University of the Aegean
Εκτίμηση - κατάταξη της σεισμικής τρωτότητας των εγκαταστάσεων επεξεργασίας λυμάτων και διερεύνησή της ως προς τη ρύπανση εδαφικών και υδατικών πόρων
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe present thesis addresses the issue of rapidly assessing seismic vulnerability in Wastewater Treatment Plants (WWTPs) and proposes an original methodology that explores the variables influencing this vulnerability. It employs qualitative analysis through the "expert judgment" method. Globally, estimating the vulnerability of structures is a challenging task because of the multi-parametric nature of the variables involved in it. Until now, methods for determining seismic vulnerability have primarily concentrated on individual constructions or facilities, resulting in a time-consuming procedure. In Greece, the assessment of structural vulnerability for Public and non-profit Buildings progresses is notably slow. Additionally, evaluating vulnerability for WWTPs, other critical facilities and private buildings are non-existent and incomplete. This research underscores the need for a swift seismic vulnerability estimation methodology for WWTPs as analytical calculation methods are time-consuming and previous individual efforts have regrettably not seen practical or widespread application. The thesis aims to conduct pre-earthquake assessments and estimate the seismic vulnerability of WWTPs, focusing on their post-earthquake response. The ultimate objective is to enhance resilience against seismic disasters, optimize the operation of treatment systems, and ensure public health and safety maintenance. The originality of the thesis lies in developing a rapid qualitative estimation methodology for assessing the seismic vulnerability of WWTPs. This methodology is based on the "crisis of experts" approach, which involves identifying the most critical seismic vulnerability variables (along with their respective weighting factors). This identification process is conducted following a thorough review of the literature and a preliminary "pilot" study. To implement this methodology, a prototype Seismic Vulnerability Questionnaire, referred to as “Questionnaire ST” was designed and subsequently administered to a sample of 116 WWTPs’ Managers and Officers 9Sample 1). This sample was chosen using a proportional stratification method. The methodology approach is empirical, centering on investigating the seismic vulnerability estimation provided by WWTPs’ Managers and Operators regarding their facilities. The seismic vulnerabilities under examination exclusively pertain to the facility’s area, with a specific focus on Structural Vulnerability (SV), Non-Structural Vulnerability (NSV) and Operational Vulnerability (OV). The analysis includes the treatment stages of Primary, Secondary and Tertiary Wastewater Treatment, all based on adopted assumptions. Upon determining the seismic vulnerability of each WWTP denoted by indicator “DST”, a scale known as “KST” is constructed. The methodology’s capabilities are demonstrated by its specialization in investigating and assessing the seismic vulnerability of WWTPs, which have potentially contaminate soil and water resources (referred to as “REF”). Additionally, the methodology estimates the temporal dispersion of pollutants within 24 hours after a seismic event. Furthermore, a “KST-REF” scale is calculated as part of the assessment process. Targeting also involves the identification of the category of "experts" who should participate in the research, which is essential for enhancing reliability. To determine the most suitable "experts" for research participation, a corresponding questionnaire, the Standard Seismic Vulnerability Report (“TEST”), identical to Questionnaire ST, was developed. The “TEST” was distributed to a representative Sample 2, comprising 118 Environmental Impact Study Surveyors (“MPE”) specializing in WWTPs. This group differed from the Managers-Operators who participated in the "Questionnaire ST". The Seismic Vulnerability Scale was calculated based on the “TEST” questionnaire responses, referred to as “TEST/KST”. Additionally, a scale called “TEST/KST-REF” was also calculated. In any case, the statistical analysis encompassed various elements, including the utilization of descriptive statistics, the generation of statistical diagrams, and the computation of cumulative frequencies. The “KST” and “TEST/KST” values for the WWTPs were also derived