Back to search

National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)

Ηydrophobically modified ethoxylated urethane (HEUR) synthesis: process intensification and insight into the structure- rheology relationship for waterborne coatings

Abstract

dc:description

This dissertation addresses key research gaps in the synthesis and application of Hydrophobically Modified Ethoxylated Urethanes (HEURs), which despite being well-established as urethane rheology modifiers in waterborne coatings, lack comprehensive scientific inquiry in certain crucial aspects. The primary focus is on addressing the shortcomings related to HEUR production processes and their rheological behavior across various waterborne systems. Four main areas of investigation have been identified: (1) examination of the sampling procedure for urethane rheology modifiers and the process conditions of the solventless one-step HEUR synthesis, which is the current industrial standard; (2) comparison of the benefits and limitations of one-step and two-step synthesis processes; (3) exploration of the potential of microwave (MW) heating for process intensification;, and (4) investigation of the structure-rheology relationship in different waterborne dispersions. HEURs are amphiphilic polymers which can be prepared by the solventless step-growth polymerization of PEG with diisocyanates and subsequently end-capped with hydrophobic mono-alcohols. First, a careful evaluation of the solvent-free one-step synthesis of HEURs was performed, focusing on both the sampling protocols for polyurethane (PU) testing and the effect of critical process parameters. Specifically, polyethylene glycol (PEG) moisture content, reaction temperature, mechanical mixing speed and catalyst concentration were investigated in terms of their effect on product quality. Results showed that the sampling method significantly influences the molecular weight determination and the chemical characterization of PU, with the solid method (analysis of a solid piece of PU) displaying molecular weights up to 115% higher than the in-situ method (direct dissolution of the PU melt into dry solvent) when determined by Gel Permeation Chromatography (GPC). This phenomenon was attributed to chain-extension between NCO-terminated urethane prepolymers and ambient moisture, leading to the formation of urea linkages and an extended polyurea structure. Additionally, the study revealed that the moisture concentration in the initial polyol plays a significant role in HEUR polymerization. Maintaining moisture content below the threshold of 1000 ppm was proven to be crucial to foster the primary urethane reaction while suppressing undesirable side reactions that could adversely affect the viscosity of HEUR aqueous solutions. Further investigation revealed that both elevated mixing speeds and higher reaction temperatures (within the range 80-110°C) lead to faster molecular weight development, albeit reaching the same molecular weight plateau. Notably, when the molecular weight of polyurethanes approaches 21,000 g/mol, the polymer turns into a viscous gel exhibiting the Weissenberg effect. At industrial scale, if this state is reached too rapidly, it could jeopardize the homogeneous distribution of reactants within the viscous PEG, leading to batch inconsistencies. Therefore, in the event of viscous polyurethane polymerizations carried out in industrial-scale batch reactors, it is recommended to use moderate mixing speeds adapted to the specific polymerization scale. Given PEG's susceptibility to thermal degradation, maintaining reaction temperatures between 80-85°C is recommended, especially during extended polymerization periods in industrial-scale batch reactors. In addition, a comparison between the one-step (simultaneous chain growth and end-capping) and two-step (chain growth followed by end-capping) processes for HEUR synthesis was carried out, primarily emphasizing on the advantages and disadvantages of each method and highlighting their impact on the final HEUR properties. In the conventional one-step process (current industrial practice) there are inherent limitations in producing high molecular weight polymers due to the complex competition between end-capping and polymerization. We showed that the two-step method allows for much higher molecular weight polymers than the one-step method, while using less amount of toxic diisocyanates. Additionally, using the two-step method, the polymerization can be simply and efficiently controlled by the addition timepoint of the end-capping agent, which can be tailored to provide HEURs with a wide range of molecular weights and polydispersity indices. However, the efficient end-capping of high molecular weight polymers remains a challenge when using conventional mixing equipment in batch reactors, due to mass transfer and mixing limitations associated with significant increase in the bulk viscosity of the reaction mixture. To overcome these limitations, alternative, more efficient mixing technologies, such as reactive extruders, should be considered for the efficient end-capping of high molecular weight polymers. The application of MW irradiation as an alternative energy source for HEUR synthesis was explored due to the inherent heat and mass transfer limitations encountered in highly viscous systems. Given these challenges, the application of MW irradiation, known for its rapid volumetric heating capability, was investigated with the aim of reducing both the energy consumption and process time. We studied the effect of microwave heating on both the HEUR synthesis step and the initial pretreatment step of the reagents. During the