University of Crete (UOC)
Γνωσιακοί μηχανισμοί επεξεργασίας νοήματος: νοητικά συστήματα που συνεργάζονται με τον γλωσσικό επεξεργαστή
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe thesis examines the formation of meaning in communicative interaction, with the assumption that beyond the linguistic mechanism, non-linguistic mechanisms are activated for the full recovery of meaning. The first part of the thesis is primarily a critical review of theoretical approaches, including the role and function of the Theory of Mind, joint attention, the asymmetry between prediction and explanation, and the function of both linguistic and non-linguistic mechanisms. This section concludes with the hypothesis of a 'common operating system' that is supposed to run through the human cognition. The second part focuses on the study of operators, linguistic tools through which non-linguistic mechanisms contribute to the addition of meaning, specifically examining causal operators. The analysis follows Sweetser’s (1990) tripartite distinction of domains: content, epistemic and speech act. A distinction is proposed between genuine and trivial speech acts, predicting that trivial uses precede genuine ones in language acquisition, a prediction confirmed by the data. Within the proposed theoretical framework, operators functioning ‘conceptually’, such as “epiði”, require triggering by linguistic segments, possess greater explicitness requirements and form basic level explicatures. On the other hand, procedural operators, such as “jati” and “afu”, mobilize representations not dependent on linguistic mechanism and constitute higher-order explicatures. While the latter provide epistemic and speech act information, the former require explicit statements of epistemic or speech act content and thus remain within the content domain. Developmentally, based on data concerning the order of operator acquisition, it is argued that procedural operators precede ‘conceptual' ones: mental operations that begin unconsciously are linguistically exposed to consciousness during development. Particular emphasis is placed on the ‘causal’ operator “afu”, which is argued not to be a purely causal operator but rather one that manages the mutual cognitive environment (Kalokerinos 2001, 2004), an assumption tested and confirmed experimentally. Data were collected from 109 adult native speakers of Greek, and the results align with the theoretical framework tested. Moreover, “afu” shares properties with the French causal operator “puisque” (Zufferey 2014). The theoretical model proposed for the study of causal operators in adult language is then adapted for the case of children. By incorporating the mutual perceptual environment of joint attention, a three-level developmental hierarchy is proposed, based on the metarepresentational ability required for the use of the operator in different contexts. A developmental order of appearance of Greek causal operators is also proposed, consisting of three stages: in the first stage, the child manages the non-mental content domain by triggering a simple basic explicature with the use of “jati”; in the second stage, the mental and speech act domains are managed with triggering of a high-level explicature using “jati” and “afu”; and in the third stage, more complex basic explicatures, in mental and speech act domains, are triggered using “jati”, “afu” and later, “epiði”. Two original experiments were conducted with 32 and 9 participants aged 3;5 – 6;8 and 2;11 – 5;2 respectively, and data were drawn from two databases to investigate the order of acquisition of Greek causal operators and the relationship between the three domains of modality. The results support the proposed theoretical framework. Furthermore, data show that children are able to construct and manage complex structures, such as those involving irrealis “jati”, at an early age. This finding is taken as evidence that most non-linguistic mechanisms are activated asynchronously, supporting the hypothesis of a modular architecture of the mind. Overall, the findings suggest that, in terms of explanation referring to intentional agents is concerned, it is possible to begin without a fully formed Theory of Mind.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Crete (UOC)
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Giannadaki, Kyriaki
- Γιανναδάκη, Κυριακή
Subjects
dc:subject × 56- Πειραματική πραγματολογία
- Γλωσσική κατάκτηση
- Αιτιολογικοί τελεστές
- Θεωρία της νόησης
- Ελληνικοί σύνδεσμοι
- Διαδικασιακό νόημα
- Εκνόημα
- Υπονόημα
- Γλωσσικές πράξεις
- Eπιστημικό πεδίο
- Αμοιβαίο γνωσιακό περιβάλλον
- Από κοινού προσοχή
- Οριοθετημένη ορθολογικότητα
- Επαγωγικός συλλογισμός
- Παραγωγικός συλλογισμός
- Πρόβλεψη
- Εξήγηση
- Μεταναπαραστάσεις
- Θεωρία της συνάφειας
- Μη-πραγματικό νόημα
- Υποσυστημικότητα της νόησης
- Νοανάγνωση
- Πραγματολογικοί μηχανισμοί
- Πραγματολογικές διαδικασίες
- Στάδια γλωσσικής κατάκτησης
- Experimental pragmatics
- Language acquisition
- Causal operators
- Theory of mind
- Greek connectives
- Procedural meaning
- Explicature
- Implicature
- Speech acts
- Epistemic domain
- Mutual cognitive environment
- Joint attention
- Bounded rationality
- Inductive reasoning
- Deductive reasoning
- Prediction
- Explanation
- Metarepresentations
- Relevance theory
- Irrealis meaning
- Modularity of mind
- Mind‐reading
- Pragmatic mechanisms
- Pragmatic processes
- Stages of language acquisition
- Γλώσσα και Λογοτεχνία
- Ανθρωπιστικές Επιστήμες και Τέχνες
- Γλώσσα και Γλωσσολογία
- Languages and Literature
- Humanities and the Arts
- Language and Linguistics
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/55318