Back to search

University of the Aegean

Regional unevenness and youth not in employment education or training (NEET) in the Mediterranean European South: analysing the relationship between regional resilience and youth workfare policies amid successive crises

Abstract

dc:description

The socio-economic reforms that have been gradually implemented in recent decades and accelerated by the recent and successive crises have had a significant impact on the economy and society. The impact of these crises has been very strong on youth labour markets, especially in the European Mediterranean South, with the main characteristics of high entry difficulties into the labour market, increasing labour flexibility and precariousness, and the inadequacy of targeted policies. In particular, youth unemployment, which reached its highest level since the founding of the European Union (EU) in 2013, has led the Union to introduce the acronym 'NEET' (Not in Employment, Education or Training) to emphasise young people who are not in employment, education or training. The vulnerability of young people is not only due to whether they are in NEET status, as young women/young workers who are in involuntary flexible employment are also in a difficult or precarious situation. The decline in wages, the increase in poverty and the more intensive flexibilisation of employment relationships, which was introduced mainly after the 1970s - and increasingly since the 1990s - with the formal aim of reducing unemployment by adjusting the size of the workforce to the fluctuations of the economic cycle, have obviously led to a considerable precarisation of young people and continue to do so.In order to address to some extent the problems in youth labour markets caused by the recent Great Recession, EU Member States have committed to implementing the Youth Guarantee (YG) Action Plan. This plan is part of the EU Youth Strategy 2010-2018 and follows the recommendation of the European Council (April 2013). The aim of the action plan was to ensure that all young people under the age of 25 receive a high-quality offer of employment, further education, an apprenticeship or a traineeship within four months of becoming unemployed or leaving formal education. After the first pandemic shock, the Youth Guarantee was replaced in 2020 by an extended version to contribute more effectively to the creation of employment opportunities (and employability) for young people (up to 29 years old), as the effects of the pandemic were added to an already unfavourable socio-economic context. This is particularly the case in the southern regions of the European Mediterranean. This Youth Employment Guarantee policy builds on the workfare policy (employment - social assistance or welfare to work) and includes a wide range of support measures that serve as an umbrella for young people's transition to adulthood, with controversial results. European policies have also put the skills of the labour force, and young people in particular, at the heart of the challenges of twin transitions (i.e. digital transition and energy transition), which have accelerated following the pandemic and the 2022 energy crisis. Concepts such as reskilling and upskilling are key factors in the current political debate on the digital and energy transitions. However, as skills development is an inherently social process created and maintained by hierarchical power relations within and outside the labour market, exaggerated expectations of the role of skills and the opportunities they create in the labour market need to be reconsidered within a critical theoretical and methodological framework. This thesis is written in English and follows the thesis-by-publication model. The main body of the thesis is divided into eight different chapters (including the introduction) and includes three chapters in the Appendix with additional research material, results and the survey questionnaires. More specifically, the main body of the thesis consists of articles that are either published or forthcoming, while the questionnaire and the questions for the semi-structured interviews with labour market and Youth Guarantee experts are at the end. On the level of theoretical contribution, the thesis follows the basic principles and concepts of Political Economic Geography and Evolutionary Economic Geography. On this basis, this thesis explores the uneven geography of youth precarity through different but previously unconnected concepts such as resilience and the concept of workfare. These concepts, considered in the light of Geographical Political Economy and Evolutionary Economic Geography, recognise the hegemonic role of capitalism but also highlight the constant reproduction of socio-spatial inequalities. Adaptability, resilience, path dependency, institutional context and spatial 'lock-in' phenomena thus aim to emphasise the ways in which geographical configurations of economic activity emerge and change over time, as well as the processes and mechanisms that are 'evolutionary' in nature. However, although the concept of workfare analyses the importance of social institutions for the economy and society, in this work it places great emphasis on the socio-spatial inequalities that it reproduces. Thus, the labour market is considered as a complex geographical space in which it depends on social origin, geographical location and economic power, rather than an abstract space occupied by autonomous individuals who have equal opportunities. In this context, this thesis does not consider the role of skills, education and possible maladjustment in the light