Back to search

National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)

Παραγωγή μίκρο/νάνο-γαλακτωμάτων με βάση το ελαιόλαδο και μελέτη των ιδιοτήτων τους

Abstract

dc:description

Micro/nano-emulsions are of particular interest in the food, supplement and pharmaceutical industries. Due to their small particle size, they can act as delivery systems of bioactive ingredients with high optical clarity, good kinetic stability and high bioavailability. However, achieving such a sufficiently stable structure against kinetic destabilization and oxidation makes it a challenge when formulating a structured emulsion. Water-in-oil (w/o) emulsions generally exhibit low stability due to the high mobility of water droplets, which can easily precipitate, flocculate or coalesce. Recent studies have confirmed that certain polyphenols contained naturally in olive oil affect both the kinetic and the oxidative stability of olive oil emulsified w/o systems. Their effectiveness in prolonging both the oxidative and colloidal stability of emulsions has been related to their surface-active properties and their ability to accumulate at the water/oil interface. However, there are very limited studies so far investigating the relationship between antioxidant activity and surfactant properties of these compounds in both model and real emulsion systems. The purpose of this thesis was to investigate the conditions for obtaining micro/nano-emulsions based on olive oil, as well as the effect of incorporating olive oil phenolic compounds of olive oil into them, seeking to investigate and reproduce the colloidal formations that are naturally contained in the recently produced virgin olive oil. Initially, the homogenization/preparation techniques and conditions that can lead to the preparation of micro/nano-emulsion with desired characteristics were investigated. Two micro/nano-emulsion preparation techniques were chosen at two exposure times (10 or 20 min): homogenization using a high-speed homogenizer at various rotation speeds (8000rpm, 10000rpm, 12000rpm), and homogenization using high-power ultrasound (150, 225, 300W). Tests showed that high-speed homogenization was more effective than ultrasonic homogenization. Despite the smaller mean droplet diameter achieved with ultrasound (45.6 nm compared to 114.4 nm with high speed), the use of ultrasound showed a high degree of polydispersity, negatively affecting the Emulsion Stability Index - ESI, (ESI%= 96-100 %, in contrast to high-speed homogenization ESI%=99-100%). The polydispersity index (PDI) with sonication was about 6 times higher than high speed homogenization. The turbidity and color of the emulsions varied accordingly with the PDI. The high-speed homogenization method at 12,000 rpm for 20 min was considered the best option for further investigation. Subsequently, a study was carried out to achieve w/o micro/nano-emulsion systems, based on refined olive oil, without the addition of a co-surfactant, but using food grade non-ionic emulsifiers (Tween 20, Tween 40, Tween 60, Tween 80, Span 20 and Span 80). This was followed by the construction of ternary phase diagrams with predetermined concentrations of emulsifier. Tests were carried out with the controlled addition of water to an oil-emulsifier mixture (titration) to determine the range of proportions of the three components that, by mixing them, can yield a micro/nano-emulsion. From this study it initially emerged that it is possible to prepare stable micro/nano-emulsions based on refined olive oil without the addition of a co-surfactant. In particular, Span 20 emulsifier was shown to have the most effective emulsifying capacity - addition of 27.3% w/w of this resulted in homogenization of 8.39% w/w water. Then, micro/nano-emulsions were prepared with specific emulsifier ratios (2%, 4%, 6%, 8% and 10% w/w) and 2% w/w aqueous phase ratio. 2% and 4% w/w Span 20 and Tween 20 ratios demonstrated 100% stability. The emulsifiers Tween 20, Tween 40 and Span 20 had the lowest Mean Droplet Diameter (MDD) values, with Tween 40 achieving the lowest MDD (45 nm at 6% w/w). Most emulsifiers showed low PDI (0.1-10.2). Micro/nano-emulsions prepared with Span 20 and Tween 60 had higher viscosity. Regarding the oxidative stability of the emulsions, it was shown that Span 80 showed the best protective effect, followed by Tween 80. Specifically, the Peroxide Value (PV) in (meqO2 kg-1) at the end of the observation period was 20.25 and 20.52 respectively for a 10% w/w emulsifier ratio in contrast to the blank which gave an PV value in (meqO2 kg-1) of 32.84 at the same conditions. Then, based on the most effective emulsifiers (Tween 20 and Span 20), the incorporation of the phenolic olive oil compounds (quercetin, apigenin, trans-cinnamic acid, and gallic acid in the aqueous phase at a ratio of 1% w/w) was studied, as well as their effect on the micro/nano-emulsions properties. As in the previous series of experiments, pseudo-ternary phase diagrams were constructed, and subsequently the kinetic and oxidative stability as well as the physicochemical properties of the micro/nano-emulsions were determined. It was concluded that all tested phenolic compounds except quercetin improved the quality characteristics of the emulsions. Specifically, in the emulsions containing