Back to search

National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)

To κύκλιο ορχηστικό άσμα του Διθυράμβου τον 7 ο αι. π.Χ.: μυθολογική και αρμονική χωρική αντίληψη

Abstract

dc:description

The subject of this Thesis concerns the choral song ("κύκλιο ορχηστικό μέλος") of the Dithyramb during the 7th century B.C. as well as the Dithyramb's relationship with an early cult of Dionysus and the origin of drama. The Dithyramb is an improvised circular choral song that is believed to have been born in the early 7th century. The earliest mention of it was found in a fragment of Archilochus (circa 665 BC) who connected it with the cult of the god Dionysus and first presented it as a song in Paros, in which he sang as the leader of a group (Pickard - Cambridge (1962, σ.58). Based on the reports of Herodotus, the Dithyramb was the creation of the Arion of Corinth (circa 624 BC). He formed the first circle, adding a chorus of 50 men (κύκλιος χορός) in order in turns and reversals and separates in it the part of the chorus and the part of the "Exarchon", turning it into a literary form. Herodotus attributes to Arion the discovery, composition, and teaching of the Dithyramb, but his invention could also be understood as a renewal of the genre (Athanasaki 2009, p. 16). According to Aristotle (384 -322 B.C.), the earliest origins of drama come from the "Exarchons of Dithyramb" («Εξάρχοντες τον Διθύραμβον»), who according to common practice start the beginning of a song, or "παιάν" and the chorus answers or repeats the chant (επωδός).The "Eξάρχων" (auctor, soliste) is the forerunner of the actor who holds a dialogue or clashes with the chorus (αποκρίνεται - υποκρίνεται) (Aristotle Poetics IV 12).The Dithyramb was an epithet of Dionysus as well as the Hymn’s name in honor of him, otherwise called: "Bacchus", where the root of the name Bacchus, i.e.: "Iacchus" also indicates a voice («ιαχή»). Some believe that the surname "Dithyramb", attributed to Dionysus, is due to this double birth of the god - Dithyramb = dyo (two) + Thyra (door): from two doors («Διθυραμβογενής»): the one who was born twice, from his mother earth Semeli and the thigh of his father God Zeus («μηρογέννητος»). (Arist. Frogs 398), (Eur. Bacch. 1993, Commentaries, p. 212). Regarding the etymology of Dithyramb, Pindar writes the word “Lythiramvos” («Λυθίραμβος») which comes from the words: «λύθι» and «ράμμα» and means the cry which Dionysus uttered when he was sewn to his father’s thigh. The development of the study is based on the wider interpretation of the specific etymology. However, the term Dithyramb remains enigmatic. The purpose of the research is to examine the conditions of the harmonious development of Dithyramb in the early 7th century B.C., relating the circular orchestral chant ("κύκλιο ορχηστικό μέλος") both to the structural organization of self - created harmonic organic systems and to an early form of the harmonic musical scale, which also corresponds to circular time. The theoretical conception of Harmony is based on considerations of ancient Babylonian and Egyptian origin (Kilmer A. 1971/ M.L.West, 1994 / Effat et al, 1996), but also of Anaximandros (611-545B.C.), Pythagoras (580 – 496 B.C.), Pre - Socratic philosophers of the 6th century B.C. (Heraclitus, Empedocles), Aristoxenus Tarantinos (370-304 B.C.), or more recent views of Vitruvius (1st century B.C.), or M. Ghika (1881-1965), but also modern scientific theories. According to Vitruvius and Ghika, Harmony constitutes a preexisting system of proportionality of parts with the whole, as a symphonic composition ruled by a dynamic symmetry corresponding on space to musical eurythmy in time (Vitruvius I, 25 p. 51,95 /Ghyka,1977, ix).An additional objective of this paper is to demonstrate the mythological environment associated with the birth of the pre-philological Dithyramb, as existing evidence for Dithyramb - such as the life of Arion credited with inventing the dithyramb - moves in the space between History and Myth. The two goals that define the purpose of our research complement each other indicating the way to approach the investigation of Harmony. Firstly, we study the references of Dithyramb as a "Phrygian song" harmonized according to the "Phrygian Harmony" accompanied by flutes. We also investigate the mythological connection of Dithyramb with rituals of the orgiastic worship of the ancient Deity Mother Earth – Phrygian Cybele. The Great Earth Goddess who is the epicenter of all mysteries is connected with Nature, while vegetation is personified in the form of a "divine infant" born and dies like the seasonal