University of Patras
Βαθμονόμηση της σεισμικής επικινδυνότητας παρακείμενων κατασκευών έναντι του προβλήματος της αλληλεπίδρασης και καθορισμός του βέλτιστου σεισμικού αρμού
Abstract
dc:descriptionIn the present doctoral thesis, a novel methodology is introduced to calibrate the seismic risk of adjacent structures against pounding and to determine the optimal separation gap distance (dg). In this context: 1. New Probabilistic Seismic Demand Models (PSDMs) against structural pounding are developed. 2. Fragility curves for the seismic assessment of the pounding effect between the adjacent structures at different performance levels are developed. 3. Multi-parametric investigations to assess the validity of analysis assumptions and results are carried out. 4. A fragility-based framework to evaluate the minimum separation gap distance dg,min between adjacent structures is developed. 5. A methodology to calibrate the seismic risk of RC structures against pounding and to determine the optimal separation gap distance at different structural pounding risk levels is proposed. For these purposes, the present dissertation includes the following: Based on the literature review in the research area of the earthquake-induced pounding the case study of this research is defined. Therefore, the examined pounding case is an interaction case between an 8-story RC frame and a 3-story rigid barrier. The assumption of using a rigid 3-story structure is adopted in order the overall assessment of the pounding risk to be engaged only on the global and local demands of the 8-story RC frame. It is also noted that extensive work in this research area revealed that the seismic performance of a tall flexible frame structure is critically increased due to the interaction with an adjacent stiffer and shorter structure. In addition, emphasis is given to modelling the actual behavior parameters of the structural members to provide an accurate nonlinear model. The analytical model incorporates details of geometries, masses, reinforcement, nonlinear finite elements, materials, confinement, etc. Based on the literature, the following two distinctive types of structural pounding are recognized and examined in this study: a) the floor-to-floor structural pounding (Type A), and b) the inter-story (floor-to-column) structural pounding (Type B). Furthermore, the critical global and local engineering demand parameters are defined taking into account observed failure modes due to structural pounding from past earthquakes. For the needs of this study, three different initial gap distances dg between the adjacent structures are considered, while the seismic performance of the RC frame structure without the pounding effect is also estimated. Afterwards, the examined intensity measures (IMs) are defined, and the seismic excitations are selected based on the characteristics of ground motions. The Incremental Dynamic Analysis (IDA) and Cloud Analysis (CA) are employed to define the seismic demands of the 8-story RC structure due to the pounding effect and 2733 nonlinear dynamic analyses are performed. 1. Linear and bilinear probabilistic seismic demand models (PSDMs). Linear and bilinear PSDMs are developed in order to describe the seismic performances of the structures for the examined cases of this study (without pounding and due to structural pounding). It is stressed that: a) the local inelastic demands of the structural members, and b) the inter-story pounding case are incorporated for the first time in the probabilistic seismic assessment of the pounding effect. In addition, global and local PSDMs are developed as a function of different EDPs, different separation gap distances dg, and different IMs. The results of this study reveal that linear regression models confirm better the global seismic performance of the structure. On the other hand, the local performances of the critical structural members in terms of flexural and shear demands are adequately described based on bilinear regression models. Results also indicate that the IM considered for the development of the PSDM may significantly influence the estimation of structural demand. In general, a reliable prediction of the seismic structural response is accomplished when IMs with small variability are used. 2. PSDM-based fragility curves. Fragility curves of the 8-story RC structure are developed taking into account different performance levels, separation gap distances dg and intensity measures (IMs). The proposed linear and bilinear PSDMs are used for the fragility assessment of the 8-story RC structure (without pounding and due to structural pounding). It is stressed that: a) the global and local performances, and b) the inter-story pounding case are incorporated for the first time in the fragility assessment of the structural pounding effect. Based on the results of this study, it can be concluded that the local performances of the 8-story RC frame are the key parameter for the fragility assessment of the pounding effect since the flexural and the shear demands are critically increased. In addition, the type of structural pounding (Type