University of the Aegean
Δημιουργία και αξιολόγηση λογισμικού πλήρως εμβυθιστικής εικονικής πραγματικότητας για τη μουσειακή εκπαίδευση στην αρχαία ελληνική τεχνολογία
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe groundbreaking technological changes taking place today affect almost every aspect of social and individual life. One of the cutting-edge technologies is Virtual Reality (VR). VR is a set of hardware and software technologies aimed at immersing the user in the Virtual Environment. At the same time, in recent years there has been an increasing interest in ancient Greek technology. This thesis aims to create an Immersive Virtual Reality (IVR) software and evaluate it, based on its learning performance and its performance on user experience factors. Thus, an IVR software was created, which included eight ancient Greek inventions. In addition to the IVR software, Desktop Virtual Reality (DVR) software was also created, so that the evaluation of the IVR software could also be done in comparison with the DVR software. DVR is the type of VR that uses conventional means of interface (mouse, keyboard, screen). For the same reason, websites were also created. The creation of the media initially required the study of ancient technology. This is how technology was studied from prehistoric times in the Aegean area up to Byzantine times. Of particular interest are - among other inventions - the Antikythera Mechanism, the inventions of Archimedes, automatic mechanisms and water pumping mechanisms. Special softwares were used to create the softwares. Blender software was used to create the 3D models of the inventions. Unity, a computer game development software, was also used. For Unity to work, script writing in C# language is required. The software in which the scripts were written was Visual Studio Code. The IVR software execution platform was the Oculus Quest system. Regarding the creation of educational software, only two IVR software were identified for ancient Greek technology, and they use the Oculus Rift as an execution platform. These are two impressive softwares that are the works of a team of IT scientists. The first concerns a virtual museum of fragments of the Antikythera mechanism. The second software is «Palace of Agai». Literature review was performed based on the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) chart. Initially, 3,145 articles were collected. After the removal of duplicates, irrelevant and other justifiably excluded the final corpus of 29 articles of the analysis was formed. Of the studies that were characterized as reliable (n = 4), a generally positive cognitive effect of IVR was revealed and additionally a positive effect on the factor’s presence/immersion, ease of use, graphics, enjoyment. In addition, an effect of IVR on the creation of simulator sickness was also detected, mostly using the joystick movement method. The following inventions were created for the IVR software: The aeolosphere, the flamethrower, the frictories and the automation of the temple gates.In the aelosphere, the user would grab a torch and set fire to the wood at the base of the machine. As the flame developed, steam began to escape from the engine's exhausts, and it began to spin. After a period, the fire began to weaken until it went out. The engine continued to spin with ever decreasing steam until it stopped. In the Boeotian flamethrower, the user could grab the lever, move it down and fire the flamethrower. In the phriktories, the user could, by changing the position of the torches on the walls, emit a different letter, based on the model. In the temple door automation, the user would set fire to the temple altar, and through a mechanism in the temple basement, the doors would open automatically. As soon as the fire was extinguished the doors were closed again. The above inventions were accompanied by informative text, corresponding to the signs found in museum exhibits. Additionally, the user had the ability to enable narration, which was accompanied by images. The informational elements of the inventions concerned the historical context, the use, and the principle of operation of each invention. Also, benches were created with the mechanical parts of the inventions on display. Each place was accompanied by a sign with its name. The user was able to grasp and pick up the exposed mechanical parts. Four additional ancient Greek inventions were created for the DVR software: the floating sphere, the steam cannon, the hydraulic telegraph, and the automatic fountain. In the floating sphere, the user clicking on the machine saw a fire start. Then steam would come out and the hollow sphere would float. As soon as the fire was extinguished, the steam continued to escape for some time diminishing, and then the sphere returned to its original position. On the steam cannon the user clicked on the cannon, saw the boiler valve turn, an explosion occurs and the stone ball was launched, dragging the retaining stick and breaking the retaining board. In the hydraulic telegraph, the user clicking on the invention saw the valve of the telegraph open and water flow out. At the same time, the receiver device was displayed in front of him, with transparencies so that its inner workings could be seen. The floats would lower until the user clicked again and specified the message. In the automatic coin-operated liberator, the user clicked on the liberator and watched the coin fall into the liberator, deflect the balance mechanism, and flow sanctification into the cup. The same information elements (signs and narrative with pictures) were developed in the DVR, as in the IVR. In the DVR, however, as expected, the user could not grasp and explore the exposed mechanical parts. In addition to the two software, websites were also developed for ancient Greek technology. The web pages were made using the Google Sites application and included the following inventions: the flying pigeon, the catapult machine gun, the cryptographic disk, and the audible alarm. They included informative texts, images, and videos. The research questions of the thesis are the following: Will the use of IVR applications lead to better learning outcomes compared to the use of DVR applications and websites, which have similar content? Do users find that IVR apps provide a better learning experience compared to DVR apps and websites that have similar content? Does learning experience shape cognitive outcomes in IVR applications? The within subjects’ methodology was chosen for the main research. The sample of the main research consisted of 103 young adults, students of the Pedagogical Department of Elementary Education of the University of the Aegean. Two tools were used: a knowledge assessment test and a questionnaire of Virtual Reality factors. The results of the data analysis led to the general conclusion that the learning effects of the three media were «relatively» equivalent. There was a statistically significant difference in favor of IVR compared to websites, but it could be characterized as marginal (p = 0.04). Also, between IVR and DVR, no statistically significant difference emerged (p = 0.592), as well as between EEP and websites (p = 0.709).Out of the total of 13 factors, in seven the IVR prevails in both compared means (aesthetic/technical perfection, immersion, presence, interaction, motives of use, simulator sickness mild symptoms, positive emotions), while in two it prevails only over websites (ease of use/control, feedback). The effect of all the above factors has a positive contribution to the overall user experience, except for the simulator sickness factor. Also, no difference of the three means was detected in the effect of four factors (cognitive load, subjective efficacy, simulator sickness severe symptoms, negative emotions).The following six factors had a statistically significant effect on learning outcomes: aesthetic/technical perfection (p = 0.007), immersion (p = 0.004), presence (p = 0.005), motivation to use (p = 0.020), subjective effectiveness (p = 0.007) and positive emotions (p = 0.020). All the aforementioned factors had a positive impact on learning outcomes. Also, a positive fact is that producing simulator sickness-mild symptoms had no effect on the learning results.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of the Aegean
- Year dc:date
- 2024
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Antonopoulos, Panagiotis
- Αντωνόπουλος, Παναγιώτης
Subjects
dc:subject × 12- Αρχαία ελληνική τεχνολογία
- Εικονική πραγματικότητα
- Μουσειακή εκπαίδευση
- Ancient Greek technology
- Virtual reality (VR)
- Museum education
- Άλλες Ανθρωπιστικές Επιστήμες
- Ανθρωπιστικές Επιστήμες και Τέχνες
- Ανθρωπιστικές επιστήμες, άλλοι τομείς
- Other Humanities
- Humanities and the Arts
- Humanities, miscellaneous
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/55849