydroponics and fish farming, connecting the two sub-systems through the recirculating water and the diluted nutrients. Fish metabolism and uneaten feed enriches the water with essential nutrients for plant growth. The conversion of wastes to resources makes aquaponics a promising and environmentally friendly cultivation technique. However, the main disadvantage of aquaponics is that certain essential nutrients for plant growth are often at suboptimal concentrations. The aim of the present work was to thoroughly examine crop’s functional responses, including physiological, biochemical and growth parameters, as well as fish growth performance in lab-scale aquaponics systems, to capture the cultivations dynamics and identify system’s weak points and the limitations they impose. The doctoral thesis was developed in three axes/sections. The first section includes the study of the above-mentioned functional responses of three crops when grown with nutrient inputs following the "minimum nutrient supplementation" approach. In the 2nd and 3rd section, the effects of qualitative and quantitative changes in fish diets on plant functional responses were studied. In all cases, plants were grown until they reached the marketable size, in co-culture with red tilapia (Oreochromis sp.). During the growing season, gas exchange and photosynthetic responses to light, the status and efficiency of the photosynthetic apparatus through chlorophyll a fluorescence in vivo, photosynthetic pigment concentrations, leaf nutrient composition and antioxidant capacity of the plants, as well as physicochemical parameters and water quality, together with plant and fish growth parameters were studied at regular intervals. In the case of the aromatic plants, basil and mint, the effect of treatments on the yield and qualitative composition of essential oil was also evaluated. In the first section, three independent experiments were conducted with lettuce (Lactuca sativa var Romana), spinach (Spinacia oleracea var Virofly), and spiny chicory or stamnagathi (Cichorium spinosum). Three different nutrient solutions were studied, a) additional Fe, b) combined addition of Fe+K, and c) the Control, which refers to aquaponics water without further supplementation. In lettuce, Control plants showed reductions in photosynthesis and the efficiency of the photosynthetic apparatus as early as day 14 of the experiment. These early signs continued throughout the experiment, with corresponding decreases in photosynthetic pigment concentration, antioxidant capacity and growth, all of which were attributed to Fe, K and Mn deficiencies, as demonstrated by nutrient analysis of the leaves. The Fe group showed high rates of photosynthesis and functionality of the photosynthetic apparatus, sustained throughout the cultivation period without stress symptoms. However, supplementation of K is considered necessary to ensure maximum lettuce yield, since Fe+K plants significantly increased lettuce production by 41 and 54% compared to Fe and Control groups respectively. Moreover, nutrient supplementation increased the specific growth rate in tilapia.Spinach plants in the Control group showed extensive chlorosis and functional impairment already on day 10 of the experiment that were attributed to Fe deficiency and ultimately caused a significantly reduced growth. The latter appeared to be the result of a concerted reduction in light absorption and light use efficiency, along with a down-regulation of photochemistry and carboxylation processes, which together were associated with early chlorophyll loss and possibly structural problems in the photosynthetic apparatus. In contrast, spinach plants in the Fe group showed similar growth and function to plants in the Fe+K group but outperformed them in chlorophyll content, photosynthetic rate and photochemical efficiency, mainly due to higher quantum yield of electron transport. Fish growth was unaffected by further nutrient input into the system. Iron deficiency proved to be the major weak point for spinach cultivation in coupled aquaponics systems, and the results demonstrate that sole iron supplementation can significantly improve the function and performance of spinach. In stamnagathi plants, Fe deficiency was crucial in shaping the responses of Control group, which showed inferior performance in terms of photochemistry, chlorophyll content, light use efficiency, and, subsequently, photosynthetic activity. Fe and Fe+K-treated plants exhibited similarly high performance in all studied parameters and achieved 4.5- and 4-fold increased yields, respectively, compared to Control. Fish growth characteristics and survival rates remained unaffected. The results demonstrate that aquaponics is an advantageous cropping system for stamnagathi, and that sole Fe supplementation is adequate to promote excellent performance and yield of this oligotrophic native species. In the second section, the functional responses of broad-leaf basil (Ocimum basilicum) were studied when two feeds of tilapia were applied, which differed in quality and composition. The first one used nettle (Urtica dioica) as an alternative to totally replace soybean meal in commercial feeds, thus a nettle meal in proportion of 30% of the diet was included (Nettle) and was compared to the optimal diet of the species (Control). During the experiment, two successive cuts of the aboveground part of the plants were performed and, in addition to the measurements mentioned at the beginning, fish flesh quality parameters were included. The results showed that the Nettle diet significantly reduced fish production and specific growth rate by 20%, while the feed biomass conversion factor increased by 50% compared to the Control diet. Fish survival and the protein and fat content of fish flesh remained unaffected. Plant growth was not significantly affected by the different diets, with the only response being the 20% increase in the leaf number of the Nettle group. Similar levels of all measured physiological and biochemical parameters were recorded in both treatments, without any stress symptoms. The main effect of nettle application on fish feed was found in the essential oil analyses. Oil yield was reduced by 30% in the Nettle group compared to the Control. In the opposite direction was the effect of Nettle on oil quality composition as more substances were detected compared to the Control. Significant differences were also recorded in the contribution of different components, with 15 substances being at higher levels in the Nettle plants and only one being exceeded by the Control. The percentage of eucalyptol, which gives the characteristic strong aroma of basil, increased by 85% in the Nettle treatment. Overall, the presence of nettle in aquaponic fish feed is evaluated as positive if the objective is to produce basil biomass and to exploit specific components of its essential oil. In the third section of the thesis, the effects of different feeding frequencies of red tilapia on mint (Mentha piperita) cultivation were studied. The treatments were a) two (FF2, every six hours), b) three (FF3, every four hours) and c) five (FF5, every two hours) times during the day ad libitum. The experiment lasted 45 days and two successive cuts were performed in the aboveground part of the plants. The results showed that increasing meals during the day up to five times did not affect the growth and functional responses of mint as well as fish growth. The most important results were that FF5 caused an increase in Mn content of mint leaves and increased two substances in the essential oil. Feeding frequencies FF2 and FF3 were equally effective for high plant and fish performance. In conclusion, two meals every 6 h daily is a suitable and effective feeding frequency for red tilapia in the co-cultivation with mint in aquaponics to avoid feed waste and increase the productivity of the system. This PhD thesis is the first in Greece to study aquaponics as an alternative farming system. It has been shown that with a " minimum nutrient supplementation " approach, besides being sustainable and environmentally friendly, it is an effective system that can achieve high yields, with stamnagathi showing the highest yields compared to all other conventional farming systems. In addition to the above, the results demonstrate - irrespective of the plant species - the necessity of monitoring the functional responses of the plants. They can give an early indication of constraints originating from the aquaponic system itself, describe their effects on the mechanisms underlying plant growth, highlight weak points of the system and indicate target points for further improvement and successful management.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of Thessaly (UTH)
Year dc:date
2023

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Tsoumalakou, Evangelia
  • Τσουμαλάκου, Ευαγγελία

Subjects

dc:subject × 12

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/54892

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Tsoumalakou, Evangelia; Τσουμαλάκου, Ευαγγελία. Λειτουργικές αποκρίσεις φυτών που αναπτύσσονται υπό συνθήκες ενυδρειοπονίας (aquaponics). University of Thessaly (UTH), 2023. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/54892