National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Monumentic arched structures: stability, seismic response, soil-structure interaction
Abstract
dc:descriptionHistoric building and structural environment of Greece is a denotable asset of the Hellenic Cultural Heritage. Stability of monumental buildings is affected by many factors which should all be taken into consideration when preservation, restoration, repairing or strengthening procedures are about to be conducted. One of these factors is the monument’s interaction with soil which plays a fundamental role to the structural stability. With reference to the interplay between structure and soil, monuments of the Hellenic territory can be grouped in two major categories:(i) Structural systems rising above the ground such as historical buildings, ancient temples, arches, entrance gateways, bridges etc. In this type of structures, soil performs exclusively as a supporting medium, as superstructural loads are transmitted to it through foundation. ii) Geostructures, such as underground tunnels, structural support systems (bastions in castles or fortresses, retaining walls), ancient theaters, mounds, etc. In this case the ground, in addition to a supporting medium, can load the construction with its own weight or even to be supported by her. The principal components of those heritage structures is the masonry arch which is an articulated structure, composed of wedge-shaped stones (voussoirs). These stones are arranged on a curved line retaining their position by mutual pressure. Occasionally, they are also reinforced with mortar at joints. Therefore, the study focuses on specific monumental structures as representative examples:•The arch structure in its simplest form on a rigid base. Two different profiles are taken into consideration, the circular and the hybrid elliptical-circular called from now on “part-elliptical”.Specifically, seismic response of masonry arches is examined in this study by means of analytical and numerical methods. Emphasis is placed on the low-amplitude levels where linearisation techniques may be efficient. When dealing with monumental arches of fragmented masonry, rocking rotation even in low levels is most often undesirable as it may lead to severe permanent displacements and dislocation of the arch axis, and sometimes to general instability of the structure. It is therefore of great importance to develop simplified procedures for estimating the levels of such low-amplitude arch response in earthquake prone regions. Near-source ground excitation at the base of the structure is idealised with rectangular and cycloidal pulses. The analysis is limited to the prior-to-impact regime in which rocking occurs between successive fragments (voussoirs). Yet, this limitation does not prevent from extracting conclusions, as the prior-to-impact state is the most crucial to rocking response and it can determine whether the structure will undergo rocking vibration or eventually overturns. For simplicity, a specific kinematic mechanism of the fragmented arch, well-known in the literature is implemented throughout the study, thus allowing for comparison of the results with existing solutions. This idealisation is justified as the predominant mechanism from both previous analytical and experimental studies. A good correlation of the results between simplified closed-form solutions and rigorous semi-analytical methods is accomplished. Moreover, these results are also quite close to those of the 2-d finite element analysis. Next, a segmental arch consisting of an elliptical upper part (extrados) and a circular lower part (intrados) is introduced. This so-called part-elliptical arch is treated as a rigid monolithic body enabled to rock on a triggering base. The objective of the study is to extend the established methods applicable to the conventional circular arches, particularly in terms of: (a) stability analysis which is performed in static terms to calculate the hinge locations as well as the minimum ground acceleration at the onset of rocking, given the slenderness and the angle of embrace of the arch, (b) time-history analysis of rocking prior to impact is then feasible as the transition criterion from the full-contact to rocking phase has been established from the previous step. The results are presented comparatively to those extracted from the circular arch of the same geometric characteristics. •A masonry barrel vault (which behave as a series of side-by side arches) supported by lateral walls. Assumed for simplicity for the static and dynamic analyses, the masonry vault is thus reduced to that of a masonry vault with equal profile and thickness. Buttresses operate by applying a counterforce opposing the thrust induced by the arch. In addition to the arch geometry, buttress dimensions play a crucial role to the horizontal capacity of the entire structure. Depending on the arch-to-buttress relative proportion, three different hinging mechanisms can arise as mentioned in the literature. The aforementioned states (mechanisms) regard the location of the four ruptures (hinges) that will initiate the rocking mode of the structure. The mechanism which is mobilised for slender buttresses is investigated. Furthermore, a three dimensional finite element model of two different geometries, consisting of individual voussoirs is triggered with idealised pulses of various frequencies and acceleration amplitudes. The nonlinear response of these structures is determined by the produced overturning spectra and the developed collapse mechanisms. •A common barrel vault with part-circular uniform profile supported at its ends by transverse walls, and surrounded by soil. Soil structure interaction effects are implemented to investigate the stability of masonry arches supported on buttresses. Initially, a schematic illustration of the model under its self-weight and the forces acting on it are presented along with two possible cases of pressure redistribution above the structure. In the first case the arch sustains the whole overburden load whilst in the second case the phenomenon of arching effect is associated with the transfer of the load at the surrounding soil. Emphasis is given to the construction sequence of the cut & cover structure throughout the whole chapter. A series of sophisticated nonlinear FE analysis is performed to models whose soil profiles are described as homogeneous cohesive. The elastoplastic soil behaviour under undrained conditions is described with Von-Mises failure criterion combined with an isotropic and kinematic hardening model in the post-yielding domain. Considerable attention is given to the induced lateral earth pressures and displacements acting on crucial points. The effect of the arch geometric characteristics is also investigated and the results are presented comparatively. Ultimately, the soil stratum is subjected to idealised pulses and records of acceleration time histories
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Leontari, Aikaterini
- Λεοντάρη, Αικατερίνη
Subjects
dc:subject × 18- Μνημεία
- Μηχανισμός κατάρρευσης
- Αντισεισμική μηχανική
- Αλληλεπίδραση εδάφους-κατασκευής
- Λικνισμός
- Ανάλυση πεπερασμένων στοιχείων
- Monuments
- Collapse mechanism
- Earthquake engineering
- Soil-structure interaction
- Rocking
- Finite element analysis
- Επιστήμη Πολιτικού Μηχανικού
- Επιστήμες Μηχανικού και Τεχνολογία
- Δομοστατική
- Civil Engineering
- Engineering and Technology
- Structural Engineering
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/55566