National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Μελέτη ομογενοποίησης με υπερήχους σε ζυμωμένα προϊόντα γάλακτος
Abstract
dc:descriptionOne of the most important aspect of food science is the discovery and creation of innovative techniques and methods to optimize production processes and food quality. Recently, there has been great interest, from the food industry, for alternative technologies that combine performance and efficiency with minimal processing and cost, but at the same time provide safe and high quality products. The application of ultrasound is an innovative food processing method that has low cost and low energy consumption, is simple, fast, non-toxic and environmentally friendly. Ηigh-intensity ultrasound, when propagated in food systems causes physicochemical changes comparable, if not more beneficial, to the results of established techniques applied for years in the food industry. In particular, milk homogenization by pressure, a method widely applied in the dairy industry, is a process with a result that, theoretically, could be effectively achieved with high-intensity ultrasound. The current study aims to evaluate high-intensity ultrasound as a milk homogenization method and, given it’s effectiveness, to integrate the method into the yogurt production process, in comparison to the already, commonly, applied two-stage homogenization method. In this case, cow's milk (raw) with a fixed fat content of 3,5% w/w, has been treated with ultrasound (frequency 20kHz) of different amplitudes, 150, 262, 375, 562 and 750W, for 10 min, and compared with conventional 2 stage pressure homogenization with pressure values of 10/5, 15/5, 20/5, 25/5 and 30/5 ΜPa. The various homogenization conditions studied here, were evaluated for their homogenizing effect based on the size (mean diameter) and distribution of fat globules, the emulsion stability of milk and it’s z-potential. In addition, the effect of these conditions on the total microbial flora and the population of lactic bacteria, the volatile components and the proteins of the milk were also studied. Subsequently, milk samples homogenized by the various conditions mentioned, were inoculated with conventional lactic acid culture Streptococcus salivarius subsp. thermophilus and Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. Bulgaricus and the course of their fermentation process into yogurt was analyzed, in terms of fermentation time, the maximum rate of change in pH and viscosity (μpH and μvisc respectively) as well as the duration of the lag phase of the same parameters (λpH and λvisc respectively). Following the completion of the fermentation process, yogurt samples were analyzed for their viscosity and texture characteristics (hardness, cohesiveness, adhesiveness and gumminess), their volatile components, their sensory profile and their microstructure. Finally, the homogenization conditions mentioned above, were utilized into the fermentation process of probiotic yogurt, with the probiotic strain Bifidobacterium animalis sub. Lactis in action and the fermentation parameters (fermentation time, μpH, μvisc, λpH, λvisc) as well as the yogurt characteristics (viscosity, hardness, cohesiveness, adhesiveness and gumminess) were measured. Milk fat globules decreased in size and showed a more homogeneous distribution than raw milk in response to all conditions studied. However, fat globules, in milk that had been homogenized by ultrasound, were more homogenously distributed, even at low ultrasound intensities, while in milk samples that had been homogenized by pressure, fat globules of bigger size were detected occasionally. Both homogenization methods led to milk fat globule size decrease and the stronger the homogenization intensity, either higher ultrasound amplitude or higher pressure, the smaller the milk fat globules. The mean diameter of fat globules in non-homogenized milk was 1.53μm. The lowest average mean diameter of milk fat globules achieved by pressure homogenization was 0.62μm (corresponding to pressure value of 30/5MPa), while the respective for ultrasound homogenization was 0.61μm (corresponding to ultrasound amplitude of 750W).Homogenization intensity and method had significant effect (P<0.05) on the milk emulsion stability. Pressure homogenized samples remained stable for 6-8 days, no matter the homogenization pressure value. On the other hand, ultrasound homogenized samples displayed higher variance of their emulsion stability depending on the ultrasound amplitude. Higher ultrasound amplitude led to milk samples remaining stable for longer times, from 2 days (corresponding to ultrasound amplitude of 150W) to 14 days (corresponding to ultrasound amplitude of750W). Homogenization intensity had significant effect (P>0.05) on milk z-potential. The more intense the