gallic acid, the maximum aqueous phase concentration achieved in the prepared micro/nano-emulsions was 8.99 % w/w with the addition of 30.1% w/w Span 20, and 8.82 % w/w with the addition of 34.8% w/w Tween 20. The addition of the remaining phenolic compounds in combination with the emulsifiers Tween 20 and Span 20 had no significant effect on the phase diagrams of the studied systems. This study was followed by the preparation of micro/nano-emulsions with known proportions of water (2% w/w final emulsion) and emulsifier (0, 2, 4, 6, 8 and 10% w/w final emulsion) for each endogenous component. Gallic acid, apigenin and trans-cinnamic acid functioned synergistically with Tween 20 and Span 20 emulsifiers, extending their kinetic stability while improving their properties. The efficacy of phenolic olive oil compounds was: gallic acid (LogP = 0.7) > trans-cinnamic acid (LogP = 1.59) > apigenin (LogP = 2.1) > quercetin (LogP = 1.81). This ranking agrees with the order of their partition coefficient (LogP), except in the case of quercetin, leading to the conclusion that the amphiphilic nature of these compounds led them to be placed at the droplet interface and stabilize the emulsion. Quercetin due to its extremely low solubility in water was not considered effective and the micro/nano-emulsions in which it was incorporated showed low stability, high turbidity and mean droplet diameter values. Regarding the ESI index, better stability was achieved by the combination of the emulsifier Tween 20 at a ratio of 4% and 5% w/w and gallic acid incorporated in the aqueous phase. The lowest Mean Droplet Diameter (MDD) value achieved was 39.7 nm with the addition of 8% w/w Span 20 and gallic acid in the aqueous phase. Successively, a study was carried out on the preparation of micro/nano-emulsions using the emulsifier Tween 20 (0, 2, 4, and 6% w/w final emulsion), water ratio (2% w/w final emulsion) and as a continuous phase extra virgin olive oil or refined olive oil. The aim was to investigate the effect of the oil phase on the stability and properties of micro/nano-emulsions. The study showed that the prepared micro/nano-emulsions based on extra virgin olive oil were significantly superior in kinetic stability, as well as in oxidative stability, to those prepared based on refined olive oil. This was probably due to the increased concentration of micro-compounds contained in the extra virgin olive oil, which was used as a base for the preparation of micro/nano-emulsion. More specifically, micro/nano-emulsions were prepared based on the two oils with the addition of an emulsifier Tween 20 (2 and 4% w/w) and an aqueous phase of 2% w/w. Micro/nano-emulsions based on extra virgin olive oil showed a higher stability index, especially at storage conditions of 40 °C. The minimum MDD value achieved was 99.2 nm with preparation conditions of 4% w/w Tween 20 and extra virgin olive oil as base, compared to 110.7 nm based on refined olive oil. In addition, extra virgin olive oil as a base resulted in lower PDI values of the micro/nano-emulsions, which is an indication of greater stability. The turbidity values also varried accordingly. Micro/nano-emulsions prepared with refined olive oil had a lower initial PV than those prepared with extra virgin olive oil. This is because refined olive oil, during the refining process, is released from most of the substances that contribute to the formation of Peroxide Value. However, although an oil with an initially higher number of peroxides would be expected to oxidize at a faster rate than an oil with a very low concentration of peroxides, it was observed that the oxidation of micro/nano-emulsions with extra virgin olive oil progressed at a slower rate than that of micro/nano-emulsions based on refined olive oil. As an example, the emulsion prepared with 4% w/w Tween 20 and extra virgin olive oil had a PV value in (meqO2 kg-1) of 12.3 at the beginning of the study and at the end of the observation time at 40°C, the value evolved to 17.4. Respectively, the emulsion prepared with 4% w/w Tween 20 and refined olive oil had a PV value in (meqO2 kg-1) of 4.8 at the beginning of the study and at the end of the observation time at 40°C, the value evolved to 12.7.Next, an extensive study of the kinetics and oxidative stability of micro/nano-emulsions based on refined and extra virgin olive oil with emulsifier Tween 20 (proportions of 0%, 2%, 4% and 6% w/w), ratio of aqueous phase 2% w/w and addition of olive oil phenolic compounds (gallic, vanillic and syringic acids at a ratio of 1% w/w in the aqueous phase) was performed, which was framed by determining the physicochemical properties of the prepared micro/nano-emulsions as well as the surface tension of the individual phases. It was found that the micro/nano-emulsions based on extra virgin olive oil containing 4% w/w Tween 20 showed similar or even superior characteristics to micro/nano-emulsions based on refined olive oil containing 6% w/w Tween 20. The incorporated phenolic compounds of olive oil had excellent surfactant properties, significantly increasing the ESI% of the micro/nano-emulsions. Specifically, vanillic acid proved to be the most effective, followed by gallic and syringic acid. Micro/nano-emulsions based on extra virgin olive oil and 6% w/w emulsifier