Panteion University of Social and Political Sciences
Στρατός και ατομικές ελευθερίες: παραβιάσεις δικαιωμάτων στρατευμένων στην Τρίτη Ελληνική Δημοκρατία
Abstract
dc:descriptionFollowing the Greek junta, most members of the Hellenic Armed Forces, accustomed for decades to treating enlisted soldiers as devoid of rights, with the exception of life or even physical integrity and the privileged one, were not discharged and remained in the barracks. Improvement initially occurred mainly in practice due to the fear of control by politicians and especially the non-right-wing opposition. Almost concurrently with the government change of 1981, an assertive movement emerged, advocating for the recognition of nearly all individual rights for conscripts and the enhancement of their conditions. Significant legal changes would be introduced, particularly within the next 20 years. Improvements would go beyond the rules of law in some respects. Even today, however, basic individual rights are not recognized and legislative provisions that protect them are not implemented. Soldiers are entitled to the same rights as other citizens, except in cases where clear constitutional provisions specifically exclude them. Of course, their individual rights are restricted mainly for reasons of public interest. These restrictions (must) be subject to judicial review. The right to form associations defending military life interests is not recognized, although it is acknowledged for professional military personnel. The prohibition of expression for or against a political party is not sufficiently specified. Unconstitutional restrictions persist on freedom of expression, notably seen in the prohibition of criticism. Provisions deemed unconstitutional by case law are yet to be amended. Moreover, soldiers are uniquely barred from lodging written complaints, despite the clear constitutional provision allowing for written petitions. Compulsory involvement in religious activities and forbidden questions about religious beliefs predominantly impact minorities, creating an environment within the institution that is less friendly to them compared to other branches of the state apparatus. Simultaneously, it appears that the state can order the service soldier to perform various tasks, despite the legality of forced labor being limited to specific contexts, predominantly related to duties of a "military nature" rather than just general "soldier" duties. The conduct of intra-military investigations following suspicions of illegal acts may breach the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), primarily due to the involvement of unit executives in the investigation not being prohibited. Despite an improvement over the pre-1995 repulsive situation and the 2019 constitutional revision, the full legislative establishment of the independence of military justice functionaries remains incomplete. Regarding disciplinary penalties, the extension of military service as a form of punishment, and much more the lack of control of disciplinary penalties of conscripts presented by the case law as "internal order measures" violate individual rights. In 2022, a peculiar three-stage oral quasi-judicial appeal process was exclusively designated for soldiers. Equality is still blatantly violated due to the clientelistic state, while instances of illegal hazing persist, undermining affect dignity, honor, personality, health and freedom of will. Relevant criminal provisions, though existing, remain inexplicably dormant and unenforced. Legislative changes, effective information of soldiers and professionals on the rights of the former, as well as the assistance of the Ombudsperson are essential prerequisites for significantly reducing violations.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Panteion University of Social and Political Sciences
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Papadimas, Ioannis
- Παπαδήμας, Ιωάννης
Subjects
dc:subject × 16Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/55535