Back to search

Athens University Economics and Business (AUEB)

Essays on asymmetric cost behavior

Abstract

dc:description

Asymmetric cost behavior (or cost asymmetry) is a rapidly and dynamic research field within the context of contemporary cost accounting research. The traditional cost assumption is based on the microeconomic distinction of fixed versus variable costs, where costs move mechanistically with changes in volume, without considering the effect of direction. However, the asymmetric cost behavior is an alternative pattern of cost behavior where managers have an explicit role in affecting cost behavior with their deliberate decisions. More specifically, cost asymmetry arised from deliberate managerial commitment decisions to reduce resources less than expected, in the case of an activity decrease. The empirical research on asymmetric cost behavior is typically divided into two main streams: (i) identifying determinants of the intensity and the direction of cost asymmetry, and (ii) exploring the consequences cost asymmetry on earnings behavior and other economic phenomena. The current doctoral thesis aims to expand research in both of these streams by addressing the following research questions: (i) How does financial distress impact the intensity of asymmetric cost behavior? (ii) Does cost asymmetry increase the likelihood of future business failure and (iii) Does cost asymmetry affect the economic efficiency of managerial decisions on working capital? The first two research questions align with the main research streams in the context of asymmetric cost behavior. The third research question aims to explore asymmetric cost behavior beyond the cause-and-effect dichotomy, suggesting that the manifestation of cost asymmetry may influence the dynamics of relationships developed through other economic variables within the framework of business organizations. Chapter II illustrates the literature review and states the research motivation of the thesis. The literature review section of the chapter analyses the asymmetric cost behavior phenomenon and reviews prior findings of the two major streams of the contemporary empirical asymmetric cost behavior research. Prior empirical findings are critically analyzed to state the research motivation. The research motivation section of the chapter documents the research significance of exploring specific themes that correspond to different streams of asymmetric cost behavior inquiry. More specifically, this thesis intends to explore if financial distress a possible determinant of the intensity and the direction of cost asymmetry, and if cost asymmetry has a predicting potential a firm to file for corporate bankruptcy or to be contact financial misconduct. Furthermore, this thesis attempts to explore the moderating effects of cost asymmetry on the relation of working capital management with operating performance. Chapter III emphasize on the effect of financial distress on the intensity of asymmetric cost behavior. Cost asymmetry refers to the different (i.e., asymmetric) response of variable costs between increases or decreases in the level of a firm’s operating activity due to deliberate managerial resource commitment decisions to maintain idle resources when the activity volumes decline. High levels of financial distress increase the cost of maintaining idle resource capacity, decrease the intensity of the managerial building behavior and managerial optimism for future sales revenues. As a result, financial distress is negatively associated with the intensity of cost asymmetry. Our data sample consists of 88,624 firm-year observations for US listed firms over the period 1990-2020. It seems that, on average, financial distress decreases the intensity of cost asymmetry of SG&A and operating expenses. Additional analysis corroborates the generalization of our main empirical findings including: (i) determinants of cost asymmetry, (ii) earnings management and (iii) additional firm-specific characteristics. Robustness tests confirm the negative relationship of financial distress with cost asymmetry under: (i) endogeneity issues, (ii) alternative econometric specifications, (iii) different levels of corporate governance and (iv) alternative measures of financial distress and cost asymmetry. Chapter IV explores the predictive potential of cost stickiness in financial reporting misconduct. Managers in firms with high-cost stickiness have increased motivation and opportunities to commit financial reporting misconduct. Increased cost stickiness negatively affects operating and market performance and undermines managerial financial benefits. Additionally, increased stickiness signifies intense agency issues that tend to be combined with weak corporate governance mechanisms. To empirically examine the ability of cost stickiness to predict the occurrence of Accounting and Auditing Enforcement Releases (AAERs), we employ a data sample of 41,061 firm-year observations for the period 1990-2020. It seems that cost stickiness increases the likelihood of financial reporting misconduct. Our empirical findings remain robust when we control for (i) the main drivers and alternative measures of cost stickiness, (ii) earnings management, (iii) the intensity of financial difficulties, and (iv) agency and managerial optimism issues. However, our empirical evidence seems more profound when firms experience high transitory earnings. Chapter V examines whether the intensity of cost asymmetry matters for bankruptcy prediction. An increased level of cost asymmetry implies increased requirements to finance a high level of adjustment costs due to high investments in prior period resource levels, decreased operating efficiency and negative market reactions. In addition, a high level of cost stickiness driven by intense empire building behavior consumes valuable resources and it signalizes weaker corporate governance mechanisms and auditing efficiency. For these reasons, we speculate that that the intensity of cost asymmetry tends to be positively associated with the likelihood a firm to file delisting for bankruptcy or liquidity issues. Using 54,468 firm-years observations of US publicly listed firms over the period 1990-2020, the chapter provides empirical evidence that the level of cost asymmetry is incrementally useful for bankruptcy prediction. Reported findings are more profound in firms experience small and medium current sales changes and in firms with high managerial incentives. Additional robustness tests reveal that our empirical results remain robust against: (i) the effects of financial constraints on the intensity of cost asymmetry, (ii) alternative specifications of cost asymmetry, and (iii) in partitioned samples, propensity-scored for cost asymmetry. Chapter VI investigates if cost stickiness is positively related with inefficient portion of working capital investments and has negative moderating effects on the relationship between working capital management and operating performance. It seems that the presence of asymmetric cost behavior has negative moderating effects on the relationship between working capital management and operating performance for a data sample of 63,495 observations of US-listed firms between 1990-2020. The empirical findings are confirmed in the case of a non-linear association between working capital and operating performance, and they are more profound when a firm experiences a decline in sales revenue within the context of an aggressive working capital policy. Different levels of earnings management, managerial ability, and expectations for growth potential do not seem to have substantial effects on our empirical findings.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Athens University Economics and Business (AUEB)
Year dc:date
2024

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Ntounis, Dimitrios
  • Ντούνης, Δημήτριος

Subjects

dc:subject × 8

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/56595

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Ntounis, Dimitrios; Ντούνης, Δημήτριος. Essays on asymmetric cost behavior. Athens University Economics and Business (AUEB), 2024. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/56595