of market-orientated theories (e.g. human capital theory), where the idea of self-investment in the form of education makes graduates responsible for individual success or failure. The role of skills and education confirms the importance of the field and political economy, as the thesis emphasises that skills and work are constantly influenced by broader processes, including demographic and socio-economic changes, institutional arrangements and the field of social reproduction. The thesis aims to i) examine the uneven geography of youth precarity of young NEETs in the Mediterranean South of Europe and ii) provide a spatially sensitive conceptual framework for the interaction between youth guarantee policy, labour flexibilisation and (high/low) regional resilience. In particular, an integrated cross-regional analysis will analyse the profile and distribution of NEETs (young people not in employment, education or training), the prevalence of precarious forms of flexible employment among young people (see temporary and part-time jobs) and the role of skills and education. At the same time, the impact of recent and far-reaching EU policy on youth employability (see Youth Guarantee Action Plan) are analysed. Through this analysis, the paper attempts an empirically grounded conceptualisation of precarity in the youth labour market by examining the ability of youth labour markets to withstand shocks by 'bouncing back', 'moving on' or simply remaining in a state of 'delay', and by introducing the Youth Guarantee into the broader context of workfare and its link to precarity. In this way, the trajectory of precarity in youth labour markets is ultimately decoded through the relationship between regional resilience and workfare. In doing so, this thesis contributes to i) a thorough comparative and cross-regional analysis of youth unemployment, inactivity and precarity in the Southern Mediterranean region of the EU for the post-Great Recession period and ii) a comparative theorisation and synthesis of two previously unconnected pieces of literature: regional resilience and the politics of workfare. The key questions of this thesis are:1. To what extent is there a problem in regional youth labour markets? What role do young NEETs, flexibilisation and precarity play?2. How does Youth Guarantee affect the (unsuccessful) transition from youth to adulthood and what role do flexible employment relationships and qualifications play?3. What impact does workfare policy have on young people? What factors determine the interaction between workfare and (high/low) labour market resilience for young people? The above research questions are intended to fill a number of gaps and contribute to topics that have not yet been systematically and thoroughly researched. In particular, while there are studies on workfare policies in the post-Fordist era and more recently, these focus on countries outside the EU South (i.e. countries such as the US, the UK, Denmark and the Nordic countries) that have traditionally developed such policies. Moreover, empirical studies that focus on recent youth policy programmes in the EU South do not critically relate their findings to the broader context of workfare, nor do they adopt a spatially sensitive perspective. As a result, studies on youth have sometimes overlooked possible links to regional resilience, while studies on regional development have also failed to consider the resilience and precariousness of vulnerable youth labour markets and issues related to skills and labour force training. Furthermore, while there are several analyses of resilience and 'regions left behind', there have been no analyses linking youth labour market resilience to employability measures. Therefore, this is the first English-language work to systematically analyse and conceptualise the spatially sensitive challenges of youth precarity in the Mediterranean South of the EU based on a comprehensive review of relevant publications. Methodologically, this thesis utilised a mixed methods approach, collecting quantitative and qualitative data through secondary sources and fieldwork to allow for a more comprehensive interpretation of the results. In terms of structure, it begins with the theoretical framework (Chapter 1), continues with the empirical analysis (Chapters 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6) and concludes with a final chapter (Chapter 7) highlighting the challenges that have arisen throughout the research, analysing the main findings and identifying new challenges due to recent events (the pandemic, the Great Recession and the twin transitions) that suggest new topics for further research, while the two chapters in the appendix conclude the research. Specifically, the theoretical-conceptual part of the thesis places youth guarantee policy in the broader context of workfare, showing how these youth policies and precarity influence each other and how the relationship between resilience and these policies is shaped. It shows that the integration of workfare into youth labour markets creates a 'symbiotic' relationship with precarity and maintains a reserve army of young workers who 'alternate' between unemployment, workfare offers and underemployment. Moreover, the relationship between regional resilience and youth workfare policies appears to be particularly sensitive geographically and temporally. In this sense, resilient youth labour markets in tourism-dependent regions develop a weak relationship with workfare policies, but have a strong relationship with precarity. However, resilient labour markets in regions with a high international