Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
Impacts of road networks on brown bear (Ursus arctos) and mitigation measures
Abstract
dc:descriptionRoad networks, with their multiple impacts on the landscape and wildlife, are considered one of the main drivers of biodiversity loss. The most important road effects on wildlife are the road-related mortality and the barrier effects, which may isolate certain sub-populations increasing their extinction risk. Large mammals are particularly vulnerable to road effects due to their wide-ranging movements and low reproductive rates. Road construction projects have always been promoters of development for humans, but their negative road effects on biodiversity should be minimized (Chapter I). The mitigation hierarchy (avoid, mitigate, restore, compensate) is now being recommended, aiming to achieve no net loss outcomes, or even net gain outcomes. Thus, during the past 20 years, more and more mitigation measures have been tested and adopted to mitigate road effects. The common practice is to deal with mitigation during road construction, and hence, manage road verges and adopt and adapt measures on the roadway from the start. The main two goals to achieve are animal-vehicle collision reduction and connectivity preservation. To this end, there are many available mitigation measures that cover a wide range of costs and effectiveness. Animal-vehicle collisions is the most profound road effect on wildlife and their reduction has been one of the main goals of mitigation strategies worldwide. In Greece, the most known animal vehicle collisions involve brown bears, and the outcome of bear-vehicle collisions usually results in human injury, extensive property damage and animal fatality. Thus, we investigated these collisions from 2005 to 2020 in northwestern Greece (Chapter II). We recorded 101 bear-vehicle collisions and identified four collision hotspots, where 58% of total collisions occurred. The number of collisions with bears seems to follow activity patterns and hence, most collisions occurred during mating and hyperphagia. They also happened during the night when animals are more active, and there are low conspicuity conditions. Our results also showed that most collisions were most probably unavoidable as the estimated stopping distance was larger than the respective sight distance. There is not a “one size fits all” mitigation strategy. Rather, we should utilize all available knowledge and tools to effectively mitigate roadkill hotspots, while raising driver awareness and promoting vigilant driving in unfenced areas. Roads are also a barrier for wildlife, and it is crucial to act proactively and preserve connectivity by creating safe crossing opportunities for wildlife. To this end, the cooperation of wildlife experts and engineers is crucial to achieve permeable roads. We investigated the case study of E65 and followed a method that enabled us to evaluate the need for design adaptations to limit the motorway’s impact on brown bears (Chapter III). CALLISTO supplied past telemetry and denning data, as well as raw field data from transect surveys (biosigns) and camera-traps. Using these, we calculated relative abundance and estimated biosign density. Following, we mapped habitat suitability in the area of the motorway alignment and connectivity of the study area as is, before the motorway construction and as it will be after the motorway construction. In turn, we utilized these results to calculate two cumulative indexes, one for the state before the motorway construction and one for the state after, to assess location significance (by 660m segment) and identify areas where it is crucial to preserve permeability. We also examined all the foreseen crossing structures and used a sorting key to classify them in four suitability categories. Lastly, we juxtaposed the cumulative indexes with the foreseen crossing structures and used a simple process to determine whether the foreseen structures per segment are adequate, or connectivity should be somehow enhanced. We used a similar process to also evaluate the impact of all accompanying constructions, such as borrow and rubble pits, construction roads, etc. After careful consideration of our results, we drafted mitigation proposals to mitigate road effects on brown bears. We considered animal disturbance and collisions with vehicles, but the majority of detailed proposals refer to measures and adaptations in crossing structures that can enhance connectivity and ensure that the motorway will be permeable. We further propose the incorporation of two additional structures to the motorway designs. The implementation of all suggestions drafted can render the motorway permeable up to 72%, with only a handful of short (>1.3 km and <2 km) stretches remaining as impermeable for bears. We also drafted respective suggestions for the accompanying constructions that seem to have a strong impact on bear habitat suitability and will greatly disturb probable denning sites. With societies demanding consideration of ecological issues within any construction project, road planners attempt to incorporate biodiversity issues into road design. Hence, over the past few decades, several mitigation measures have been tested and implemented to reduce the impact of roads on wildlife. Still, there are caveats to be considered and hence, the input of road ecologists is deemed necessary to efficiently tackle road effects. Wildlife experts should follow comprehensive methodologies and draft detailed mitigation proposals, as exact specifications, and siting and spacing are crucial factors in achieving mitigation success. The close cooperation of wildlife experts and road planners is vital in keeping the socio-economic needs of humans and the needs of wildlife balanced within comprehensive, cost-effective mitigation strategies.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Psaralexi, Maria
- Ψαραλέξη, Μαρία
Subjects
dc:subject × 18- Καφέ αρκούδα
- Οδικά δίκτυα
- Τροχαία ατυχήματα
- Επιπτώσεις οδικών δικτύων
- Μέτρα
- Brown bear
- Transportation networks
- Road effects
- Animal vehicle collisions
- Road ecology
- Mitigation measures
- Road permeability
- Βιολογία
- Φυσικές Επιστήμες
- Διατήρηση της βιοποικιλότητας
- Biological Sciences
- Natural Sciences
- Biodiversity Conservation
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/55170