Back to search

Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)

Tooth color alterations in orthodontically treated teeth and their clinical relevance to external tooth bleaching

Abstract

dc:description

INTRODUCTION: Consensus exists in the literature that people prefer attractive over unattractive faces. In literature, facial attractiveness and smile attractiveness appear strongly connected to each other. In social interaction one’s attention is mainly directed toward the eyes and mouth of the speaker. Several studies attempt to explain why a smile with dentition in harmony is considered beautiful. It has been suggested that an esthetically pleasing smile is dependent on components such as tooth position, size, shape, inclination, color, smile arc, gingival display as well as the framing of the lips. Results of studies regarding tooth aesthetics agree that tooth color is one of the most important factors in satisfaction with oral appearance. In literature, tooth color and visibility of gums correlated with satisfaction of the smile while white teeth and marginal gingival display corresponded with the authentic meaning of the smile expression as a friendly and non-aggressive signal to others. More recently, it was found that relatively minor changes in the lightness of tooth colour influenced the perceived social appeal (social, intellectual, psychological and relational abilities) of an unknown male and unknown female. A perceptible change in dental lightness was recognized as the strongest factor associated with the dental attractiveness stereotype, affecting significantly the 12 traits assessed, but mainly the Happiness, Social Relations and Academic Performance. Patients’ strive for a “Hollywood smile” has led to increase in the orthodontic demand along with a bleaching “phrenitis”. In a U.S. survey of private-practice members of the American Association of Orthodontists conducted in order to assess their current practices regarding tooth whitening, a high percentage of orthodontists (88.8%) had patients who requested tooth whitening and had recently recommended (76.2%) whitening procedures for some patients. Although there is an abundance of information in the literature regarding the risks and benefits of orthodontic treatment or bleaching alone, little information is available on the bleaching effect of orthodontically treated teeth. There are only four in-vitro studies in the literature that refer to the influence of the bonding/debonding procedure on the bleaching efficacy. Outcome reports on the response to bleaching of untreated and bonded/debonded are inconclusive to obtain a post-orthodontic bleaching protocol. With the lack of agreement, it is reasonable to conjecture that randomized clinical trials might provide evidence-based information to be the ground for clinical-decision making. The necessity of randomized clinical trials to further verify the findings of these studies has previously been supported. Therefore, it would be of great interest to clinically investigate the effect of cosmetic bleaching to orthodontically treated teeth and to compare the bleaching potential of bonded/debonded versus untreated teeth. AIM: The aim of this study was to explore whether the bonding/debonding procedures as part of a comprehensive orthodontic treatment alter the response to vital bleaching. The null hypothesis to be tested was that there were no significant differences in CIE color parameters L*, a* and b* of orthodontically and non-orthodontically treated teeth after vital bleaching. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Sample size calculation for this single-blind randomized control clinical trial was based on the formula by Brown and Prescott. Each tooth was considered a unit with minimum significant difference between mean ΔΕ values of at least 0.9 times and variance of ΔΕ with probability at least 80%, the alpha error probability was set to 0.05. Accordingly, the number of patients in each of the 6 GROUPS was N=11.1 Rounding up to an even number for randomization purposes, 12 was the number of subjects in each of the six GROUPS, overall N=72 subjects; 432 teeth; 2 repeated measurements; 6,048 captures in total. All patients invited to enroll in this study voluntarily consented to participate and were informed according to the ethical principles for medical research involving human subjects. The first group, DEBONDED, included 24 consecutively treated orthodontic patients, 14 females and 10 males with a mean age 24.8±13.4 years, who received comprehensive fixed appliances orthodontic treatment at the Postgraduate Orthodontic Clinic of Aristotle University of Thessaloniki and appliances were removed by the author. The second group included 24 consecutively treated orthodontic patients currently in RETENTION, 13 females and 11 males, with a mean age 21.9±5.9 years. The third group consisted of 24 arbitrarily selected fourth-year and fifth-year undergraduate dental students at Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, 14 females and 10 males with a mean age 21.9±0.7 years without a fixed appliances orthodontic treatment history. Each of the above three groups was further randomized into two sub-GROUPS each (BLEACHING and PLACEBO). Randomization