Back to search

National and Kapodistrian University of Athens

Ισοτοπική ιχνηλασιμότητα των πρώτων υλών της αρχαίας υάλου

Abstract

dc:description

It is known that, in different periods of history, glass was produced from a solid material acting as “former” (usually silica –SiO2), which is the main component of glass and mainly derived from quartzitic-calcitic sand or quartz pebbles and the addition of a flux, consisting of natron (term adopted here to mean usually complex, often polyphasic sodium carbonate-rich evaporite deposits). Natron, can be found in ash from burning halophytic plants like Salsola or Salicornia, or in potash ash from burning trees like beech, birch and oak. The use of natron, as a raw material, took place for about 20 centuries, from the first millennium BC to 1000 A.D. For all these centuries the origin of the used Natron was mainly from the natural natron deposits found in the evaporating lakes of the Wadi Natron in the oases of the Western Desert of Egypt. The same source can therefore be assumed for the glasses found in Greece. However, Lake Pikrolimni of Macedonia has been known as a source of natron and was proven as such in the international literature since 2003. The first salt analysis from Pikrolimni showed the existence of sodium carbonate [trona (Na2CO3 * NaHCO3 * 2H2O) and bourkeite (Na2CO3 * 2Na2SO4] and halite (NaCl). This mineralogical sequence was consistent with that of the Wadi Natron. It should also be emphasized that natural natron deposits in the region of Macedonia in northern Greece were known in the 5th century B.C., as “nitron halastraion”, making the problem of the origin of the basic materials more complicated. In Greece, some early data of some Greco-Roman soda glasses reveal the problem of the provenance of the glasses suggesting that these glasses were probably made in different factories with different production technologies and were not produced using material from the famous sources of glass-making materials (natron from Wadi Natrun in Egypt, sand of Belus or Volturnus). Furthermore, preliminary scientific data on soda glasses highlights the problem related to the origin of the raw material (natron), indicating that these glasses were probably made locally from a different raw material and/or imported. Indeed, the importation of raw glass further complicates the existing international problem of identifying the origin, local or foreign, of the basic glass components and fusing processes. Additionally, after the 7th century A.D. the use of natron began to be limited, mainly due to the increased demand, and consequently it was replaced from plant ashes, making the geographical tracking of raw materials quite difficult. The use of plant ashes, being always a widespread first material for the manufacture of glasses, began to gradually prevail from the 9th century A.D. The cessation of the use of sodium , from the 9th century A.D., marks a new era in the production of glass, since new raw materials are used, mainly local ones. At the same time, until 1000 A.D., the production of glasses continued in northwestern Europe with the traditional raw materials that were transported from long distances. Collectively, the glassmaking process, 800–1700 A.D., relied primarily on fusing a silicate component (e.g., quartz sand, crushed quartz pebbles) with a flux (e.g., potassium-rich plant ashes or sodium). Sometimes calcium-rich material (such as limestone, shells, or ground marble) was added and small amounts of pigments, opacifiers or decolorizers and a source of lead in the melt were also used. Additionally, we can mention that from the 15th to the 19th century, 5 types of glasses were produced:- soda-calcium-silica [Islamic, Venetian ( VC , VVB , VC ) and 'à la façon de Venise ']- potassium-calcium-silica [ Waldglas or 'forest glass, HLLA, Crystal (KB) and Bohemian glass (GB), ' Verre de fougere '].- calcium-silicon (forest glass manufactured in France and Germany).- Mixed alkali glass and- Lead glass or flint glass ', ' lead crystal ', ' crystal glass '.As can be seen from the above, the use of these different raw materials affected the final chemical compositions of the resulting glass. To date, chemical analyzes of ancient glasses provide clear evidence of the use of a different raw material, but little is known about the origin of the glass and its raw materials. In this context, the existence in Greece of local glass vessels, as well as the importation and trade of raw glass and glass artefacts, possibly produced in Near Eastern or Middle Eastern countries, draws attention to the importance of: 1) recognizing the " fingerprint" of glass artefacts B.C. and mainly of Roman and late ancient glass made in Greece, 2) distinguishing raw materials and flows used for glass melting, 3) defining production technologies while in the same time (indirectly), constraining the age of the analyzed objects. Measurements of radiogenic isotopes (Sr, Nd) and stable isotopes of oxygen (δ18O) and carbon (13C) in glass samples and raw materials seem a promising tool to face these new scientific challenges. The current Τhesis is actually the first study concerning the analyses of B.C., Roman and late antiquity raw materials and glass from Greece with chemical, mineralogical and isotopic methods of oxygen (O), neodymium (Nd) and strontium (Sr), in order to determine the raw materials, the production technologies and identify the "fingerprint" of local producers. In this context, glass samples were selected, originating from various regions of Greece, aged from the 8th century B.C. to the 19th century A.D. and were analyzed in terms of their isotopic and chemical composition. The glass objects were provided from the Museum of Byzantine Culture of Thessaloniki and the Archaeological Museum Thessaloniki. The relevant archaeological information for the samples were provided and compiled by the archaeologists, Dr. Antonaras and Dr. Ignatiadou. Glass objects from Pydna and Methoni, dating from the 8th to the 2nd century B.C., were extensively examined based on their chemical and isotopic data. The combined use of multiple analytical techniques allowed the elemental and isotopic characterization of these polychromatic and colorless glass artefacts in order to examine their provenance. All of the glass fragments could be classified as natron glass made from a mixture of clean silica-rich sand containing sea shells and natron (probably from two different sources). The assemblage shows similar chemical characteristics to contemporary artefacts from archaeological sites on the Black Sea coast of modern Georgia and the Italian peninsula