rebirth. As it is speculated that the orgiastic cult of Phrygian Cybele was imported from Phrygia to Crete, we then investigate the correlation of Dithyramb with the cult of a vegetative "resurrected" Cretan-born Zeus (Κρηταγενής Δίας) (Zois, 1996, p.184).This particular god, who is a religious focal point of the Phrygian colonizers in Crete, is mythologically referred to, as: "Kronios Kouros" and coming at the head of his followers, curators, sons of Earth and Cronus («κουροτρόφοι»), as Leader Orchestrator (Απάρχων Ορχηστής), embodies the vegetative spirit of the time, the Demon "Eniautos" (Eνιαυτός). Transferring the figure of the god to the annual transformations of nature, he becomes the personification of joyful festivals in spring and pain and mourning during its winter decline. According to Jane Harrison, Dionysus is a variation of the Annual Demon and in the spring devotional acts in honor of the Demon, the beginnings of the Dithyramb orchestral chant are traced (Harrison, 1999, p.133/ 2003, p.15/ 1997, p.12).The word: « Ενιαυτός», derived from the additive " ενι-αυτώ", circles itself - returns to itself (Om. Od. A. 16). In this Thesis, we approach the symbolism of “Eνιαυτός” as a periodic unit, according to a dual interpretation, i.e. both as a “year” and as a wider periodic temporal unit of Pythagorean origin, referred to as: "Great Eνιαυτός" (Μέγας Ενιαυτός).According to the first interpretation, “Ενιαυτός” is symbolized by a Demon, who dies and is reborn as a spirit of the “Year”, when the Sun runs through the entire cycle of the Zodiac in one year, while according to the second interpretation, during the period of the "Great Eνιαυτός", an orderly resonance of the planets is born, which according to Plato composes a Harmonic Musical Scale (Plato Republic 617b 6-7) and the model of a primordial dance circle (Lucian, On Orchis 8). As mentioned by Plato, this long period measures the time interval between two consecutive identical positions of all celestial bodies in the sky when the relative velocities of all eight orbits are completed simultaneously and corresponds to a celestial musical scale, the "Eighth Harmony" (η «δια ογδόης Αρμονία»). The "circle of Eniautos" is also referred to in ancient Greek literature as a "sacred circle" symbolizing a "fenced place for orchestra in which dances take place, while the word: "chorus" denotes a multitude of people standing in circles without escape (Aesch. Aposp.407/Aristoph. Apos. 247).Based on the relevance of the "Great Eνιαυτός" to the birth of a harmonic scale and according to Herodotus' reports, on the separation in the fifty-member Dithyramb the part of the chorus and the part of the “Exarchon", by Arion, an additional objective of the present study, is to demonstrate the symbolism of the completion of the periodic unit "Great Eνιαυτός" with a reborn God coming at the head of his troupe as Leader Orchestrator ("Απάρχων Ορχηστής"). Hesiod in the 8th century BC is the first to refer to the phenomenon of the "Great Eνιαυτός", foreshadowing with its end the return of Zeus (Hesiod, Theogony 453-506).A harmonization process also takes place in the rituals of the Thraco-Phrygian Cybele with the musical instruments: rhombuses, cones, whirlwinds, "βέμβυκες", or "ίυγγες". The whirling of the organs, which is also identified with the birth of a whirling dance of the followers of the goddess, and curators («κουροτρόφων») of the infant God, who is also referred to as: «καρκίνου στρόβιλοι», or «κίρκινος κύκλος» (Plato, Laws 790d), is also related to the Bacchic cult and the Dithyramb. The events are also accompanied by pipe chants («αυλητικά») such as the chant: «σχοινίων», which imitate:• a. the track and the voices of migratory, or various birds, such as: « σχοινίων, ίυγξ, ή σεισοπυγίς, shallow, trochilos, οίστρος », or• b. a lament for the passing of the old Moon and the call of the new - this is also the interpretation of the later word: «καλάνδαι» (< lat. Calo luna novella)symbolizing the passions of the Demon «Eνιαυτός», in which a mortal god – “old time” is persecuted and a new one is welcomed. According to Pindar the «μέλος σχοινίων» is associated with the early phase of the Dithyramb. As demonstrated by Aristotle, the fundamental tone in the flutes: «βόμβυξ», is the opposite of a sharper tone, a high-pitched melody, which corresponds to the «oυλομέλεια του ουρανού», or the "Harmony of the Heavenly Spheres", defining a musical scale (Aristotle, After the Physics 3 1093 b / On the Heavens, B 290b 20, 291a 8 / On the Soul, 407b 33).Based on Pindar's references, or mythological interpretations, we deduced the affinity of the Dithyramb with the mournful fertility chants, such as the pipe chant « σχοινίων ». Also, we established their association with an early form of harmonic scale. Given the Pythagorean theory of the musical harmony of the celestial bodies carried in a circle, we confirm that the whirling dance of the followers of Mother Earth, or the “Oestrus Swirling Sound Dance” («οιστροδίνητη» και «οιστροδόνητη») of the Bacchae - Maenads of Dionysus, or the circular choral chant (" κύκλιο ορχηστικό άσμα") of Dithyramb, also referred to, as: «μύωψ βοηλάτης κινητήριος» that raises «oestrus» and «voice» (Aeschyl. Suppl. 