Abstract
dc:descriptionSelectivity is the most important parameter of fishing gears and one of the main objectives of fishing gear technology. Knowledge of selectivity is crucial for the sustainable management of fisheries, particularly in the Mediterranean Sea where most fisheries are controlled by effort limitations and technical measures such as the minimum legal mesh size (MMS) and the minimum conservation reference size of exploited organisms (MCRS). The selectivity of gillnets and trammel nets, the most important fishing gears of small-scale coastal fisheries in Greece, is the subject of this thesis, which aims to contribute to the enhancement of existing knowledge and the investigation and formulation of proposals that will contribute to the sustainable exploitation of fisheries resources. The study area was the northern Aegean Sea, one of the most important fishing grounds of the eastern Mediterranean Sea. Over a period from April 2016 to February 2017, four seasonal samplings were conducted, each lasting five consecutive days. Ten different mesh sizes ranging from 16 to 70 mm (bar length) were examined, which were the same for both fishing gears. Considering that the selectivity is closely linked to morphometric and biometric characteristics of fish, our investigation aimed to assess whether gillnet and trammel net selectivity introduce bias in the length-weight relationship (LWR) of fish. We calculated the LWR for 31 species (28 fish species, 2 crustaceans and 1 cephalopod) from 21 families. With the exception of brown comber Serranus hepatus and rough ray Raja radula, all LWR slopes fell within the range of 2.5 to 3.5. The median value for fish species was determined to be 3.11, with 50% of the b-values ranging from 3.04 to 3.24. Somatic growth patterns were found to be isometric in 14 species, hyperallometric in 12 species, while only 5 species grew hypoallometrically. The selectivity experiments clearly showed that the different mesh sizes catch quite different length ranges, with slight overlap in gill nets and greater overlap in trammel nets. Thus, the selectivity of gillnets and trammel nets significantly impacts the LWR estimation, and the data obtained from these fishing gears can be used for determining LWR only if the widest possible range of mesh sizes is used. This condition was fulfilled in the present work ensuring the validity of the estimated LWR results. The knowledge of morphological relationships and particularly of those concerning fish body girth (G) and total length (TL) is necessary in gear selectivity. Total length-body girth relationships (LGR) are used as a mean to assess fishing gear selectivity since length-based selectivity models are only valid when a linear relationship between fish girth and fish length is established. The LGR was estimated for 24 marine species exploited by the small-scale coastal fleet in the northern Aegean Sea. For 6 species the TL-G relationships were estimated for the first time in the Mediterranean Sea and the adjacent seas. The coefficients of linear regression of body girth in three body positions, (Geye, posterior to the eye; Ghead at the posterior end of the operculum; Gmax at the maximum body depth), with the total length were estimated for each species, as well as for the groups formatted when Geye, Ghead and Gmax were plotted against total length for all the species combined. Statistical analysis (ANCOVA, P<0.001) revealed significant differences among the groups formed, mainly according to their body shape, in the slopes (b) of the general total length-body girth relationships for each girth type (Geye, Ghead Gmax). For 18 species of the present study, for which the relationships between total length and body girth had been calculated in previous studies in different geographic areas of the Mediterranean and adjacent seas, the slopes (b) were compared with the Z-test, which revealed statistically significant differences, especially from the results of studies along the Portuguese coasts. Using the resulted equations, the maximum girth (Gmax) corresponding to the Minimum Conservation Reference Size (MCRS) and to the total length at maturity (Lm) were calculated for each species. Identified mesh sizes respective to Gmax values were quite larger of the minimum legal mesh size for gillnets and the inner sheet of trammel nets (10 mm, bar length), indicating that the relevant current fisheries regulations cannot meet the requirements for a sustainable exploitation of fisheries resources. The size selectivity of trammel nets was investigated for the eight most abundant target and bycatch fish species, namely black scorpionfish Scorpaena porcus, annular seabream Diplodus annularis, red mullet Mullus barbatus, surmullet Mullus surmuletus, round sardinella Sardinella aurita, European hake Merluccius merluccius, greater weever Trachinus draco and blotched picarel Spicara flexuosum. These species collectively represented 51.5% by number and 42.7% by weight of the fishes caught with trammel nets in the sea trials. The