homogenization treatment, the higher the z-potential value. Slightly higher were the z-potential values of the milk samples homogenized by ultrasound. Pressure homogenization led to up to 4mV increase (corresponding to pressure value of 30/5Mpa) while ultrasound homogenization led to up to 7mV increase (corresponding to ultrasound amplitude of 750W). Ultrasound homogenization caused significant reduction (P<0.05) in the total microbial and lactic acid bacteria content of the milk samples, in contrast to pressure homogenization that did not significantly affect the microbial flora. Higher ultrasound amplitude led to lower microbial content, maximum reduction of TMC achieved was 69% and maximum reduction of lactic bacteria content achieved was 73%, corresponding to homogenization with ultrasound amplitude of 750W. In the milk homogenized samples the following volatile components were identified: acetaldehyde hexanal, acetone, 2-butanone, 3-butadione, 2-heptanone, bicyclo[2.2.1]-hepta-2one, 2-nonanone 2-undecanone, butyric acid, octanoic acid, decanoic acid, hexadecanoic acid dimethyl sulfide, 1-buten-3-ene, 2,1-heptene and delta-decalactone. The concentrations of ketones, aldehydes and carboxylic acids, identified here, were greater in the milk samples homogenized by ultrasound, compared to the pressure homogenized samples, additionally higher ultrasound amplitudes led to greater concentrations of these compounds. The increase in concentrations of the compounds is attributed to oxidative reactions occurring in milk during homogenization by ultrasound. The milk proteins underwent partial denaturation during ultrasonic homogenization. The percentage of protein denaturation, depending on homogenizing ultrasound amplitude, ranged from 7.08% (corresponding to ultrasound amplitude of 150W) to 68,78%. (corresponding to ultrasound amplitude of 150W). In contrast, pressure homogenization caused minimal protein denaturation (<3%) in all pressure valued studied. High-intensity ultrasound, unfolds the peptide chains of proteins, exposing active cites of their molecules, therefore facilitating interaction with other molecules present in milk (proteins, milk fat globules) and improving the milk’s properties and functionality (increase emulsion stability, increase z-potential, create homogenous distribution of milk fat globules, increase gelation rate, leading to the production of yogurt with higher viscosity and improved texture characteristics).The evolution of the fermentation process of homogenized milk showed significant differences depending on the two different homogenization methods studied. Although the fermentation time did not show significant differences in response to the differentiation of the homogenization conditions studied here (mean value 295±10 min), fermentation kinetic parameters of (μpH, μvisc, λpH and λvisc) were significantly affected (P<0,05). μpH of milk samples homogenized by pressure had mean value equal to 1.50*10-3±1.05*10-4 min-1 the respective value of the ultrasound homogenized samples was 8.6*10-3±5.5*10-4 min-1. λpH of milk samples homogenized by pressure had mean value equal to 120±5 min and was not significantly affected by the pressure values. However, the λpH of the ultrasound homogenized samples were significantly (Ρ<0.05) shorter than the respective of the pressure homogenized samples. The higher the ultrasound amplitude of the homogenization the shorter the λpH, with the lowest value (24min) corresponding to the milk sample homogenized by ultrasound amplitude of 750W. μviscwas significantly affected only by ultrasonic intensity or homogenization pressure (P<0.05), with its values increasing as the ultrasonic intensity or homogenization pressure increased. λvisc displayed mean value of 130±17min for the pressure homogenized samples, while the ultrasound homogenized samples 124±12min. Ultrasound intensity and homogenization pressure had no significant effect on λvisc. Yogurt viscosity values increased in response to the increase of the homogenization intensity, either pressure value or ultrasound amplitude. However, viscosity values of yogurt samples derived from milk homogenized by ultrasound were higher than the corresponding values of yogurts derived from pressure homogenized milk. Viscosity values of the yogurt samples derived from milk homogenized by ultrasound ranged from 1.03 Pa*s to 2.65 Pa*s (corresponding to samples derived from milk homogenized by ultrasound amplitude of 150W and 750W respectively), while for the samples derived from milk homogenized by pressure ranged from 1.29 Pa*s to 1.55 Pa*s (corresponding to samples derived from milk homogenized by pressure 10/5MPa and 30/5MPa respectively). The hardness of the yogurt samples, derived from pressure homogenized milk ranged from 0.964Ν to 1.153 Ν (corresponding to samples