307 / Plat. Apol. 30Ε), reflect the orderly coordination of the harmonious movement of the heavenly bodies during the completion of the periodic unit of the Great One («Μέγας Ενιαυτός»), which also symbolizes a primordial circular dance also referred to as: "sacred circle" («δια της σφαίρας όρχησις») (Αth. 14D /Lucian, The Dance 8 / Pindar Ο. 13,26), «μύωψ» also means: « oestrus», and «voice» (βοή) means: « βοήθεια < βοή+θεού, επικουρία, θεραπεία θεού»."Lucian also refers to the conjunction of the planets and the position of the stars as the source of creating a dance that follows the heavenly positions (Lucian, The Dance 7, 34). This means that the spiral labyrinth may also be a later creation that followed the movements of the stars which the Cretans turned into dance- movements, that were then captured in lines creating the labyrinth (Xiroudaki, M, 2021, p.18). The elements above highlight, as the next exploratory goal of the Τhesis, the symbolism of the birth of a whirling - oestrus dance («οιστροδίνητο χορό») as a fundamental condition of existence («θεμέλια εστιακή αρμονική αρχή»), associated with a Harmonic Principle, or as a "self-motivated Principle", or a moving force that constitutes an inseparable inner characteristic of human nature. We investigate its spatial consideration as: «Hestia». From the point of view of Plato, the concept: « hestia» is attributed both as a fundamental essence, (“θεμέλια ουσία”) and as an impulse («ώθηση») (« εστία - ουσία – ώσις») (Plato, Kratylos 401a, d.). «Oestrus» is awakened in Socratic thought, as a mental passion and seduces into philosophical mania, divination, “βακχεία”, but also into an inner spinning through which the supervision of the divine is achieved (« Η ψυχή οιστρά και οδυνάται »), (Plato, Phaedrus 251 D).Investigating the spatial view of the concept of “Hestia”, we find, that through the inner swirl of being, a fundamental axis and a vortex center are projected. The embolization of an axis instead of a foundation, which allows the link between Heaven and Earth, but also the four directions of space with the center, is connected in ancient rites with the "ritual of orientation", through which a sacred space is inaugurated. (Heidegger, 2008, p.33), (Eliade, 1999, p.348) (Vernant, 1989 / Norberg-Schulz, 2009).Through the foundation of an axis, which one can also interpret as a navel («ομφαλός»), a Galaxy, or a pillar - Atlas, the transcendence of the human existence is realized by inaugurating the establishment of a «Hestia», which is also referred to, as: "μεσόμφαλη" Hestia with an «ομφαλός» in the middle. The foundations constitute a guarded Archive within the bosom of the Earth from which a new world grows and spreads, as the embryo grows from its navel. This is also the symbolic interpretation of the "μεσόμφαλη" Hestia (Eur. Mid. 396) as an epichthonian Altar («χθόνιος εστιακός βωμός») (Aesch. Ik. 372).«Hestia» also animates Mother Earth who embraces within her the human generations and the power of new vegetation and becomes the epichthonian goddess through whom the «οίκος» takes root on Earth, as the "spirit of the place" symbolized with the Demon One («Ενιαυτός») ("genius loci") (Vernant, 1989, p. 157), or with the “paligenesis of a god”. Clement of Alexandria writes: "The Pillar signifies the un-image (ανεικόνιστον) of God" (Clement Al. Strom.p.909), which is also attributed to the archaic depiction of Zeus - Dionysus (Mayassis S. 1964, Vol.2, p. 279 / Kouros, P. 1999, p. 239, 285) (Appendix 1, p. 300)Examining additionally the following cases:•Fertility rites of the Minoan Great Mother Earth Rhea, which are connected with harvest offerings to the dead ("panspermia") in the Cretan «κέρνοι», accompanied respectively by a circular whirling dance («κερνοφόρος όρχησις») of the Koryvantes, followers of Rhea, which took place in circular platforms at Minoan Knossos («κέρνοι προσφοράς» were found in mounds. This type of dance is believed to have been a preparatory act of the Eleusinian