division of labour and a strong institutional network have a strong relationship with these policies, which can lead to successful transitions for young people. In contrast, 'left-behind' and remote regions that have struggled with successive crises or prolonged recessions are strongly associated with workfare provision and precarity. A closer look at the timing of the implementation of these measures shows that the ability to withstand unforeseen shocks is linked to the return of social assistance and the freezing of workfare. Addressing the post-pandemic need for good and well-paid jobs can lead to a more promising future, especially in less resilient youth labour markets. In the following chapters, the thesis presents the empirical research. First, secondary data on young NEETs at regional level (NUTS II) and interviews with key labour market informants are analysed to investigate the relationship between young people not in employment, education and training and regional resilience. In order to analyse the problems associated with youth unemployment and inactivity in depth, this thesis conducts a purely qualitative study in the form of interviews with young NEETs or young people who move between unemployment and underemployment. Secondary data at regional level (NUTS II) on both total employment and precarious forms of flexible employment (see part-time and temporary work) are then evaluated to analyse the response of different forms of youth employment to successive crises (i.e. from the 2009 crisis to the COVID-19 pandemic period). After the in-depth examination of the conditions of youth labour markets in the EU Southern Mediterranean, the empirical part dealt with the assessment of the impact of the European Youth Guarantee policy, using secondary data complemented by interviews with key informants of this policy. The empirical part was rounded off by analysing secondary data at regional level (NUTS II) on the underlying explanatory factors for the spatial distribution of skill levels of highly skilled or educated workers. The main results of the empirical analysis clearly highlighted the current challenges for youth labour markets. First, the results showed whether youth labour markets in the Mediterranean South of the EU were able to withstand the successive crises by moving 'backwards or forwards', in other words, by moving towards a more sustainable and upward growth path or by remaining on a path of regression and 'falling behind'. The first key factor that has determined the low resilience of regional youth labour markets is the persistent fragmentation of the labour market, which is related not only to the fragmentation of the production structure but also to different working conditions. This means that some workers enjoy stable and secure careers with good job prospects, while others face unstable employment, insecure incomes and poor job prospects. As has been noted, the strong focus of island regions on the tourism sector and flexible but precarious employment was a form of 'adaptive resilience' during the debt crisis. Subsequently, however, this tactic left youth labour markets vulnerable to the 'unpredictable shock' of the pandemic. The dependence on local characteristics related to the history and geography of places has also had a major impact on changes in youth employment and unemployment. Diversified economies, infrastructure networks and local institutions play an important role, as do public sector labour markets and low-productivity agriculture. Rural regions in particular, which are 'lagging behind' and also use the agricultural sector as a 'safety net', are unable to create growth paths. The structural deficits of some economies due to their position in the binational division of labour have also shaped the resilience of youth labour markets. For example, regions that are more favourably 'positioned' in terms of the international division of labour have been able to 'absorb' the negative effects of the recession. Finally, informal practises linked to established social norms and the multidimensional behaviour of different actors in the regions under study are also an important factor for resilience. Informal employment, which is widespread in the South of the EU, is not only statistically biassed, but is also linked to social norms and the role of the family. Thus, informal employment practises and small and family businesses could be a barrier to the integration of young people into local labour markets due to the prevalence of precarious employment practises and low career development prospects. The role of non-standard employment relationships in the resilience of youth labour markets is also crucial. Flexible forms of employment, especially precarious ones, help to cushion the fluctuations of the business cycle (as young people can be easily hired and fired depending on the needs of the economic cycle), especially in the more affluent regions, but also provide a reserve for labour markets dependent on tourism and those 'left behind'. The study has also shown the importance of multi-spatial interlinkages for the resilience of youth labour markets. For example, the role of national trends in shaping the resilience of youth labour markets in times of recession was found to be important, while regional characteristics played a crucial role in shaping the recovery path of many regions (the recovery phase between the debt crisis and the pandemic recession).Qualitative research with NEETs and the underemployed has highlighted issues related to the structural functioning of youth labour markets and, secondarily, to