SELECT method was used to estimate the selectivity parameters. Five different selectivity functions (i.e., Normal scale, Normal location, Gamma, Log-normal, and Bi-normal) were applied with the Bi-normal function providing the best fit as it had the lowest deviance value for all species and the lowest values for the dispersion parameter (D/df). The mesh size of 16 mm was found to retain specimens below the size at first maturity for most of the species. For red mullet, surmullet, and blotched picarel, a mesh size of 19 mm appeared more appropriate. Round sardinella and annular seabream seemed to require a mesh size of 22 mm, while for annular seabream in particular, a mesh size of 26 mm was considered even more suitable. European hake and black scorpionfish, on the other hand, required a mesh size larger than 26 mm for effective selectivity. The size selectivity of gillnets was studied for the same eight fish species. The catch of the species was lower in both abundance and biomass compared to trammel nets. The length distributions per mesh size were relatively narrow and there was only slight overlap between adjacent mesh sizes in most cases except for European hake, greater weever and black scorpionfish. To analyse the data, four unimodal functions and one bimodal function (Bi-normal) were fitted. The Bi-normal function provided the best fit for black scorpionfish, red mullet, surmullet, European hake, greater weever and blotched picarel, while the normal location function provided the best fit for annular seabream and round sardinella. For most species the mesh size of 16 mm retained specimens below the size at first maturity, but the proportion varied. In the case of annular sea bream, the 16 mm mesh size also retained specimens below the minimum conservation reference size. For the sustainable exploitation of stocks, mesh size of 19 mm considered more efficient for blotched picarel and round sardinella, a mesh size of 19 mm would be suitable but of 22 mm even more for red mullet and surmullet. For greater weever mesh sizes from 22 mm to 26 mm considered appropriate, mesh size 26 mm is also appropriate for annular sea bream while mesh sizes larger than 26 mm would be more appropriate for European hake and black scorpionfish. The impact of selectivity on the damage of nets by marine mammals was assessed by documenting the extent of damage at the end of all sampling periods. Data analyses were conducted on the entire dataset as well as a subset specifically comprising large holes and tears, which were attributed to bottlenose dolphin Tursiops truncatus. Findings demonstrated that the sequence in which nets were deployed had no noticeable effect on the accumulation of holes per net, implying that data from studies investigating net selectivity can be used to evaluate the accumulation of damage resulting from fish predation by nets. The absence of a significant trend in the build-up of large holes and tears with depth suggests that depth alone may not be a contributing factor in dolphin interactions with the net. Nets with large mesh sizes exhibited the least overall damage regardless of fishing depth, while nets with small and medium mesh sizes deployed in shallow and intermediate depths suffered the most severe damage. Nets with small to medium mesh sizes employed in deeper waters experienced intermediate levels of damage. These observations suggest that mesh size could potentially determine the frequency of dolphin depredation and resulting damage on set nets. In conclusion, gillnet and trammel net selectivity is a useful management tool, however, in order to effectively utilize the results of selectivity studies in fisheries management and link them to technical measures, it is necessary to establish a correlation between the technical measures taken (minimum mesh size of nets, minimum conservation reference size) and key population parameters (length of first maturity). Therefore, legislation on mesh size of nets should be based at least on the minimum conservation reference size, which should be determined based on the length of first maturity of the species. In this manner, the scientific validity and applicability of such management techniques can be improved.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Adamidou, Angeliki
- Αδαμίδου, Αγγελική
Subjects
dc:subject × 26- Απλάδια δίχτυα
- Επιλεκτικότητα
- Μανωμένα δίχτυα
- Μικρή παράκτια αλιεία
- Αλιευτική διαχείριση
- Σχέση μήκους-βάρους
- Σχέση μήκους-περιμέτρου σώματος
- Net selectivity
- Gillnets
- Trammel nets
- Small scale fishery
- Fisheries management
- Lengths and length-weight relationships
- Length-girth relationship
- Βιολογία
- Φυσικές Επιστήμες
- Θαλάσσια βιολογία και Βιολογία γλυκών υδάτων
- Γεωπονία, Δασολογία και Αλιεία
- Γεωπονικές Επιστήμες και Κτηνιατρική
- Αλιεία
- Biological Sciences
- Natural Sciences
- Marine and Freshwater Biology
- Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries
- Agricultural and Veterinary Sciences
- Fisheries
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/55693