University of Western Macedonia
Ιστορικά μοντέλα για το γονίδιο και τη γονιδιακή λειτουργία στις αντιλήψεις μαθητριών/τών και εκπαιδευτικών της δευτεροβάθμιας εκπαίδευσης
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe importance of genetic literacy, as an aspect of scientific literacy, is widely documented in numerous studies, while the integration of genetics into in secondary and higher education curricula internationally emphasizes genetics’ central position in science education. Studies highlighting students' perceptions, however, indicate significant difficulties in students’ understanding of genetics, show conceptual confusion, and an inability to understand complex genetic phenomena and processes at different organizational levels, such as the molecular, cellular, and phenomenological (phenotypic) levels. The inherent conceptual variation in genetics’ terminology such as that of 'gene' or 'gene function', having received historically different interpretations and explanations, further complicates its teaching. In addition, during the educational process, teachers face learners’ alternative perceptions, often cultivated through mass media, family environment or other informal forms of education, which often present an obstacle. The investigation of students' perceptions of genetics is widespread in international educational research compared to Greek data. At the same time, research on teachers' perceptions of genetics is quite restricted both internationally and for the Greek population. Despite the broad interest, researchers focus their studies mainly on detecting alternative perceptions and misconceptions, the assessment of genetic determinism, the understanding of genetics’ concepts in relation to a specific aspect of gene function, therefore not tackling the entirety of the parts which constitute the gene function. The present dissertation examines students’ and teachers’ perceptions regarding the gene and gene function, focusing on the conceptual variation of these concepts historically, while matching features from five multiple historical models, the Mendelian, classical, biochemical-classical, neoclassical, and modern models and their individual epistemological characteristics. Considering these models, a qualitative systematic review of the literature examining students' and teachers' perceptions of genetics internationally is conducted. A total of 38 scientific publications and 11 scientific articles concerning students' and teachers' perceptions respectively were analysed, and then classified into the historical models according to the detected epistemological features in the studies. At the main research study 18 12th Grade students and 25 Biology teachers participated, following the theoretical sampling method where the enrichment of the data allows their parallel analysis during the research. The research instrument chosen was the semi-structured interview, while content analysis guided by theory and epistemological model features provided the theoretical framework for analysis. The results of the qualitative systematic review of the literature show that there are two concepts of the gene in students’ and teachers’ perceptions of the gene-function relationship, the Mendelian one where the gene is considered as an abstract concept, and the neoclassical where it is defined as an information carrier and/or a DNA segment. Furthermore, while students seem to be unable to link different organisational levels of gene function, as they often did not include a protein as a mediator when describing the genotype-phenotype relationship (classical model). As studies focusing on teachers’ perception of genetics were scarce, only weak generalisations were able to be made. Regarding Greek students, the biochemical-classical model was dominant at their perceptions, as a hybridization of classical and neoclassical models’ characteristics. Similar results have been found in international studies, but also in relation to Greek textbooks, where the same model prevailed. Moreover, the neoclassical model was found more frequently in the perceptions of Greek teachers, which is in line with international studies involving biologists holding PhDs in Molecular Biology, Genetics, and related disciplines of Biology. The results of the present study present a detailed view of students' and teachers' perceptions of the gene and its function, constituting a first simultaneous assessment of genetics in this context in the Greek student and teacher population. Furthermore, the findings of the study can provide a basis for teaching materials’ creation in genetics, from the perspective of the history of science and the changing scientific knowledge, portrayed through the conceptual variation shown through the five historical genetic models.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Western Macedonia
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Tsopoglou-Gkina, Despoina
- Τσόπογλου-Γκίνα, Δέσποινα
Subjects
dc:subject × 15- Ιστορικά γονιδιακά μοντέλα
- Αντιλήψεις μαθητών
- Αντιλήψεις εκπαιδευτικών
- Δευτεροβάθμιμα
- Gene historical models
- Students' conceptions
- Teachers' conceptions
- Εκπαίδευση
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Εκπαίδευση και Έρευνα της εκπαίδευσης
- Διδασκαλία και κατάρτιση
- Education
- Social Sciences
- Education and Educational Research
- Teaching and Training
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/55814