mysteries (Warren, 1984, p.321, 322) (Chapoutier F.1928). (Lawler, 1951) / (Xanthoudides, 1905)•Αncient customs of Etruscan rites of establishing an area dedicated to the Roman goddess «Hestia», as a «topos» of deposit of the harvest of the first fruits («απαρχαί») to the dead, which takes place based on a ritual circular demarcation and a primordial groove circle (sulcus primigenius) – The Pindaric reference of the circular choral chant of Dithyramb is: "βοηλάτης", which means: "driving oxen" and also indicates a threshing floor, as the most circular place in which the oxen thresh the wheat •The description of the early form of theater orchestra as a threshing floor. Such an area was established in the area of the Ancient Agora in Athens in the 6th century. e.g. (Oliver Taplin, 1988, p. 16 / Hourmouziadis, 1991, p. 48, 58 / K.J. Dover, 1989, p. 38 / Georgopapadakos, 1977, p. 97)•The consideration of the orchestra as a place of ancestors, according to Aristotle's phrase: "When the orchestras were covered with straw, the dances took place" (Arist. Prov.) ("Όταν καλύφθηκαν οι ορχήστρες με άχυρα έγιναν οι χοροί.."). This phrase testifies, firstly, that the orchestra is connected to a threshing floor and secondly, that the orchestra was a place dedicated to the primordial world of the ancestors, as the straws symbolize the dying ancestors, who need "catharsis" (Luke 3,17). The description of the overfilling of the orchestra with straw also gives birth to the principle of movement, which is rendered as orchesis, according to the ancient Greek meaning of the word: "σαλάσσω", which means both: overfill, or crowd, and vibrate. we are led to consider the relevance of the symbolism of the "μεσόμφαλη" Hestia with the circular space of a threshing floor, in which the oxen thresh the wheat, as a place for the performance of the circular “βοηλάτης” Dithyramb (Pind. O. 13,26), but also with an early form of orchestra also considered as a “seat of ancestors” («έδρα προγόνων»).Based on the above elements, we propose a harmonious design of the "μεσόμφαλη" Hestia with the “Galaxy” as a fundamental axis, also mythologized according to the Pythagoreans, as a “path of souls” (“οδός των ψυχών”). The design proposal that characterizes the "Galaxy circle", which is made up of four harmonically growing spiral arms, consists respectively of four central harmonic spirals of an "Ionic capital" ("μεσόμφαλη"), which mark in the four directions rotational symmetry and are drawn within a solar circle, that has emerged based on an orientation ritual. By applying the design method to the “μέλη” of the ancient theater of Epidaurus, their dimensions are verified, when the radius of the solar circle has a numerical value = 2Φ, where Φ = 1.625 cm (golden number). The orchestra structure of the theaters was usually about 20 meters in diameter just as the theater orchestra of Epidaurus has about the same diameter of 19.50 meters (Taplin, 1978, p.16). The reading design proposal is listed in detail in Appendix (2) of the paper. A final purpose of the present study is the investigation of the symbolism of the fundamental essence (“θεμέλια ουσία–εστιακή αρχή”) of a being, with the myth of the "thigh-born" (“μηρογέννητου”), or otherwise known as: “Διθυραμβο-γενούς” Dionysus and the attribution of this with the Aristotelian concepts of the "unmoved mover" (“πρώτον κινούν”, ή “κινούν ακίνητον”), or of "entelechy" (“εντελέχεια”) and of the “Self- Moving Soul“ (“αυτο-κίνητη ψυχή”) (Aristotle «On the Soul» 407b 30) (Appendix 1 “μηρογέννητος” Dionysus).We first match the symbolism of the fundamental essence (“θεμέλια ουσία – εστιακή αρχή”) of a being with the myth of Dionysus sewn into the thigh of his father Zeus and attribute it to the Aristotelian term: "unmoved mover" (“Πρώτον κινούν”). The "unmoved mover" is that which moves without being moved, is the first Cause of all changes, based on which a process passes from being "power" to being "energy" (από “δυνάμει ον” στο “ενεργεία ον”).Aristotle mentions that "...that which moves organically is at the point where the "Beginning and the Εnd" coincide, such as the joining point of an anatomical lock (joint)” (Aristotle, On the Soul, 433b, 15). As Dionysus is also mythologized as sewn into the thigh of a divine paternal model, we consider the young Dionysus and his father Zeus, as a dual unit which constitutes one: "unmoved mover ". Through myth, the death of the old Self and the birth of a new Self is symbolized, similarly to the sprouting of a new shoot from an aging rhizome, where a Beginning and an End also coincide. (Kerenyi, 1998, p.258). Secondly, we