Back to search

National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)

Μαθηματική προσομοίωση συμπεριφοράς πετρελαιοκηλίδας εξαιτίας ατυχήματος κατά την εξόρυξη πετρελαίου

Abstract

dc:description

Environmental management of oil spills is a complex, interdisciplinary field of research aimed at preventing oil spills at sea and minimizing the environmental impact when they occur as a result of an accident. Mathematical models for oil spill simulation are important environmental management tools. The future development of hydrocarbon exploration and production activities in Greece makes it necessary to use these models: A.in the selection of extraction sites, but also B.in case of accidental spills: i.to predict the movement of the surface oil spill as well as the oil in the water column, and ii.to select the appropriate response method. From the literature survey, regarding the applications of oil spill simulation models and the required input data of these models, the following were found: •The method for calculating coastal currents as input data for a simulation model to determine the trajectory of an oil spill in a surface spill incident varies from one region to another. As a result, each case is treated individually. Furthermore, in Greece, the factors influencing the oil spill trajectory have not been thoroughly investigated. Therefore, it is essential to take into account a diverse range of wind and current data for simulations in order to accurately reproduce a real incident. •The impact of various weather conditions during different seasons on the probability of oil pollution in environmentally sensitive areas resulting from accidents during oil extraction activities in shallow/intermediate water depths has not been sufficiently investigated. Additionally, the effects of employing surface response and clean-up measures on the extent of pollution consequences remain unexplored. Lastly, there is a lack of previous research concerning the simulation of potential oil spill accidents arising from mining and/or shipping activities in the Ionian Sea region. •The impact of employing subsea chemical dispersant injection (SSDI) in response to spills of different types of oil from deep water depths on the spill's behavior remains unexplored. Moreover, there is a need for additional research in the broader Mediterranean Sea, as no extensive investigations have been conducted in this region until today. From the literature survey, regarding the experiments that have been conducted to evaluate the effectiveness of the SSDI method in reducing the size of oil droplets in the event of a deep oil spill was found that:•Although extensive research has been carried out, there has been no investigation into the effect of oil temperature on the effectiveness of SSDI. Oil temperature is a crucial parameter to consider as it can influence various factors, including oil viscosity and density, which, in turn, can impact SSDI performance. Additionally, current chemical dispersion testing protocols, like the IFP (French Institute of Petroleum test) and MNS (Mackay Nadeau Steelman test), focus on surface dispersion chemical applications. Thus, there is a need to develop an updated protocol that accurately simulates injection conditions during subsea oil spills. The main result of this PhD thesis is that critical parameters related to the overall environmental management of oil spill incidents have been investigated and are expected to form the basis of the methodology for the response to any incidents during the upcoming drilling operations expected in the Greek seas. In order to answer the questions for which computational models were used, the investigation of the parameters was carried out in various marine areas of Greece, namely in the Saronic Gulf, Gulf of Patras and Gulf of Kyparissia. The following conclusions were drawn, which essentially constitute the answers to the four research questions:1.The results obtained from the simulation model, which incorporated both wind and current data to calculate coastal currents, exhibited stronger agreement with the real incident’s satellite and field data. This alignment indicates that both wind and current forces were significant contributors to the movement of the Holy Zone II oil slick toward the coast. The findings suggest that currents had a more pronounced impact on the spread of the oil spill during this event. Nonetheless, the absence of wind data hindered our ability to fully predict the extent to which the shoreline would be affected by the oil spill.2.Based on the analysis of the results, the following conclusions were drawn: A. The stochastic calculations showed that there is a significant probability of oil pollution in the Patraikos Gulf, which can reach 30% in the lagoons of Messolonghi - Aitoliko. In addition, a significant variation is observed in the results of stochastic simulations due to the different weather conditions prevailing during the various seasons that were examined. B. Deterministic calculations showed that 78-90% of the bird population and 2-4% of the fish population are expected to be contaminated in the event of an oil spill without any intervention. For the existing oil spill response systems in Greece, the use of chemicals reduced the amount of oil reaching the coast by about 16-21% and the population of contaminated birds in lagoons by about 70%. However, the population of affected fish increased to 6-8.5% due to the higher concentration of oil in the water column. Mechanical recovery removed nearly 10% of the oil spilled, but had no appreciable effect on the oil that ended up on the shores and on the affected bird and fish populations.3.Deterministic calculations conducted in the Gulf of Kyparissia demonstrated that implementing the SSDI method resulted in a surface oil reduction of around 25-74% and an approximately 37-62% decrease in the affected area above the defined threshold (thickness≥0.1 mm). Nevertheless, it also led to a significant increase in the mass of submerged oil by 161 to 274%, and an increase in the volume affected (concentration≥10 ppm) by 199-398%. These outcomes were attributed to a decrease in oil droplet sizes, which subsequently caused a reduction in the ascent rates. Among the 4 types of oil tested, paraffinic oil showed the greatest reduction in affected surface area and amount of oil on the surface, while waxy oil showed the lowest reduction. It can be pointed out that critical factors for using SSDI to reduce the net environmental impact are the type of oil released, seasonal changes, and the presence of natural resources such as fish spawning or bird migration.4.The effectiveness of the SSDI method in reducing oil droplet size (d50) has been tested for a wide range of oil types with varying properties. The effect of oil temperature on the effectiveness of the SSDI method is as follows: in the case of the paraffinic oil tested, it decreases while in the case of the asphaltene and naphthenic type oils tested, it increases. In the case of the waxy oil, no effect of efficiency related to the change in oil temperature was observed. The results of the experiments conducted in this thesis, combined with previous research using four different types of chemicals and various dosages, led to the development of a new protocol for the Dispersant Injection Efficiency Test (DIET). Of particular importance is the observation that the chemical ranking achieved by the new test method is substantially different from the results produced using conventional methods for the surface application of dispersant chemicals (IFP). This difference implies that existing standard methods for chemical efficiency testing are less applicable for evaluating the effectiveness of SSDI. The new test protocol includes several key elements that contribute to its effectiveness: o It uses a turbulence regime that represents the conditions of subsea oil spills, specifically a turbulent jet. o Measures the effectiveness of chemical dispersants quantitatively through the reduction in oil droplet size compared to untreated oil. o Uses a seawater flow system that allows testing of a wide range of droplet concentrations and sizes. o Injection of the chemical directly into the oil in a realistic and functional manner. o It takes into account an elevated oil temperature of 50°C associated with real world conditions. o Easily adapts to a wide range of chemical dispersion doses. o Allows for continuous monitoring during oil spill, which enables the collection of statistically significant data. o Can be highly automated, fast and cost-effective.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Year dc:date
2023

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Makatounis, Panagiotis-Eleftherios
  • Μακατούνης, Παναγιώτης-Ελευθέριος

Subjects

dc:subject × 18

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/54959

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Makatounis, Panagiotis-Eleftherios; Μακατούνης, Παναγιώτης-Ελευθέριος. Μαθηματική προσομοίωση συμπεριφοράς πετρελαιοκηλίδας εξαιτίας ατυχήματος κατά την εξόρυξη πετρελαίου. National Technical University of Athens (NTUA), 2023. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/54959