of the participants was performed by the statistician and was communicated to the author of this thesis on the first day of intervention. Each subgroup received either a 38% hydrogen peroxide bleaching agent (Opalescence Xtra Boost 38%, Ultradent Products, South Jordan, UT, USA) according to manufacturer’s instructions or a placebo agent (saline solution). For all GROUPS, in order for a subject to be included in the study, strict inclusion/exclusion criteria had to be met. Teeth included in the study were the upper central incisors, upper lateral incisors and upper canines. One method was employed to assess tooth color, namely by means of a reflectance spectrophotometer, SpecroShadeTM Micro (MHT, Zürich, Switzerland; Software version; software version 2.20). A standardized protocol of tooth preparation and spectrophotometric evaluation was adopted for all patients. All spectrophotometric images were recorded by the author at seven time intervals. Data collection initiated one day before the BLEACHING/PLACEBO INTERVENTION with the first spectrophotometric color measurement. Additional measurements were made just before the application of the BLEACHING/PLACEBO agent (20min pre), just after (20min post) and 7, 14, 21 and 90 days later. Intra-rater agreement was estimated with the Intra-class Correlation Coefficient and method error was calculated using the repeatability coefficient. Regarding parameters L*, a* b* and ΔΕ an analysis of variance model was used to study differences between GROUPS. The effects of GROUP, INTERVENTION, TIME and their interactions were analyzed with another linear mixed model with the baseline measurement used as a covariate when significant differences were observed between GROUPS at baseline. Analyses of each of the foregoing parameters was rerun with a series of linear mixed models that included the confounders “DURATION of TREATMENT”, “ANGLE CLASSIFICATION”, “ORTHODONTIC TREATMENT PLAN“, “ANGLE CLASSIFICATION” and “MONTHS in RETENTION”, in order to study any effects of them in the results. The level of statistical significance was set up to 0.05.RESULTS For all BLEACHING subgroups (DEBONDED, RETENTION, CONTROL) comparisons between baseline and follow-up measurements revealed that values of all CIE color parameters at baseline were statistically significant different than values at almost all succeeding TIMEPOINTS. ΔΕ values in all BLEACHING subgroups were statistically significantly greater than ΔΕ values in the CONTROL subgroups. Bleaching statistically significantly increased the L*value and decreased the a* and b* values in both orthodontically bonded/debonded and control teeth. However, for the a* parameter in Teeth 12 and 21 bleaching failed to produce statistical significant differences for either orthodontically treated or control teeth. In addition, the L* parameter for Teeth 11 and 21 did not exhibit statistically significant differences in the BLEACHING-CONTROL subgroup at any of following timepoints contrary to the BLEACHING-DEBONDED and RETENTION subgroups were bleaching produced statistically significant differences throughout the 90 days of observation. Also L* parameter for Teeth 12 and 22 did not exhibit statistically significant differences in the BLEACHING-CONTROL subgroup at the end of the 3 month observation period contrary to the BLEACHING-DEBONDED and RETENTION subgroups were bleaching maintained its initial response. Thus, the null hypothesis for this study was partly rejected since the CIE color parameter L* exhibited overall statistically significant differences in comparisons between CONTROL and DEBONDED GROUPS and CONTROL and RETENTION GROUPS for Teeth 11, 21. Regarding confounders “DURATION OF TREATMENT(months)” for the RETENTION GROUP and “ANGLE CLASSIFICATION” for both GROUPS statistically significantly related to all color parameters in almost all teeth. CONCLUSIONS: The null hypothesis for this study was partly rejected for the CIE color parameter L* since it exhibited statistically significant differences in comparisons between BLEACHING-CONTROL and BLEACHING-DEBONDED subgroups and BLEACHING-CONTROL and BLEACHING-RETENTION subgroups for Teeth 11 and 21.In all BLEACHING subgroups, comparisons between baseline and follow-up measurements revealed statistically significant differences in all color parameters at almost all succeeding timepoints. Parameter L* for Teeth 11 and 21 did not exhibit statistically significant differences in the BLEACHING-CONTROL subgroup for any of the follow-up measurements in contrast to the BLEACHING-DEBONDED and BLEACHING-RETENTION subgroups thus indicating an increased effect of the bleaching agent on these orthodontically treated teeth.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
Year dc:date
2018

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Koumpia, Effimia
  • Κουμπιά, Ευφημία

Subjects

dc:subject × 14

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/56047

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Koumpia, Effimia; Κουμπιά, Ευφημία. Tooth color alterations in orthodontically treated teeth and their clinical relevance to external tooth bleaching. Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH), 2018. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/56047