showed higher MDD values than those with 4% w/w emulsifier. Vanillic acid again proved to be the most effective, followed by gallic and syringic acids (smaller MDD value with extra virgin olive oil, 4% Tween 20 w/w and incorporation of vanillic acid in the aqueous phase). The PDI values also varied accordingly. The addition of the phenolic olive oil compounds resulted in a significant reduction in turbidity, with vanillic acid being the most effective. The turbidity values ranged from 135 NTU to 2551 NTU and corresponded to the micro/nano-emulsion based on extra virgin olive oil with the addition of vanillic acid and the blank emulsion without the addition of emulsifier and phenolic component, respectively. Extra virgin olive oil showed a lower surface tension than refined olive oil, which facilitated emulsion preparation. Also, the addition of the emulsifier Tween 20, further reduced the surface tension of the two oils. The addition of the three phenolic compounds of olive oil also reduced the surface tension of the aqueous phase, which confirms their surfactant properties. Gallic acid reduced the surface tension of deionized water by 17.9%, vanillic acid by 18.4%, and syringic acid by 19.7%. From these results, one could expect that syringic acid would be the most effective in stabilizing micro/nano-emulsions compared to the other two phenolic acids examined. However, ESI%, MDD, PDI and turbidity measurements showed that vanillic acid was the most effective followed by gallic acid. The oxidative stability study in conditions of accelerated oxidation of the above emulsions showed that the rate of change of PV of micro/nano-emulsions based on extra virgin olive oil was significantly lower than the one of the corresponding micro/nano-emulsions based on refined olive oil, due to the antioxidant micro-compounds naturally contained in extra virgin olive oil. The addition of the olive oil phenolic compounds to the aqueous phase significantly reduced the rate of change of PV of the studied micro/nano-emulsions. Specifically, gallic acid (k (d-1) = 1.2714) proved to be the most effective, followed by syringic acid (k (d-1) = 1.3445) and then vanillic acid (k (d-1 )= 1.3813). The conclusions of the oxidative stability study based on PV were confirmed by the rapid oxidative stability technique using the Oxitest® reactor. As in the PV study, gallic acid (IP (h)= 14.87) proved to be the most effective antioxidant component followed by syringic acid (IP (h)= 14.43) and vanillic acid (IP (h)= 13.66). Finally, the micro/nano-emulsions were studied in terms of the concentration of Total Phenolic Components (TFP) in accelerated oxidation conditions and the results were expressed as mg of gallic acid/Kg of emulsion (mg GAE/kg). At the end of the observation period for the micro/nano-emulsions prepared with extra virgin olive oil, gallic acid (95.1 mg GAE/kg) emerged as the most effective against oxidation followed by syringic acid (77.2 mg GAE/kg) and vanillic acid (61.7 mg GAE/kg). These conclusions are in agreement with the results of the PV study, demonstrating the direct correlation between the concentration of phenolic components and the oxidation of the oil. Finally, based on the previous conclusions, a study was carried out to develop 2nd degree mathematical polynomial models, using Response Surface Methodology (RSM), to predict the properties of the final micro/nano-emulsion (MDD, PDI, turbidity and ESI) as a function of the levels of the independent variables (of the ratio of emulsifier:2%, 4%, 6% w/w emulsion and gallic acid: 0%, 0.5%, 1% w/w aqueous phase). The resulting equations were found to be statistically significant with the R2 correlation coefficient equal to 0.993, 0.968, 0.997 and 0.989 respectively. The properties of micro/nano-emulsions were significantly affected by the ratio of emulsifier and gallic acid. Increasing the emulsifier ratio led to improved micro/nano-emulsions properties up to a ratio of 6% w/w. In addition higher proportions of gallic acid led to an improvement in the properties of the micro/nano-emulsions, verifying the surfactant properties of gallic acid. The micro/nano-emulsion preparation combinations incorporating gallic acid that can lead to micro/nano-emulsions with the most desirable properties are: 3.14-4.45% w/w Tween 20 and 1% w/w gallic acid for MDD, 2.95-4.56% w/w Tween 20 and 1% w/w gallic acid for PDI, 2.35%-5.21% Tween 20 and 1% w/w gallic acid for turbidity and 3.21-5.25% w/w Tween 20 and 1% w/w gallic acid for ESI. The results of this research provide information for the design and preparation of optimized n/e micro/nano-emulsions, with integrated bioactive olive oil phenolic compounds characterized by high stability and desirable properties.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Year dc:date
2024

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Polychniatou, Vasiliki
  • Πολυχνιάτου, Βασιλική

Subjects

dc:subject × 17

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/56409

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Polychniatou, Vasiliki; Πολυχνιάτου, Βασιλική. Παραγωγή μίκρο/νάνο-γαλακτωμάτων με βάση το ελαιόλαδο και μελέτη των ιδιοτήτων τους. National Technical University of Athens (NTUA), 2024. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/56409