the actions of young people themselves. In particular, the analysis showed that most participants wanted employers to be incentivised to hire or train young people, but also that young people try to determine their lives through their actions. In this context, most participants felt that they found or at least tried to find a job through personal contacts rather than through state institutions. They believe that the state does not help them to plan their future and that the recession in the economy is exacerbating the employability problems they face. The study on the impact of the Youth Guarantee in the regions of Spain and Italy highlighted the problems related to the support that this policy offers young people entering the labour market and the conditions that characterise its implementation at regional level. The study concluded that employability programmes, although designed to combat youth unemployment and precarious employment, can actually exacerbate job insecurity. The study highlighted significant problems related to poor management of the register of beneficiaries, top-down planning, lack of specificity at regional level and ineffective monitoring of the implementation of these programmes. The ineffective design and problematic implementation of these programmes in terms of improving the long-term integration of young people into the labour market is in many ways due to the temporary (often low-paid or part-time) employment promoted by these policy. The study confirms that the 'supply-side' nature of this policy largely exacerbates precariousness while suffering from institutional and operational weaknesses. Finally, the empirical analysis has shown the uneven geographical distribution of low, medium and high-skilled occupations among highly skilled workers. At this point, it should be noted that the previous parts of the thesis focussed on the regions of the Mediterranean South of Europe, while this final empirical study attempts to spatially link the thesis to other European socio-economic and institutional systems in order to highlight convergences and divergences by placing the empirical research in a broader geographical context. A key finding of the research is that there is a clear equalisation of skill and education levels in capital and metropolitan regions compared to less affluent and 'lagging' regions. The results of the survey reveal five different but interrelated parameters that directly influence the distribution of skills and education: the economic dynamics of national economies, the characteristics of regional economic structures, the degree of urbanisation, local institutional structures and practises, and demographics. Consequently, human capital is shaped by many simultaneous forces, most of which are dialectically linked, but it is also - to the extent that it is integrated into production through quality and good jobs - a very important factor for regional development. The main findings of this thesis show how youth workfare policies and precarity influence each other and how the relationship between resilience and workfare is shaped. It appears that the integration of workfare into youth labour markets creates a 'symbiotic' relationship with precarity by maintaining a large potential 'pool of labour' (see reserve army of young workers or unemployed) that 'switches' between unemployment, workfare offers and underemployment. Moreover, the relationship between regional resilience and youth employment appears to be particularly sensitive to geography and time. However, this relationship is not considered within a narrow, 'supply-side' framework focussing exclusively on the market and the promotion of individual responsibility. Rather, it is conceptualised in terms of the sustainable transitions of young people into adulthood, arguing that the resilience of labour markets should be linked to the notion of quality and well-paid employment. The paper concludes that young people without work, education or training are inextricably linked to precarity, as they are part of the surplus labour force and thus form the 'youth precariat'. This link is particularly evident in countries such as Greece, Italy and Spain, which, following the severe effects of the 2008 crisis, pursued neoliberal development paradigms by cutting public spending, facilitating the free market and abolishing labour rights in order to reduce their budget deficits. These changes have irrevocably altered the world of work and, in particular, labour markets for young people. Although this research does not link the underclass to indigenous NEETs, it argues that youth unemployment and inactivity are largely linked to the social pathologies of the working class, where the precarity of the working/middle class has been instrumentalised to enforce capitalist aspirations. Thus, the prevailing insecurity in labour relations forces young people to either accept precarious forms of employment or to participate in training or employment programmes (workfare) in order to improve their employability. In many regions of the EU in the Mediterranean in particular, this labour insecurity did not just emerge as a result of the 2008 crisis, but existed much earlier. In many less developed regions of Greece, in the underdeveloped south of Italy and in the south-eastern regions of Spain, whose industrial structure was based on construction, agriculture and labour-intensive enterprises, informal employment was encouraged. Although unemployment rates were relatively low in the 00s (albeit without targeted European youth policies), the economy and labour market were