A or Type B) that is occurred between the adjacent structures alters the results of the fragility assessment of the 8-story RC frame especially in the case of local performances. Also, the 8-story RC frame is more vulnerable to pounding with the adjacent 3-story rigid structure as smaller between them is the initial separation gap distance dg. Also, the selection of an appropriate IM leads to a small dispersion of the structural demand and minimizes the uncertainties introduced in the fragility assessment. Thereafter, different methodologies for developing fragility curves are utilized to validate the fragility assessment of the structural pounding effect based on the proposed PSDMs. In addition, the validity of the assumptions commonly used to produce a PSDM and their influence on the fragility assessment of the 8-story RC frame structure is identified. The results of this study show that a) the proposed linear and bilinear PSDMs can accurately evaluate the fragility assessment of the RC structure, b) the PSDM’s assumptions are not satisfied within the overall range of the examined IM especially in the case of local EDPs, while bilinear PSDMs allows the relaxation of the homoscedasticity assumption at each linear segment and c) linear PSDMs adequately estimate the fragility assessment of the 8-story RC frame in terms of global EDPs, while bilinear regression model is required to describe the local inelastic demands of the structural members. 3. Multi-parametric investigations to assess the validity of analysis assumptions, and results. In the present dissertation the influence of different parameters on the fragility assessment of the RC structure is also examined. In this direction a) the adequacy of examined IMs (PGA and Sa,T1) in terms of efficiency and sufficiency is evaluated in comparison to other 21 IMs, b) the influence of ground motion characteristics (Mw and Rrup) on the structure’s fragility is examined and c) the suitability of performing the IDA procedure to estimate the structural performances is evaluated in comparison to the Cloud Analysis method and the resulting fragility curves are compared and discussed. The results of this study indicate that Sa,T1 is more efficient in predicting the examined seismic demands of the 8-story RC frame structure in comparison to PGA. In general, the structural dependent IMs have shown better predictive capability than the structural independent IMs. However, the satisfaction of efficiency indicates a lack of sufficiency and vice versa. Therefore, an optimal IM that satisfies simultaneously the criteria of efficiency and sufficiency is difficult to be identified. The influence of Mw or Rrup on the fragility assessment is also evaluated by considering them as elements in a vector-valued IM with Sa,T1. The research shows that the variation of Mw and Rrup alters the results of the fragility assessment against structural pounding. However, considering the median values of Mw and Rrup in the vector-valued Sa,T1 the assessment yielded similar results to the one deduced based on the scalar Sa,T1 fragilities. Finally, IDA-based fragility assessment is very close to that obtained from Cloud-based fragility assessment. In any case, special attention should be given to the criteria that are adopted for selecting the ground motion records to perform the dynamic analyses. 4. Fragility-based framework for the evaluation of the minimum required separation gap distance dg,min. Thereafter, a fragility-based framework is developed to estimate the minimum separation gap distance dg,min between adjacent structures incorporating the global and local performances of the structure. The proposed methodology minimizes the effect of the structural pounding by ensuring acceptable local or/and global performance levels. The main attributes of the proposed methodology are the following: a) is implemented for the verification and the determination of the minimum critical value of separation gap distance between the adjacent structures, b) new performance levels thresholds PL-EDP of the seismic demands as a function of the separation gap distance dg are defined, c) more than one performance levels thresholds PL-EDP can be engaged (as combination of global and local EDPs at different performance levels PLi), and d) the method is independent of the type of structural pounding that occurs between the adjacent structures. The critical minimum separation gap distance dg,min, can be defined based on two criteria: a) based on a targeted level of IM and b) based on a targeted probability of structural pounding to occur. Thereafter, numerical examples are presented. Results indicate that the displacement demand δmax that causes an acceptable performance level is greater than the available separation dg. In the case of structural pounding Type B, the critical minimum separation gap distance dg,min is controlled by the local demands of the structure that suffers the structural pounding effect. On the contrary, when the structural pounding Type A is considered, the minimum critical value of the separation distance dg,min against pounding is controlled by the global engineering demand of IDRmax. 