confirming the use of identical raw materials. Sr-Nd isotopic sources of glass shards from Syro-Palestine, which were produced from Belus sand, indicate that the raw materials of the objects from Pieria could have come from the Syro-Palestinian coast. Therefore, based on the strontium and neodymium isotopic signatures, most of the Pieria glass artifacts are likely from a Syro-Palestinian production site, although the exact location is unknown. Furthermore, the oxygen isotopic signature of most samples indicates the manufacture of the objects from raw materials of primary origin along the Syro-Palestinian coast. However, the use of specific raw materials cannot be ruled out for some artifacts. Indeed, some glass objects appear to have been produced with different raw materials, as suggested by enriched δ18O values, possibly indicating a different glassmaking tradition. In addition, the correlation of the isotopic values of the moles and the 'mixed' glassy objects (Mn - Sb) with the sodium oxides, shows that the addition of natron during the preparation of the glass batch, causes an enrichment of δ18O in the final glass [δ18O = f (Na2O)], essentially affecting its composition, during its apparent remelting. Roman and Late Antiquity glass samples were selected and analyzed for their oxygen isotopic and chemical composition. The results show that the majority of the glass samples were produced using natron as a flux, suggesting that the raw materials likely came from the Levantine region. A limited number of samples are highly enriched in δ18O and their chemical composition clearly indicates that they were made with sodium carbonate as a flux. Isotopic and chemical data do not exclude the hypothesis of local production of the above samples. For all glass artefacts, similarities with the corresponding age groups in the literature are reported and discussed. Most glasses from the 10th to 19th centuries are 'calco-potassic', and were manufactured with plant ashes as the dominant fusing agent, possibly from land plants, which are rich in calcium and magnesium, but poorer in potassium.To confirm the different plant fluxes used for manufacture, we used the normalized flux K2O* [K2O* = K2O / (Na2O + K2O + CaO + MgO + P2O5)] against the Na2O* [Na2O* = Na2O / (Na2O + K2O + CaO + MgO + P2O5) content of the glass fragments. Normalized fluxes provide information primarily on the ash cleaning process used by glassmakers, i.e. the extent to which insoluble CaO and MgO are effectively removed from the flux. In genuine Venetian glass (Cristallo) about 75% of the ash material is soda and potash. The 'common' and the 'Vitrum Blanchum' glass, used from the 14th century onwards was manufactured with less pure raw materials than glasses Cristallo, which was top quality.For the composition of Façon de Venise these K2O*-Na2O* values are much lower (60%) and close to 'Vitrum Blanchum' glass.It was observed that based only on the K2O*-Na2O* values, no conclusion could be confirmed on the yield of the glass origin. Only with the concurrent use of K2O*-Na2O* and the elements Al - K - Fe we were able to distinguish the Façon de Venise and 'Vitrum Blanchum' glasses. A comparison was also made with 'White' glass' of the 19th century from Bohemia, with those produced with Barilla ash, Façon de Venise glasses and genuine Venetian glasses that were produced in European cities. It is possible that some of the objects studied were produced locally. Glasses with a high alumina concentration showed values similar to those of glasses from Pergamos. This group of glass is thought to have been produced locally during the late Byzantine and Islamic periods, placing new regional units in the known centers of glass production. Also, the P2O5 – CaO values of some glasses, belonging to this group, indicate recycling and/or secondary processing, but calcium phosphate is also used as opacifying agent. Both the recycling technology and the opaque technology demonstrate that some glasses are not a product of primary production, but originate from some older glass either through recycling (remelting), or through the reuse of old glasses. In addition, the aim of this thesis is to enhance the oxygen isotope database of not only archaeological glasses, but also to identify isotopic trends indicating different raw materials, production technologies and/or provenance. In this framework and in order to correlate the Greek raw materials in the manufacture of glasses, materials (raw materials) from various parts of Greece and Egypt were analyzed (salt from Picrolimni, from Wadi Natron, LaBeida and El Mallaha Egypt, cherts or birbirite (Triadi), various sands from Pikrolimni, Galliko, Aliakmona river, from Agathoupolis, Pydna, Ancient Millets, Antikythera, Egypt, La Beida and El Mallaha lake, Egypt), as well as remains of glass moils taken from ancient kilns and compared with earlier analyzes. The detection of different raw materials indicated a different production technology and/or origin, namely salts from Lake Picrolimni and ash from plants (Salsola Kali). The isotopic data for the Belus and Campanian sands , the types mentioned by Pliny for the production of glass, show that they have a similar composition to each other, as well as to the sands of the Greek area. This isotopic similarity between the sands prevents us from identifying the starting material (sand) from the δ18O of the final product. Plant ash glass samples were also manufactured and analyzed. Their isotopic analysis ranges from 12.5‰ to 16.5‰. The results showed that when plant ash is used as a flux, it is difficult to distinguish between soda ash and plant ash because the addition of plant ash did not contribute isotopically heavy oxygen. Elemental analysis and the use of other isotopes led us to identify the raw materials in the final product. Lastly, the isotopic data, δ18O, of natron from Picrolimni were compared (1988, 2001, 2017 and 2021) with those of Wadi Natron. Unfortunately the isotopical values similarities was a draw back, but did not prevent us from identifying the raw materials used in the production of the final product.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Year dc:date
2023

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Karalis, Petros
  • Κάραλης, Πέτρος

Subjects

dc:subject × 19

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/55617

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Karalis, Petros; Κάραλης, Πέτρος. Ισοτοπική ιχνηλασιμότητα των πρώτων υλών της αρχαίας υάλου. National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, 2023. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/55617