as part of the process. Furthermore, all conceivable combinations of the results from Questionnaire ST and “TEST” and the corresponding calculations for potential post-earthquake “REF” were thoroughly examined. Additionally, correlations were performed by comparing the results of Questionnaire ST with those from an additional Re-evaluation Questionnaire that was administered to 40 recipients. Furthermore, the methodology's reliability was assessed by comparing its outcomes with existing vulnerability curves from HAZUS-MH, Panico et al., and Greek WWTPs (utilizing Syner-G). The WWTPs were grouped based on their characteristics, the Hazard Seismic Map (HSM) of WWTPs, or the characteristics of the Samples. Moreover, the results from Questionnaire ST were compared to earthquake data from Shakemaps and the EM-DAT database, including expected intensities from the HSM and casualty losses. Concerning the reliability of the methodology, the correlation between the results obtained from Questionnaire ST and “TEST” (as well as the corresponding correlations for "REF") was carefully examined. Additionally, correlations were performed by comparing the results of Questionnaire ST with those from an additional Re-evaluation Questionnaire that was administered to 40 recipients. Furthermore, the methodology’s reliability was assessed by comparing its outcomes with existing vulnerability curves from HAZUS-MH, Panico et al., and Greek WWTPs (utilizing Syner-G). The WWTPs were grouped based on their characteristics, Hazard Seismic Map (HSM) of WWTPs, or the characteristics of the Samples. Moreover, the results from Questionnaire ST were compared to earthquake data from Shakemaps and the EM-DAT database, including expected intensities from the HSM and casualty losses. Additionally, a telephone survey was conducted to assess effects using the “Questionnaire ST/TE” in 14 WWTPs from 2011 to 2022. The results of this survey were subsequently compared with recorded data after categorizing them into SV, MSV and OV. A careful selection of WWTPs was made for this comparison. Furthermore, the Questionnaire ST was administered to certain WWTPs. The methodology was applied explicitly to Egion WWTP, and the results for each case were evaluated. The most noteworthy findings were visually presented on 28 maps using Geographical Information Systems (GIS), and these results were further elaborated upon. In any case, the results have demonstrated the methodology’s effectiveness, indicating that it is sufficient and satisfactory for rapidly assessing the seismic vulnerability of WWTPs, mailly when the recipients are the responsible operators. This assessment can be achieved without incurring significant time and costs. The methodology also suggests preventive or corrective measures to mitigate the effects, tailored to each WWTP's "KST" category. The document also addresses uncertainties and provides recommendations for future research on this specific issue. This could be based on earthquake scenarios, broader external factors such as climate change, or the scale of seismic effects. It is noted that the state authorities should systematically and realistically prioritize the strengthening and upgrading of WWTPs' resilience at the prevention level, implementing appropriate protective measures. This approach will help mitigate seismic risks in the scientific field of natural disasters.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of the Aegean
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Kerpelis, Ploutarchos
- Κέρπελης, Πλούταρχος
Subjects
dc:subject × 30- Φυσικές καταστροφές
- Τρωτότητα
- Σεισμική τρωτότητα
- Εγκατάσταση επεξεργασίας λυμάτων
- Διακινδύνευση κατασκευών
- Επιπτώσεις σε εδαφικούς και υδατικούς πόρους
- Ρύπανση
- Προσεισμικός έλεγχος
- Natural disasters
- Vulnerability
- Seismic vulnerability
- Wastewater treatment plants
- Risk of structures
- Soil and water impacts
- Pollution
- Pre-earthquake assessment
- Γεωεπιστήμες και Επιστήμες Περιβάλλοντος
- Φυσικές Επιστήμες
- Επιστήμες περιβάλλοντος
- Παγκόσμια και πλανητική αλλαγή, κλιματική αλλαγή
- Περιβαλλοντική Μηχανική
- Επιστήμες Μηχανικού και Τεχνολογία
- Διαχείριση και Διάθεση αποβλήτων
- Earth and Related Environmental Sciences
- Natural Sciences
- Environmental Sciences
- Global and planetary change, climatic change
- Environmental Engineering
- Engineering and Technology
- Waste Management and Disposal
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/54979