5. Novel methodology for calibrating the seismic risk of adjacent structures against pounding and determination of the optimal seismic separation gap distance. Finally, a novel methodology for calibrating the seismic risk of adjacent structures against pounding at different capacity levels by means of mean annual frequency (MAF) of exceeding a specific seismic performance criterion is introduced. In particular, a novel risk-targeted decision model is introduced to a) verify the seismic performance of structures, b) evaluate the adequacy of an available separation gap distance dg, and c) define the minimum acceptable separation gap distance dg,min,Pt (optimal) between the adjacent RC structures at a target probability Pt. Key issues for developing the proposed methodology are a) the demand hazard curve of the δmax at the top level of the potential pounding top contact point, and b) the acceptable structural pounding performance objectives (POs) of an EDP against structural pounding as a function of the separation gap distance dg. The determination of the optimal seismic separation gap distance is based on the best estimation of the dg (among δmax and δPO) that causes an acceptable PO at a target probability Pt. A set of different EDPs can be involved and more than one structural pounding performance objectives (POs) can be evaluated. Furthermore, the proposed methodology can be implemented to a) determine the minimum acceptable seismic risk P against structural pounding for a targeted value of separation gap distance dg,t between adjacent structures, and b) to access smaller values of the optimal separation gap distance between adjacent structures at an acceptable level of seismic risk against structural pounding (targeted POs-EDP). Thereafter, numerical examples based on the proposed methodology are presented for the cases: a) calibration of seismic risk of the examined RC structure and b) determination of the optimal separation gap distance dg,min,Pt at a target probability Pt. The results of this study indicate that the seismic risk of the 8-story RC structure is significantly increased due to structural pounding in comparison to the case of without pounding. The value of separation gap distance dg alters the evaluation of the seismic risk. In particular, the seismic risk is increased when the separation gap distance dg is decreased. The level of seismic risk of the 8-story RC frame depends on the examined POs-EDP. Also, the return period TR of exceeding a specific performance level is decreased, while the annual probability is increased due to the effect of the structural pounding. An optimal seismic separation gap distance based only on the maximum displacement (δmax) is not always a safe prediction to control the structural pounding seismic risk. Finally, the results indicate that the value of the estimated dg,min,Pt is influenced by the type of structural pounding that occurs between the adjacent structures. In particular, in the case of structural pounding Type A (floor-to-floor interaction) the global POs-IDRmax controls the estimation of the dg,min,Pt. However, when the structural pounding Type B (floor-to-column interaction) is considered, the estimation of the optimal dg,min,Pt is controlled by the local POs (μφ,max, Vmax).
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Patras
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Flenga, Maria
- Φλέγγα, Μαρία
Subjects
dc:subject × 60- Αλληλεπίδραση κατασκευών
- Ισοσταθμία πλακών
- Ανισοσταθμία πλακών
- Σεισμικός αρμός
- Γραμμικό πιθανοτικό μοντέλο σεισμικής απαίτησης
- Διγραμμικό πιθανοτικό μοντέλο σεισμικής απαίτησης
- Καμπύλη τρωτότητας
- Στάθμες επιτελεστικότητας
- Παράμετρος σεισμικής απαίτησης
- Μέτρο έντασης
- Αποτελεσματικότητα
- Επάρκεια
- Μοντέλο απόφασης
- Στοχευμένο επίπεδο σεισμικού ρίσκου
- Επίπεδο επιτελεστικότητας
- Κριτήριο ελέγχου
- Σεισμικός ρίσκος
- Μέση ετήσια πιθανότητα
- Καμπύλη σεισμικής επικινδυνότητας
- Καμπύλη επικινδυνότητας μεγεθών σεισμικής απόκρισης
- Καθολικά μεγέθη απόκρισης
- Τοπικά μεγέθη απόκρισης
- Ανελαστικές μη γραμμικές δυναμικές αναλύσεις
- Πεπερασμένα στοιχεία προσομοίωσης
- Οπλισμένο σκυρόδεμα
- Πολυώροφη κατασκευή
- Ευρωκώδικας 8
- Structural pounding
- Floor-to-floor pounding
- Inter-story pounding (floor-to-column)
- Separation gap distance
- Linear probabilistic seismic demand model
- Bilinear probabilistic seismic demand model
- Fragility curves
- Performance levels
- Engineering demand parameter
- Intensity measure
- Efficiency property
- Sufficiency property
- Decision model
- Target probability
- Performance level threshold
- Performance objective
- Seismic risk
- Mean annual probability
- Seismic hazard curve
- Demand hazard curve
- Global performances
- Local performances
- Nonlinear dynamic analyses
- Finite elements
- Reinforced concrete
- Multistory structure
- Eurocode 8
- Επιστήμη Πολιτικού Μηχανικού
- Επιστήμες Μηχανικού και Τεχνολογία
- Δομοστατική
- Civil Engineering
- Engineering and Technology
- Structural Engineering
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/55169