derived from milk homogenized by pressure 10/5MPa and 30/5MPa respectively) while of the samples derived from milk homogenized by ultrasound ranged from 1.049Ν to 1.503Ν (corresponding to samples derived from milk homogenized by ultrasound amplitude of 150W and 750W respectively). Gumminess values the yogurt samples, derived from pressure homogenized milk ranged from 0.572 N*s to 0.726 N*s (corresponding to samples derived from milk homogenized by pressure 10/5MPa and 30/5MPa respectively) and of the samples derived from milk homogenized by ultrasound ranged from 0.580 N*s to 0.824 N*s (corresponding to samples derived from milk homogenized by ultrasound amplitude of 150W and 750W respectively). Cohesiveness values the yogurt samples, derived from pressure homogenized milk ranged from 0.517 to 0.547 (corresponding to samples derived from milk homogenized by pressure 10/5MPa and 30/5MPa respectively), and of the samples derived from milk homogenized by ultrasound ranged from 0.542 to 0.632 ((corresponding to samples derived from milk homogenized by ultrasound amplitude of 150W and 750W respectively). Hardness, cohesiveness and gumminess of the yogurt samples increased the more intense the homogenization conditions of the milk which the sample was derived from. Yogurt adhesiveness was not significantly affected by the milk homogenization (method or intensity) and displayed mean value 0.351±0.019 Ν*S. The microstructure of yogurts made from pressure homogenized milk had a foam resembling form, while gaps and discontinuities were also detected. In contrast, the microstructure of yoghurts from ultrasonically homogenized milk, especially at higher ultrasound amplitudes, was smoother, more homogeneous and continuous. In the yoghurt samples derived from milk homogenized by ultrasound and pressure milk, the same compounds were identified as those identified in the milk samples, plus 3-hydroxy-butanone and hexaenoic acid. Increased concentrations in yoghurt samples from ultrasound-homogenized milk compared to yogurt samples from pressure-homogenized samples were detected in the following compounds: acetaldehyde, 1-buten-3-ene, acetone, dimethyl sulfide, 1-heptene, hexanal, butyric acid, 2-heptanone, hexanoic acid, 2-nonanone, bicyclo[2.2.1]-hepta-2one, octanoic acid, decanoic acid, 2-decanone and hexadecanoic acid. In order to predict the total degree of liking (DOL) of yogurt based on the aromatic compounds it contains, a mathematical model was suggested using the least squares partial regression method (PLS) and the «leave-p-out cross validation» (LpOCV) methodology, the following compounds were selected: acetaldehyde, 2-butanone, 2-3-butadione, 3-hydroxy-2-butanone and D-decalactone (with pleasant aroma-taste characteristics), and hexanal, butyric acid, 2-heptanone, 2-decanone and hexadecanoic acid (with unpleasant aroma-taste characteristics), as parameters with the most significant effect. The sensory evaluation of the yogurt samples derived from milk homogenized by pressure and ultrasound involved the analysis of 37 characteristics in order to describe adequately their appearance, texture, mouthfeel, odor, taste and flavor. The results displayed significant differences (Ρ<0.05) between samples from pressure homogenized milk and from ultrasonically homogenized milk in texture, mouthfeel, odor, taste and flavor characteristics. Yogurt samples derived from milk homogenized by ultrasound scored higher in the positive texture and mouthfeel characteristics (cohesiveness, hardness, texture DOL) but scored lower on odor, and flavor characteristics, compared to samples from milk homogenized by pressure. However, the total DOL scores of all the samples, did not differ significantly. For the prediction of the total DOL of yogurt based on the odour, taste and aroma characteristics, a mathematical model was suggested, using PLS method and LpOCV methodology and the characteristics with the most significant effect were selected: whey odour, grass/aldehyde odour, burnt odour, yoghurt taste, milk flavor, whey flavor, oily flavor, grassy/aldehydic flavour and pungent flavour. The fermentation process of the milk samples homogenized by ultrasound or pressure by the probiotic culture of Bifidobacterium animalis subsp. Lactis lasted 192±12 min for all homogenization conditions studied. μpΗ of the milk samples homogenized by pressure displayed mean value of 9.48*10-3±3.1*10-4 s-1 and differ significantly with the μpΗ of the samples homogenized by ultrasound, the latter’s mean value was 11*10-3±7.4*10-4s-1. λpH of the milk samples homogenized by ultrasound ranged from 50min to 31min (corresponding to the milk samples homogenized by ultrasound amplitude of 150W and 750W respectively) and for the milk samples homogenized by pressure ranged from 66 to 56min (corresponding to the milk