University of Patras
Taxonomy, biodiversity and evolution of fossil chelonians from the late miocene locality of Höwenegg (South Germany)
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe influence of climate fluctuations and geotectonic shifts during the Late Cenozoic era in the Western Palearctic region underscores the significance of ectothermic reptiles, such as chelonians, in serving as indicators of environmental changes. Chelonians are renowned for their exceptional fossil record, as they provide a valuable perspective on the climatic and environmental changes and which have played a significant role in shaping their evolution and diversity in Europe, particularly from the Tertiary period to the present day. The study of European chelonians has made substantial contributions to our comprehension of chelonians diversity throughout history, marked by numerous research initiatives and doctoral theses. Nevertheless, unanswered queries concerning fossil chelonians in Northern and Central Europe persist, as well as a pronounced disparity between the number of existing and extinct chelonian species, both within Europe and on a global scale as well. Specifically, it is evident that climate change has affected the reptilian fauna in Europe and has left its mark on the chelonian populations, even though the exact magnitude of this impact remains uncertain. There is an observable reduction in the diversity of freshwater turtle species, along with a transition from pleurodiran to cryptodiran turtles, suggesting that cryptodires possessed superior adaptations to colder conditions. Numerous chelonians, including tortoises and freshwater turtles, were impacted by climatic fluctuations that occurred in the Western Palearctic during the Neogene period. As a result, some of these species went extinct, such as Chelydropsis, while others experienced a reduction in their diversity. Höwenegg stands out as a remarkable fossil site, yielding a wide range of fossils, including vertebrates and invertebrates. The Höwenegg is located 2.5 km south of the town of Immendingen and consists of the most northern volcano complex of the Southwest German Hegau Volcanic area. Excavations at this site occurred over several decades, from 1950 to 2013, although they became intermittent over the years. Among the notable fossils unearthed at Höwenegg are chelonians, encompassing both tortoises and freshwater turtles. Most of these specimens were found in suboptimal preservation states, often due to taphonomic changes. The primary goal of this doctoral thesis was to enhance our understanding of Neogene turtle diversity in Germany and Central Europe through the analysis of fossil material from the Höwenegg region. More specifically, the main objectives of the doctoral thesis were: to conduct a detailed paleontological study of the skeletal material of chelonians from the fossiliferous area; the estimation of the number of taxa resulting from the material of both tortoises and aquatic turtles and their identification; the determination of any new extinct terrestrial or aquatic taxoon of chelonians derived from the material under study; the contribution of the study of the material to the general knowledge of the classification and evolution of the Neogene chelonian fauna in Germany; the assessment of the biodiversity of the site. Hence, a thorough analysis of the chelonian specimens was conducted. The material underwent comprehensive macroscopic examination, and a systematic classification approach was employed to categorize and describe the different taxa present in the material. Subsequently, for certain taxa, a phylogenetic analysis was undertaken to precisely determine their phylogenetic position and their links with other taxa. Based on the findings, it became evident that there was a minimum of four distinct taxa, comprising one tortoise and three freshwater turtles. Phylogenetic analyses were employed on the tortoise material to determine if it was either a large Testudinini or a small Geochelonini member. Additionally, for the freshwater genus Chelydropsis, the analysis aimed to ascertain whether it represented another member of Chelydropsis murchisoni, which was prevalent in Germany during this period, or if it was a distinct species. The phylogenetic analyses revealed that the terrestrial taxon seems to align with the large Testudinins. In most of the generated phylogenetic trees, it occupied an intermediate position within the Testudinini. However, it does not seem to be a member of the Testudo genus, which is characterised by tortoises with a hinge. Furthermore, the taxon was closely associated with Chersine hermanni, forming an exclusive clade with it. Comparative analysis was carried out with other terrestrial chelonians, encompassing both geochelonins and members of the testudinins group. Based on all the results, there is a tentative suggestion that this taxon may represent a new species closely related to the hermanni group, though this inference is made with some reservations due to the relatively low statistical support in the phylogenetic analyses. Regarding the Chelydropsis, it included the best-preserved and most complete specimen in the material, a nearly fully intact skeleton. Furthermore, the analysis and comparisons with other Chelydropsis species revealed that this taxon appears to be a distinct species, distinct from Chelydropsis murchisoni, and exhibits certain similarities with earlier Chelydropsis species, such as Chelydropsis decheni or Chelydropsis aubasi. Based on our analyses, the conclusions suggest that this taxon likely consists of a new species. Additionally, two other freshwater taxa were identified within the material. The first taxon belonged to Geoemydidae, based on the analysis of certain shell fragments. The second freshwater taxon was categorised as a member of Trionychinae.The study identified a total of four different taxa in the studied locality, including three freshwater turtles and one tortoise. To assess the site's biodiversity, a comparative analysis was conducted by examining Late Miocene fossil-rich sites, primarily in Germany, and expanding the study to a broader European context as well. Data from the Paleobiology Database were utilized, with a specific focus on the Tortonian, which encompasses MN9. Comparisons with other localities indicate that Höwenegg stands out as a site with notably high biodiversity, not only on a national scale but also within a broader European context. This study underscores the need for a comprehensive reevaluation of the chelonian material from previously examined sites. Many species names used in these sites have become obsolete, and there have been inaccuracies in past taxonomic assignments. Historically, smaller aquatic turtles were commonly classified as emydids, while larger terrestrial ones were often categorized as “Cheirogaster” or Geochelone. A similar situation occurred in Höwenegg, where part of the terrestrial material had been attributed to geochelonin (Cheirogaster back then member of geochelonins) and the pond turtle material was attributed to emydids. However, this research has revealed that the large terrestrial taxon is actually a member of the testudinins not geochelonins, while the pond turtle is attributed to Geoemydids, and not to Emydids.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Patras
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Pappa, Irena
- Παππά, Ιρένα
Subjects
dc:subject × 14Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/55797