Back to search

National and Kapodistrian University of Athens

Μεθοδολογικές προσεγγίσεις και ο ρόλος του πειράματος στο έργο του Lord Rayleigh

Abstract

dc:description

Lord Rayleigh (1842-1919) was a British physicist who, for about fifty years, dealt with a wide range of classical physics as it was formed in his time, publishing more than 440 scientific articles. In addition to his research, Rayleigh held high-ranking administrative positions in several foundations and institutions during this long period. He was the second director of the Cavendish Laboratory, and, later, his contribution to the establishment of the National Physical Laboratory(NPL) was vital. He also served as president of the Royal Society and the British Association for the Advancement of Science; however, a large part of Rayleigh’s experiments were carried out in his private laboratory at Terling Place. This was a period of transition for the experiment, which moved from the private space of affluent experimenters to the public spaces of research centers and universities. Experimentation was an integral element in Rayleigh’s investigations, and precise measurements are at the heart of his experimental practice. Nevertheless, what constitutes accuracy in Rayleigh’s measurements is a complex issue. Measurement is an activity, while accuracy, besides being a criterion of measurement reliability, is also a characteristic linked to a process of corrections, processing, and discussion of data, which is part of the broader cognitive and social context. In this sense, even in the “technical core” of measurements, there are historical, social, and cultural dimensions. Therefore, even in measurements, there are alternative scientific practices, and there may be different personal styles of scientists. After the introductory chapter, where the topic and research questions of the dissertation are raised, the second chapter presents some historiographical and methodological elements concerning measurement and accuracy in the history and philosophy of science. A brief reference is also made to research schools and scientific styles. Then, the next chapter provides a few brief details from Rayleigh’s biography. It attempts a rough sketch of his social and scientific profile, focusing on the aristocratic circle he belonged to, the common values and beliefs he shared with the members of that circle, and the key features of his scientific work. The dissertation is then divided into two parts. The first part consists of four chapters. The first of these, which is the fourth chapter of the dissertation overall, examines the physics laboratories that appeared in the last third of the nineteenth century; more specifically, the study focuses on British and American laboratories. The place of accuracy and precise measurements is the central issue addressed in this chapter. In the fifth chapter, attention is turned to the Cavendish Laboratory and the characteristics it acquired as a center of research and teaching during Rayleigh’s directorship. A key question addressed in this chapter is whether or not there was a research faculty in the laboratory during Rayleigh’s term as director, as well as the role of precise measurements in the laboratory during the same period. In the next chapter, the meaning of the terms “accuracy” and “precision” as well as the distinction between these two concepts are traced through experimental physics textbooks, while in the seventh chapter a corresponding analysis is attempted in order to deal with random and systematic errors in the experimental practice of physicists in the last third of the nineteenth century. The second part of the thesis focuses on two research projects, in the context of which Rayleigh conducted his own investigations: the determination of electrical standards and the determination of the densities of hydrogen, oxygen, and nitrogen, as well as the discovery of Argus. These programmes are chosen for four main reasons. First, these are two central investigations conducted by Rayleigh, as can be seen from the periodization of his scientific work given by his colleague, A. Schuster. Second, it is these investigations from which he gained his reputation as an experimenter, especially in regard to his precise measurements. Third, both of them had accuracy as their key aspect; the first programme was in the context of standardizing a unit, while the second was part of Prout’s hypothesis testing, which in turn required exact measurements. Finally, both programmes had an international character, and this helped the comparative study of the scientists’ experimental practices. The eighth and ninth chapters deal specifically with the determination of the standard and the unit of electrical resistance, and the tenth concerns the densities of hydrogen and oxygen. The eleventh focuses on research concerning the density of nitrogen and the “discovery” of argon. What emerges from this study is that Rayleigh had a personal style with which he approached measurements, accuracy, and errors in his experimental practice. Rayleigh’s style, which is thoroughly analyzed in this dissertation, was not commonplace for physicists or chemists of his time. Different laboratories and scientists approached accuracy in practice differently, at the level of both teaching and research, while even the concept of accuracy itself varied across space and time. Finally, it is argued that even among British physicists, there was variation in the approach to measurement, accuracy, and error analysis. Thus, there was no national style on this issue. Further, the comparative study of Rayleigh’s approach with that of the American “academic engineers,” this hybrid type of physicist-engineer, can shed more light on the dimensions of measurement and precision. Rayleigh and “academic engineers” put precision at the center of their experimental practice. However, they did not approach errors and precision in the same way, particularly with regard to random errors, the method of least squares, and the calculation of probable error. The professionalization of physics and its different paths, as well as its relationships with industry and/or astronomy have been crucial in shaping approaches to measurement, accuracy and error.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Year dc:date
2023

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Christopoulou, Vasiliki-Christine
  • Χριστοπούλου, Βασιλική-Κριστίν

Subjects

dc:subject × 18

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/55885

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Christopoulou, Vasiliki-Christine; Χριστοπούλου, Βασιλική-Κριστίν. Μεθοδολογικές προσεγγίσεις και ο ρόλος του πειράματος στο έργο του Lord Rayleigh. National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, 2023. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/55885