reactants pretreatment step, MW heating can reduce the overall process time through tenfold faster melting of the solid PEG. However, in the subsequent PEG dehydration step, use of MW should be avoided, as faster degradation of PEG was observed compared to conventional heating (CH) dehydration at a similar bulk temperature. In the polymerization reaction, it was shown that both the polymer molecular weight, M_n, and the polydispersity index, PDI, of the HEUR prepolymer are independent of the heating source when the same reaction temperature was applied. However, it was concluded that operation of the batch reactor in a rapid unsteady-state (transient) temperature profile, only attainable with MW heating, resulted in production of HEURs with comparable molecular weights to those produced via isothermal CH experiments at process times multifold lower (4 min in MW vs. 45 or 120 min in CH at a temperature of 110 °C and 80 °C, respectively), due to the rapid thermal response of the polymerization mixture under MW irradiation. A comparison of the energy requirements of the transient MW heating process and the isothermal CH one (at comparable mean temperatures) shows that the former one needs approximately 3 times less energy to achieve the same molecular weight polymer, due to the shorter processing times (and subsequently lower heat losses to the surroundings) and the elimination of the additional energy needed to heat up the heat transfer fluid. Acknowledging the academic and industrial need for deeper understanding of the rheological properties of urethane thickeners, the effects of hydrophilic and hydrophobic segments of HEURs on the rheological properties of various waterborne dispersions, including aqueous solutions, latex-based emulsions, and commercial waterborne paint formulations were investigated. Utilizing both experimental and computational methodologies significant insights were gained in this area that can help advance the transition from empirical to systematic optimization of rheological performance of paints. Linear HEUR thickeners with different hydrophilic and hydrophobic segments were synthesized through a controlled one-step polymerization process by employing PEGs with molecular weights ranging from 2000 to 10,000 g/mol, resulting in HEUR molecular weights ranging from 8,000 to 33,000 g/mol. To investigate variations in molecular weight, we used HMDI-C8 as the terminal hydrophobic group. To investigate the effect of hydrophobic segment, we selected a HEUR molecular weight of 23,000 g/mol. Utilizing diisocyanates, such as HMDI, IPDI and HDI, we standardized the end-capping with C8. When mono-alcohol lengths were altered (C6 to C12), HMDI was retained as diisocyanate linker. The rheological analysis demonstrated a significant influence of the hydrophobe’s structure on HEUR behavior across all studied formulations. Notably, HEUR samples with increased terminal hydrophobicity, particularly the P8-HMDI-C12, exhibited strongly pseudoplastic behavior in all formulations studied. In paint formulations, these structures demonstrated rapid structural regeneration and high TI values resulting in enhanced sag resistance. However, these benefits were offset by compromised leveling properties. In contrast, HEURs with less effective hydrophobic segments (P8-HDI/IPDI-C8 and P8-HMDI-C5/C6) displayed Newtonian rheological behavior and the corresponding paint formulations showed slower structural regeneration with superior leveling but worse anti-sag performance. Regarding the hydrophilic segment, gradual increase in HEUR molecular weight up to 23,000 g/mol resulted in marginal viscosity changes in aqueous solutions, while a pronounced viscosity increase was observed with a molecular weight of 33,000 g/mol. In latex emulsions, lower molecular weight HEURs (8000 g/mol) displayed extended flocculated regions, a trend that appeared to be diminished with a 14,000 g/mol HEUR and absent with a 23,000 g/mol HEUR. In paint formulations, molecular weights of 14,000, 18,000, and 23,000 g/mol exhibited similar rheological response in paint formulations, but a molecular weight of 33,000 g/mol deviated, showing a shift towards higher viscosities and solid-like properties. To complement and rationalize the experimental findings, coarse-grained molecular dynamics (CG-MD) simulations were utilized to explore HEUR micellar morphology and effectively capture the spontaneous micelle formation in aqueous solutions. Guided by the DBSCAN algorithm and Monte-Carlo techniques, metrics, such as the volume of the hydrophobic cluster, the total micellar volume, the aggregation number (Nagg), and the number of interconnected chains (Nbridged) with other micelles were employed. By performing CG-MD simulations for various concentration values in aqueous solutions, we observed variations in the micellar network density correlating with experimental viscosity trends, while as the hydrophilic length of HEUR increased, the micellar volume continued to grow, in alignment with observed experimental viscosity changes.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Year dc:date
2023

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Tzortzi, Ioanna
  • Τζώρτζη, Ιωάννα

Subjects

dc:subject × 14

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/56613

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Tzortzi, Ioanna; Τζώρτζη, Ιωάννα. Ηydrophobically modified ethoxylated urethane (HEUR) synthesis: process intensification and insight into the structure- rheology relationship for waterborne coatings. National Technical University of Athens (NTUA), 2023. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/56613