Institutes outside Greece
An empirical study of the desirability and usability of model-based scenarios for informing energy and low-carbon transitions
Abstract
dc:descriptionMany energy and low-carbon transitions are underway around the World today, guided by strategies such as the Swiss Energy Strategy 2050, the European Green Deal, and the Paris Agreement. A key method to inform transition strategies is scenario analysis. Scenarios can highlight uncertainties, explore alternatives, or show how to reach specific targets. For energy and climate change mitigation topics, the story-and-simulation approach is usually followed, where scenario developers define storylines which are then quantified using modeling. Research has so far focused on improving models themselves, as well as the diversity and consistency of the analyzed scenarios. Nevertheless, significant challenges remain such as enhancing the inclusivity of transition stakeholders in scenario generation and ensuring the usability of scenario results. Energy and low-carbon transitions involve diverse stakeholders, including policymakers, industries, NGOs, and the wider public. However, it has been shown that even large scenario ensembles from multiple models and modeling organizations may focus on a relatively narrow range of views about the future. As citizen perspectives have been rarely used in scenario generation, it remains unclear whether energy technologies and other alternatives that are frequently included in scenarios are also desirable by the citizens. Nevertheless, incorporating citizen perspectives in scenario generation carries its own challenges, since these perspectives can be influenced by knowledge gaps, prior beliefs, or even demographics. Similarly, user characteristics such as numeracy can affect the usability of scenario information, especially in the case of more complex visualizations of large scenario ensembles. While interactive visualizations have been seen as a solution to show large scenario ensembles, it is unclear whether interactive visualizations outperform their static counterparts to merit the extra investment. In response to these research gaps, this thesis aimed to empirically evaluate large scenario ensembles that inform energy and low-carbon transitions in terms of desirability and usability. On desirability, the thesis assessed the representation of citizen perspectives in scenario ensembles that inform energy transitions. On usability, the thesis assessed the performance of various interactive and static formats for visualizing large scenario ensembles in terms of supporting the understanding and engagement of transition stakeholders. Methodologically, all evaluations were structured in five research studies (journal articles). The studies were based on data collected from large population surveys and workshops and almost all of the studies used a newly developed interactive scenario tool Riskmeter, both for collecting data and for evaluating its performance in terms of scenario communication. In terms of case studies, the thesis focused on the electricity supply transition until 2035 in Switzerland, the European Union, and the World, as the electricity sector is especially crucial for decarbonizing the energy system and it is prioritized in most transition strategies. The thesis showed that existing multi-organization, multi-model scenario ensembles for the electricity supply in 2035 in France, Germany, Poland, Switzerland, and the European Union are only narrowly representative of citizen perspectives. Compared to most model-based scenarios, most citizens preferred deeper decarbonization and/or denuclearization by 2035, increased efficiency and electricity savings, and an electricity supply based on domestic hydropower, solar photovoltaic, wind power, and biomass. Scenario preference patterns were affected by the knowledge level and the national context of the citizens but remained mostly similar among groups of citizens with different demographics, political orientation, and attitudes on the transition and its governance. In contrast, scenario usability was affected by the prior beliefs, age, education, and relevant abilities of the scenario users such as numeracy. In fact, user understanding and engagement with scenario visualizations was more strongly influenced by user characteristics than by different visualization formats. Among the five static visualization formats that were tested, none was consistently outperforming the rest, while no evidence was found that an interactive format was superior to a static alternative. Nevertheless, customizing formats to user characteristics was shown to allow to control adverse effects from these user characteristics. The outcomes of the thesis underline the need to explicitly consider informed and diverse citizen perspectives in scenario generation in order to improve the desirability of scenarios that inform transitions. For the examined countries and the European Union, findings indicate that more scenarios are needed with an early and ambitious deployment of renewable electricity. In terms of scenario communication, results suggest that no visualization format is perfect and that formats should be customized according to the needs and characteristics of different audiences. In all cases, empirical evaluation is key to ensure that methods for scenario generation and communication perform as intended. Future research should focus on integrating iterative empirical evaluations in all design phases of scenario visualizations and on investigating how to achieve a better trade-off between eliciting scenario preferences at scale and assuring that stakeholders are properly informed beforehand.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutes outside Greece
- Year dc:date
- 2022
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Xexakis, Georgios
- Ξεξάκης, Γεώργιος
Subjects
dc:subject × 32- Ενεργειακά σενάρια
- Ηλεκτρική ενέργεια
- Μοντέλα ενεργειακών συστημάτων
- Μοντέλα ολοκληρωμένης αξιολόγησης
- Προτιμήσεις των πολιτών
- Συμμετοχικότητα
- Δημόσια αποδοχή
- Αξιολόγηση χρηστικότητας
- Οπτικοποίηση
- Αβεβαιότητα
- Energy scenarios
- Electricity
- Energy system models
- Integrated assessment models
- Citizen preferences
- Citizen engagement
- Public acceptance
- Usability evaluation
- Visualization
- Uncertainty
- Περιβαλλοντική Μηχανική
- Επιστήμες Μηχανικού και Τεχνολογία
- Ανανεώσιμη ενέργεια, Αειφορία και Περιβάλλον
- Οικονομικά και Επιχειρήσεις
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Επιστήμη λήψης αποφάσεων
- Environmental Engineering
- Engineering and Technology
- Renewable Energy, Sustainability and the Environment
- Economics and Business
- Social Sciences
- Decision Sciences
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/55971