Πανεπιστήμιο Μακεδονίας
Η ποιότητα έλεγχου στην Ελλάδα μετά την εφαρμογή των διεθνών προτύπων χρηματοοικονομικής αναφοράς και των διεθνών προτύπων ελέγχου
Abstract
dc:descriptionThis thesis assesses audit quality in Greece using as measure the Type II audit error, which is defined as the failure of the auditor to issue a going concern audit opinion (GCO) for a client that subsequently declares bankruptcy.The starting point of the research is the financial year 2005, when the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) and the International Standards on Auditing (ISA) first implemented in Greece, and extends to year 2017, encompassing very important economic and political events that affected both Greek and global economy. During this period, Greece was at the top of European and global interest due to consecutive rescue loans received from the European Commission, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the European Central Bank (ECB), starting from May 2010, when the first memorandum of understanding (MoU) was agreed. Since then, Greece entered a long period of recession and political instability, being eight years under bailout programs, the longest period in Europe, facing the possibility of exiting European Union (Grexit) and becoming the first developed nation, in the 70-year history of the IMF, to fall into arrears, when, in 2015, missed a 1.6 billion euros payment.While in most financial crises, auditors are strongly criticized for being unable to protect the markets, in the case of Greece, audit firms have been assigned to be a major partner in the country's fiscal adjustment. It is of great importance, though, to examine the quality of the audits performed by the audit firms in Greece.During the period of the survey, thirty-eight (38) listed in the Athens Stock Exchange companies found to have filed for bankruptcy. The Type II audit error estimated to be 42,1%, (16 out of 38 had not received GCO), which according to international literature constitutes an audit failure, highlighting the low level of audit quality. This conclusion is getting even stronger, taking into consideration that, all of the bankrupt firms were in financial distress, following Chen & Church's (1992) criteria, most of them had negative equity and overdue debts and loans, whilst some of them were under negotiations for loan restructuring in order to finance the continuity of their operations. Furthermore, the performance of three of the most international accepted bankruptcy prediction models (Altman Z-score, Zmijewski and Ohlson O-score), producing accuracy rate from 84.2% to 86.8%, proves that the auditors were aware that the companies were facing going concern issues and they should have issued either an adverse opinion or a GCO.Following Mutchler (1985), stating that the issuance of a GCO is a two-stage process for the auditor: Stage 1: the identification of a potential going-concern problem andStage 2: the decision process for the type of audit opinion to be issued,eight (8) hypotheses and two (2) panel data logistic regressions models were developed in order to identify the factors determining the issuance of a GCO. Initially, a basic model was developed, to examine the first stage of assessing auditee's financial information, including rates measuring operating efficiency, profitability, liquidity and financial distress, which, afterwards, was further extended to include the factors that influence the auditor's decision process, including auditor’s and auditees’ characteristics and relationship (previous year’s audit opinion, size of the audit firm-Big4, tenure, size of the auditee). Additional sensitivity tests were performed: a) testing for interactions between auditor’s and auditee’s characteristics, b) changing Big 4 to Big 6, in order to include 2 audit firms with high market share in Greece, c) testing for outliers bias, d) testing whether auditor’s decision to issue GCO significantly differs between the periods before and after May 2010, when the fist MoU was agreed, followed by consecutive bailout programs and e) using a probability of bankruptcy model (calculated on revised Y model proposed by Giannopoulos & Sigbjornsen, 2019) as a tool to auditor’s decision making process, and additionally for the presence of endogeneity between the GCO and the specific rate.The sample consists of 2,236 observations, concerning the annual financial statements of 214 companies listed on the Athens Stock Exchange, from 2005 to 2016. In 293 observations the auditors had issued a GCO, whilst 1,658 observations concerned financially distressed companies.The results of the initial empirical model, examining the financial factors determining auditors opinion, reveals: a) a positive significant relationship between GCO and two consequent years of losses, reflecting the inability to generate operating profits, b) a negative significant relationship between GCO and rate reflecting liquidity (current assets to current liabilities), operational efficiency (operating cash flow to total liabilities, sales to assets) and profitability (return on assets) and c) no significant relationship between GCO and financial leverage. The results of the extended empirical model, including financial factors and factors affecting the auditor’s decision process, reveals: a) a positive significant relationship between GCO and the opinion expressed in the previous year, showing that the opinion issued is likely to be the same with the the one issued in the immediately preceding year and b) no significant relationship between GCO and the size of the auditor, where the audit by Big 4 does not seem to have an effect on GCO, and tenure, where it is found that being audited for many consecutive years from the same audited firms does not effect GCO. Concerning the size of the auditee, the results of the extended model showed no significant effect, however, when using, in the model, the probability of bankruptcy rate as a tool, and after controlling for endogeneity, it was found that there is a significant negative relationship between GCO and the size of the company, raising auditor’s independence matters, explaining, partially, the audit failure.Finally, after separating the period of the survey, into the pre-memorandum period (from 2005 to 2009) and the memorandum period (from 2010 to 2016), the results reveal a significant positive relationship with GCO, as expected, showing that in the memorandum period auditors chose in a greater extent to issue a GCO than in the pre-memorandum period.The general conclusion of this thesis is that the quality of audit performed by audit firms in Greece, is at low level, as reflected in the failure of auditors to issue a GCO in 42% of the companies that went bankrupt, even though they were facing significant financial and operational problems, which they were revealed in their financial statements. Contrary to the abovementioned conclusion and to the global criticism to auditors due to their involvement in financial scandals, the latest of which refers to advisory services to their client to avoid taxation, estimated to €50-70 billion yearly revenue loss in EU, both Greek and European Commission governments and state bodies have made audit firms partners in designing, implementing and auditing fiscal and tax policy. The results of the thesis concerning audit quality in Greece could be extended by: a) assessing the effectiveness of the involvement of audit firms in the fiscal adjustment of the country, related to the objectives set in the bailout programs, b) assessing the effectiveness of the supervisory authorities in assessing the quality of the auditors' reports and audit work and c) examining audit quality and the factors determining audit quality in Greece in the post-memorandum period (the enhanced post-memorandum surveillance period ended in August 2022).
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Πανεπιστήμιο Μακεδονίας
- Year dc:date
- 2024
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Daskalakis, Athanasios
- Δασκαλάκης, Αθανάσιος
Subjects
dc:subject × 37- Ελεγκτής / ελεγχόμενος
- Διεθνή Πρότυπα Ελέγχου (ΔΠΕ),
- Ελεγκτική εταιρία
- Σφάλμα ελέγχου τύπου ΙΙ
- Πτώχευση
- Γνώμη με επιφύλαξη
- Συνέχιση της δραστηριότητας
- Πρόβλεψη πτώχευσης
- Μνημόνιο
- Χρηματοοικονομική κρίση
- Ελλάδα
- Ενδογένεια
- (ΔΠΧΑ) - Διεθνή πρότυπα χρηματοοικονομικής αναφοράς
- Auditor / auditee
- International standards on auditing (ISA)
- International Financial Reporting Standrads (IFRS)
- Going concern opinion (GCO)
- Bankruptcy
- Financial distress
- Audit error type II
- BANKRUPTCY PREDICTION MODELS
- Financial crisis
- Memorandum of understanding
- Bailout program
- Greece
- Big 4
- Tenure
- Panel data analysis
- Endogeneity
- Οικονομικά και Επιχειρήσεις
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Λογιστική
- Χρηματοοικονομικά
- Economics and Business
- Social Sciences
- Accounting
- Finance
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/57135