not on an upward trend, suggesting that young people without employment, education or training, flexible forms of employment and all the challenges faced by young people are part of a structural problem rather than a parameter of economic fluctuation. In several regions, rates of young people out of education or employment were already high before the debt crisis and reached significant levels during the recession that have not significantly declined to date, suggesting that while they have increased due to the recession, they are not a direct consequence of the recession, but rather a pre-existing condition. In contrast, in the highly developed regions, which are not coincidentally close to Central Europe and have a higher status in the international division of labour, these rates rose during the debt crisis and fell significantly after the recession. In these regions, these rates followed a cyclical pattern with a tendency to return to the original low rates. The initial spatial inequality thus cumulatively led to ever greater cycles of inequality, which confirms the approach of cumulative causality. Similarly, the resilience of youth employment highlights important resilience factors such as structural deficits, the persistent fragmentation of the labour market, dependence on local specificities and informal practises linked to established social norms, as mentioned above. The impact of the crisis on youth labour markets in the Southern Mediterranean region of the EU is related to the above-mentioned factors, which have contributed to the different responses of these labour markets. In particular, the labour market in the tourism and island regions developed a form of adaptability by directing its resources towards the monoculture of tourism in order to survive the 2008 crisis. The price for this was the further optimisation of young people's work and the prevalence of low-skilled occupations. However, during the pandemic, this type of resilience was disrupted by external (and unforeseen) factors (e.g. travel restrictions and health insecurity). This interruption of seasonal work then led to resignation. In this wave, young people, especially Generation Z, are redefining values such as social justice and sustainability in search of better jobs and opportunities. In contrast, the youth labour market in the lagging regions of the EU's Mediterranean South is trying to survive not only the crises, but also the challenges of their ongoing decline. Youth labour markets cannot 'recover' or 'transition to new resilient situations' as they are dominated by low-skilled occupations and sectors. However, the concentration of the public sector in some of them acts as a safety net, absorbing very high NEET rates and employment losses. As a result, this long-standing process of geographical inequality in the Mediterranean South of the EU is more closely linked to these low-skilled activities than to deindustrialisation, as is the case for regions in the industrial North, where manufacturing has historically not flourished. The emergence of such places as sites of discontent reflects the intensification of social and spatial inequalities over the last decade, not only in the US and UK, where the term originated, but also in the regions analysed. Nevertheless, 'superstar" regions, more favourably positioned in the international division of labour and based on more dynamic industries, have shown a kind of absorptive capacity that allows them to absorb shocks and shift their labour market to another state or form, generally less favourable than before. These administrative and business centres often determine the position of the entire country within global value chains and represent the growth potential of their country. Highly skilled workers are concentrated in these locations, although in many cases this concentration is greater than their labour market can cope with. They therefore concentrate highly skilled people in low-skilled occupations, leading to great inequalities and intense competition even in the most dynamic regional labour markets, resulting in labour dualism. It is therefore clear that workfare policies have a negative impact on youth labour markets, which is directly linked to the structural problems faced by the Mediterranean South of the EU. However, these policies have so far failed to address the weaknesses of the youth labour market, despite the introduction of the youth dimension in EU policies more than twenty years ago. These policies do not seem to be a solution to the problems of unemployment, inactivity and precariousness of young people. Against this background, retraining or skills upgrading may not be able to integrate young people into the labour market if their underlying structural problems are not addressed. Instead, a targeted regional policy focusing on the sustainability of resources (and people) could support a more resilient youth labour market.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of the Aegean
Year dc:date
2024

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Emmanouil, Efstratia
  • Εμμανουήλ, Ευστρατία

Subjects

dc:subject × 18

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/56795

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Emmanouil, Efstratia; Εμμανουήλ, Ευστρατία. Regional unevenness and youth not in employment education or training (NEET) in the Mediterranean European South: analysing the relationship between regional resilience and youth workfare policies amid successive crises. University of the Aegean, 2024. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/56795