confirm the view of the emergence of a god, namely the "thigh-born Dionysus" («μηρογέννητος»), as an entelechy (εντελεχές) system, in which a rapid process of transformation, similar to complete biological phenomena, takes place, such as the larva into a butterfly, transferred to the symbolism of the awakening of the soul. The Aristotelian "entelechy" is defined as the completion of the process, through which a being from “δυνάμει ον” becomes an “ενεργεία ον”. In the entelechy, there is an integrated purpose, as completion (“το ον έσχε το τέλος του”). Contributing to the new birth of a god is the projection of a collective Soul (“συλλογική ψυχή”) of a past time (Harrison, 1999, pp. 56,66). This is probably the existential meaning of the double birth of Dionysus also called: «Διθυραμβογενής» (Lekatsas, 1999, p. 90, 91 / Orpheus/ Nonnos). The self-creation of organic systems may, finally, be connected to the science of the so-called "Emergence" (emergence, entelechy). On the authority of emergent systems theory, once there is a threshold accumulation of matter, which acquires an appropriate level of complexity, a system develops new laws that cannot be explained by the properties of its parts. The "whole is greater than the sum of the parts”. The theoretical biologist Stuart Kauffman identifies this process as a new one "divinity", which derives from the emergent system properties (Kauffman, 2010).In the Conclusions of the Research, we prove, that the circular choral chant (“κύκλιο ορχηστικό μέλος”) of the Dithyramb is born together with the ritual, which is formed based on natural periodic harmonic phenomena that occur in the fullness of time. Such an event constitutes, according to the stated point of view of the Thesis, the cosmological periodic unit of the "Great One" (“Μέγας Ενιαυτός”), that produces a Harmonic scale through the orderly coordination of the planets, but also the symbolism of a circle of primordial dance and space, referred to as: "Sacred circle". We also confirm that the analogy of the circular choral chant of Dithyramb with the harmonious arrangement of spiral natural forms had fallen into the perception of ancient civilizations and had been explicitly recorded in their symbolism. Therefore, the concept of the Dithyramb covers the requirements of a high symbolic order within the limits of Sacred Architecture. We also conclude that there is a reference of the ”ορχηστικό μέλος” of the Hymn to natural born sounds (“φυσικογενείς ήχους”), which have a harmonizing character. These sounds, which preserve in their verbal description, elements of their natural reference ( Ίακχος, ιαχή, ίυγξ, σεισοπυγίς < σείω + πυγή, «σχοινίων,..) are reproduced in primitive myths and fertility events of the early rural populations, symbolizing the periodicity of natural harmonic phenomena. They also have a spatial symbolism, which is related to the formation of a Labyrinth. We therefore prove the original proposition according to which the organization of the Dithyramb is directly linked to the spatial reference of the Labyrinth and the harmonic cues to which this reference refers. As the conclusion of the paper, it follows that the harmonic periodic phenomenon of the Great One (“Μέγας Ενιαυτός”) is an entelechy system that recycles itself, at the end and the new beginning of which, a heavenly harmonic musical scale and the symbolic pattern of a primal dance circle emerge and space. The birth of the “ορχηστικό άσμα” of Dithyramb constitutes the spatial and temporal dramatized metaphor (“δραματοποίηση”) of the Great One (“Μέγας Ενιαυτός”) leading to human deification (“θέωση”). The deeper essence of the special investigation of the Dithyramb chorus, therefore, refers to a transition from more general symbolic classes to their spatial projection and performance. The cultural practices in the scope of History are, after all, areas that are constantly contracted: welcoming, that is, conditions of transfer, or metonymy from one area of consideration, mental construction, and expression to another.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Year dc:date
2024

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Chatzigiosi, Kleopatra
  • Χατζηγιώση, Κλεοπάτρα

Subjects

dc:subject × 31

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/56346

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Chatzigiosi, Kleopatra; Χατζηγιώση, Κλεοπάτρα. To κύκλιο ορχηστικό άσμα του Διθυράμβου τον 7 ο αι. π.Χ.: μυθολογική και αρμονική χωρική αντίληψη. National Technical University of Athens (NTUA), 2024. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/56346