samples homogenized by pressure of 10/5MPa and 30/5MPa respectively). μvisc the milk samples homogenized by pressure displayed mean value of 4.72*10-3±0.27*10-4 s-1; but had significant difference (Ρ<0.05) from the μvisc of the milk samples homogenized by ultrasound, which ranged from 4.48*10-3 s-1 to 19.35*10-3 s-1 (corresponding to the milk samples homogenized by ultrasound amplitude of 150W and 750W respectively). λvisc the milk samples homogenized by pressure ranged from 82 min to 78 min (corresponding to the milk samples homogenized by pressure of 10/5MPa and 30/5MPa respectively), and for the milk samples homogenized by ultrasound ranged from 92min to 32min (corresponding to the milk samples homogenized by ultrasound amplitude of 150W and 750W respectively). The viscosity, hardness, cohesiveness and gumminess of the prebiotic yogurt samples were significantly affected (Ρ<0.05) by the homogenization method and the homogenization intensity (either pressure or ultrasound amplitude). Highest values of those properties were measured on the yogurt samples from milk homogenized by ultrasound. Additionally, higher homogenization pressure values or higher homogenization ultrasound amplitude lead to the increase of the viscosity, hardness, cohesiveness and gumminess of the prebiotic yogurt samples. Specifically viscosity values of probiotic yogurt samples derived from milk homogenized by pressure ranged from 1.02 Pa*s to 1.44 Pa*s (corresponding to samples derived from milk homogenized by pressure of 10/5MPa and 30/5MPa respectively), while viscosity values of probiotic yogurt samples derived from milk homogenized by ultrasound ranged from 0.95 Pa*s to 2.48 Pa*s (corresponding to samples derived from milk homogenized by ultrasound amplitude of 150W and 750W respectively). Hardness values of probiotic yogurt samples derived from milk homogenized by pressure ranged from 1.08 Ν to 1,208 Ν (corresponding to samples derived from milk homogenized by pressure of 10/5MPa and 30/5MPa respectively), and of probiotic yogurt samples derived from milk homogenized by ultrasound ranged from 1.049 Ν to 1.503 N (corresponding to samples derived from milk homogenized by ultrasound amplitude of 150W and 750W respectively). Cohesiveness values of probiotic yogurt samples derived from milk homogenized by pressure ranged from 0.617 to 0.632 (corresponding to samples derived from milk homogenized by pressure of 10/5MPa and 30/5MPa respectively), and of probiotic yogurt samples derived from milk homogenized by ultrasound ranged from 0.591 to 0.731 (corresponding to samples derived from milk homogenized by ultrasound amplitude of 150W and 750W respectively). values of probiotic yogurt samples derived from milk homogenized by pressure ranged from 0.671 Ν*s to 0.764 N*s (corresponding to samples derived from milk homogenized by pressure of 10/5MPa and 30/5MPa respectively), and of probiotic yogurt samples derived from milk homogenized by ultrasound ranged from 0.620 N*s to 1.099 N*s (corresponding to samples derived from milk homogenized by ultrasound amplitude of 150W and 750W respectively). Adhesiveness δεν not significantly affected neither by the method nor by the intensity of homogenization and displayed mean value equal to 0.445±0.02 Ν*S. In conclusion, high-intensity ultrasound has better homogenizing effect than conventional homogenization with two-stage pressure, achieving similar reduction in milk fat globules size, but a more homogenous distribution as well as emulsion stability of milk for longer period of time. In addition, high intensity ultrasound disrupt the cellular membranes of the native milk microflora, therefore unleashing in the milk enzymes and metabolites that can be utilized by added starter cultures and facilitate the latter’s growth during fermentation process. Also, cause partial denaturation in milk proteins, which favors interactions between protein molecules and other components of milk, thereby increasing their functionality and enhancing the homogenizing effect. As far as the volatile components of the mil are concerned, high-intensity ultrasound has a negative effect, as it causes the formation of compounds such as aldehydes, ketones and carboxylic acids, components responsible for of undesirable flavor in milk and subsequent dairy products. Utilization of ultrasound homogenization of milk in yogurt production, facilitates fermentation and coagulation of milk, resulting in yogurt with higher viscosity, improved texture characteristics and more homogenous microstructure but with unpleasant flavors.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
- Year dc:date
- 2024
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Sfakianakis, Panagiotis
- Σφακιανάκης, Παναγιώτης
Subjects
dc:subject × 12Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/56408