Πανεπιστήμιο Μακεδονίας
Implementing new public management reforms in Greece: benchmarking for best practices in the public sector
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe aim of this research is to enhance the methodology of public sector benchmarking (BMK) by incorporating critical realism meta-theory. The primary assertion supporting this thesis is that the adoption of a critical realist perspective can address the limitations inherent in traditional approaches, which rely on predefined criteria for both quantitative and qualitative measurements, when assessing the impact of benchmarking on organizational performance (OP). Consequently, this research seeks to shed light on benchmarking-mediated performance change — a subject that remains a focal point of considerable debate in the literature and yet represents a significant gap in its exploration. The research focuses on a comparative analysis between two key aspects: a) traditional methodological approaches to public sector benchmarking and the results they claim to yield in terms of organizational performance, and b) the critical realist approach to benchmarking (BMK) and its impact on organizational performance (OP). Traditional approaches have thus far exhibited limited recognition of the impact of benchmarking on organizational performance, primarily concentrating on measurement and the achievement of predetermined goals. Simultaneously, these approaches have constrained the explanatory dynamics and broader understanding advocated by the inherent nature of the BMK methodology itself. In contrast, critical realism broadens the perspective on the outcomes of BMK activities on OP while also acknowledging the significance of explanation and understanding of these results. Consequently, the analysis presented contributes to the identification of the shortcomings of traditional methodologies and the appreciation of the value of critical realism principles within the BMK methodology. Causality, generalization, and explanation, as viewed through the lens of critical realism, emphasize methodological pluralism within benchmarking (BMK). This approach offers the potential to provide extended results, which encompass explanations derived from empirical research data. Primarily, this approach facilitates an understanding of BMK’s impact on organizational performance (OP). As an illustrative example, the implementation of best practice BMK for performance management in the Greek public sector during the New Public Management reform period is examined. This analysis aims to explore the common effects of best practice on the performance of public organizations, based on user experiences, and to propose an alternative explanation for these effects. This alternative explanation is rooted in the formulation of plausible inferences (abduction) and an exploration of the structures and generative mechanisms responsible for these effects (retroduction). In this manner, the dynamic interplay between various BMK methods is highlighted, providing the capacity to yield extended BMK results in OP and shed light on the generative mechanisms within the benchmarked practice development process. More specifically, the case study contributes to the development of a theoretical framework that explains why and how informal benchmarking (BMK) occurs. It emphasizes that the measurements of benchmarked practices (best practices) are merely a contingent element in the evolution of organizational performance and quality, depending on current conditions. Additionally, it was observed that the benefits of informal inter-organizational benchmarking, based on inter-organizational interaction, trigger a process of informal discovery that facilitates the standardization of processes within the organization. Similarly, the benefits of informal intra-organizational benchmarking promote the informal creation of innovative practices, leading to informal excellence. With the informal discovery of standardized organizational practices and the informal creation of innovative organizational practices, new extended results, such as changes in behavior, roles, and relationships, emerge, along with new types of benchmarkers. These developments disrupt the reproduction of organizational performance and allow for the pluralistic methodological emergence of benchmarked practices that impact the transformation of organizational performance.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Πανεπιστήμιο Μακεδονίας
- Year dc:date
- 2024
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Kessopoulou, Eftychia
- Κεσσοπούλου, Ευτυχία
Subjects
dc:subject × 12Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/55775